Dressing up like 'Indians'

Nurses General Nursing

Published

taken in its entirety by request of website: http://www.nativecircle.com/ppdressingup.html

i will say this flatly - please do not dress yourself or your kids up

like 'indians'! although it should not be necessary for me to have

to explain why this is a no-no, i will elaborate briefly.... i have an

african american friend who told me that on several occasions

on halloween night he came to his door to find a white child who

was dressed up like a 'black' person, complete with painted face

and fake afro. he was never upset with the child, but did say he

thought the parents needed a swift kick in the rear! i also have,

as you can imagine with all the 'poca-haunt-us' hoopla, endured

countless cute little kids dressed up like 'indians' by their folks.

there are many problems with this. one big problem is that it

trivializes the american indian race. our traditional regalia is

much more than clothing. it is a sacred and personal spiritual

expression of our most holy ways. when we paint our face a

certain way, wear eagle feathers and design our incredibly

complex patterns bead, quill, leather, shell and so on, these

are all very holy and sacred interpretations of our spirituality.

to dress an innocent child in silly colored chicken feathers,

a brown paper sack and paint their face with mock 'indian'

designs is an insult to the sacred spiritual expressions of

american indian people. that having been said, i think it is

important to say that no one should ever 'dress up' like an

'indian', an 'asian', an 'african', or any other race. it is

simple common sense. to do this is to make a game of

somebody's ethnicity, to trivialize a race for the sake of

'fun'. by the way, a 'pilgrim' is not a race. *wink* so, it is

my hope that people will learn that it is insensitive and

just plain morally wrong to dress up like someone else's

race. may we all learn to be considerate of others.......

written by john two-hawks

Specializes in Education, FP, LNC, Forensics, ED, OB.
All persons should be respected without regard to race,

Totally agree with you here.

And, we shall agree to disagree with the other comments.

Respectfully,

Chi Chi, Native American Indian, Cherokee Tribe

Specializes in School Nursing.

Agreed. :smiley_abEnough of THAT!!!

Peace.

Specializes in ER, ICU, L&D, OR.
what if I had my kids dress up as Caucasians?

Are we forgetting that Halloween, outside of its religous background, is actually just a fun holiday, for kids and parents to enjoy without being taken seriously.

Specializes in 6 years of ER fun, med/surg, blah, blah.
Are we forgetting that Halloween, outside of its religous background, is actually just a fun holiday, for kids and parents to enjoy without being taken seriously.

Actually there are several ethnicities among the "Caucasians", celtic, middle eastern, nordic, slavic, mediterranean, etc., so why pick one group & be offended if people, for a costume party, want to dress up as someone other than themselves. It supposed to be for fun or to learn about another's heritage. Halloween, All Hallows Eve was traditionally a Celtic holiday celebrating the end of the year, before winter descended & the dearly departed were said to roam that night. They were to be treated to food snacks & the Irish lit carved turnips with candles to light their way @ night. When the potato famine hit Ireland & the survivors landed in the US, they used pumpkins instead or turnips, our "American" jack o lanterns. Pumpkins are a traditional New World food. Is it then sacrilegious to carve up a pumpkins then for Oct. 31? Costumes were to fool the dead so the living wouldn't be brought back with them when they returned to their "other dimension".

Specializes in ER, ICU, L&D, OR.

I like carving them up and cooking them into pumpkin pie, smells so good when they are cooking

I don't see anything wrong with it. I am not a Native American, I am Asian; sometimes I see women wear Americanized version of a traditional Chinese dress, or a kimono. I think it's a great way to start a conversation, and just do something different. My husband (Caucasian) wore a traditional hat from my country to a dinner party, it started questions, and people were eager to learn about my heritage and culture. I think it's a positive thing.

I think people in general do understand that there is much more to a Native American culture than just a couple of feathers and a Disney movie. However, an "average" american is probably not going to go researching the meaning of different beading tecniques and such.

I live in Montana, and surrounded by 7 Indian Rezervations, Crow and Blackfeet being the closest to my town. I knew nothing about the Indian heritage, traditions or culture until I met a girl, who showed me a pattern on her keychain, that reminded me of my culture, and the patterns on our wedding dresses.

A few years ago my daughter wanted to be Sacajawea for Halloween. She was 5 at the time, and her favorite book that we read over and over was about the life of Sacajawea. She was very excited to dress up like her hero on Halloween, and was very annoyed when people kept calling her Pocahontas.

I'm usually sensitive about these things, so I had no idea it would have been offensive to Native Americans. I'm sure I didn't get the dress right, but my daughter learned a lot about this courageous woman and wanted to represent her. I think it would have been difficult to explain why it might be offensive to other people.

Thanks for this post. Too many non natives are really naive when it comes to our people. They assume we all live in teepees, wear regalia around the house and say, "How". I can't even count the number of times I have been called Pocahontas.

Most of the time I ignore them, but there are times I would just like to yell at them.

Specializes in Acute rehab/geriatrics/cardiac rehab.
Thanks for this post. Too many non natives are really naive when it comes to our people. They assume we all live in teepees, wear regalia around the house and say, "How". I can't even count the number of times I have been called Pocahontas.

Most of the time I ignore them, but there are times I would just like to yell at them.

This brings to mind an old Sesame Street scene (cartoon) in which a little Caucasian child is dressed up like a Native American (stereotypical) complete with bows, arrows, etc. and the child is saying "How" or something like that and the other little boy who is dressed in a regular shirt and pants says "Real Indians don't talk like that" and the kid who is dressed as a "supposedly" Native American says "Oh..yeah, how would you know". And the other little boy says "Because I'm an Indian". I found a link here: (having been born in Oklahoma, I know that sterotypes of the typical "Indian" are usually false..... See the video below:

http://www.zippyvideos.com/9082450714596096/vintage_sesame_street_-_indians_dont_talk_like_that/

Specializes in geriatric and military hospital.

i think alot of people also do not get what halloween is actually is most just think it is a day to dress their kids up but that is not the sole reason for the holiday.

+ Add a Comment