Does it make me a bad nurse if I'm not book smart?

Nurses General Nursing

Published

Nursing has been in my family. My own mother has been a nurse for more than 30 years and is still working on the ICU floor - has never gone into management, teaching, etc... She is passionate about it and very book smart. As kids, we had the health lectures everyday and would correct any piece of wrong information. She's grown to become very caring and less critical... except on me :) I have other family members who are also nurses - cousins, aunts, and friends.

I just graduated and I was talking with some instructors and the director. I feel like many of them see me as their "daughter" and see themselves in me... a twenty something - spazzy nursing student, enthusiastic about the profession. I am very aware of my weaknesses and one big one is that I'm not a very book smart person. I learn BEST through experiences and cannot just "get it" with text books and tests. That stuff is reserved in my short term memory and after that, I don't know anything. Being a CNA for years before nursing school, I was working alot with mental health patients and with that, I did very well in mental health. Regardless, I suck at taking tests and am not the smartest. ALL my instructors, including the director (I'm sure are very aware of this as well) know I'm not the best at this... HOWEVER, during clinicals, I do well. Apparently, there were nurses on the floor who have told my instructor good things about me, on the first day of our clinical; I had family members of patient tell the facility (who then, told my instructors) how I was "there" for them, etc... I'm also a very energy sensitive person and when there were times when patients were so frustrated, I literally became anxious and frustrated. There were 2 or 3 clinical instructors saw me cry at the back because of this. They've also told me I'm a great public speaker, which is a rarity. So I guess in terms of nursing, I'm good at "the art" but I suck at the science. Is this a bad thing? I feel a bit embarrassed about my weakness....

Specializes in ICU.

I would MUCH rather have a nurse taking care of me (or a loved one) who had good common sense/clinical skills, versus a brainiac who scored 120% on the tests but couldn't take care of patients.

Go for it!

I would MUCH rather have a nurse taking care of me (or a loved one) who had good common sense/clinical skills, versus a brainiac who scored 120% on the tests but couldn't take care of patients.

Go for it!

As long as we're talking about our "druthers," I'd rather have a nurse who had common sense/clinical skills AND scored a 120% on tests! I knew a whole lot of these types in the ICU's at my hospital. They were phenomenal nurses.

It really doesn't have to be either/or.

Thank everyone. I'm just a newbie so I'm hoping (if I get hired, please God) I can increase my knowledge through work. Hopefully the material will "click" along with application; thus boosting my confidence (but not too much). And let's hope the nurses who've had decades of experience will be kind to me :) I'm willing to learn alot from them.

Specializes in Certified Med/Surg tele, and other stuff.

Much of it you will learn through hands on while at work. We all have our weaknesses in regards to nursing. I know what mine are and I study and try to learn the latest or understand it a bit more. I'm the first to admit I'm not perfect, and I'm completely ok with that. :)

Specializes in Adult/Ped Emergency and Trauma.

The #1 person we have to blame for our self confidence is ourselves. I agree with all the prior posts, that you seem to be intelligent and worthy. I just hope someone hasn't made you feel inferior, or not "Smart."

Everyone learns in different ways: auditory, visual, practice, etc.

Don't sell yourself short, and don't give others negative opinions of you permission to damage your self worth, self confidence, or self esteem. You might be really surprised what you do remember from those books when you get into nursing practice.

Great Luck, and Congrats on Graduation!!!

I never measure "being a good nurse" as getting along with patients, or getting tasks done right. Those aren't too hard to accomplish.

If you can think and act as needed, you may be a good nurse. After all, everybody has a different learning style, you may learn best after doing it. There is nothing wrong with this.

Anyone can learn the tasks. almost. Better understand ap, pharmacology, know about what to watch for etc. And to know that you must know about the disease, surgery, what is to be excpected what is not etc. It is not all just doing tasks. You have to be able to learn the material and APPLY it.

"Book smart" doesn't have to mean "genius who can recite pathophisiology text from memory". Sometimes you might have read something.. gosh, what was it... wasn't there SOMEthing about (whatever) that I should remember? And that is enough to make you look it up, or ask, and then you're glad you did. Or not. Sometimes it wasn't anything and I wasted a few minutes. Sometimes I have to look the same thing up over and over; for some reason, my coworkers do appear to think of me as smart, anyway. If you just make it a habit to learn as much as you can, you will end up "book smart" as well as hands-on smart. And seek a workplace that nurtures learning. Find friends at work who enjoy talking about science as much or more than they enjoy talking about reality TV.

As far as being energy sensitive: you can learn ways to shield yourself energetically. Learning to meditate and clear your mind helps; learn to "ground" yourself; then there's ways to visualize, for example, protective light around you. The goal is to be emotionally present and nurturing but not absorb other people's "stuff", or at least to be able to shed yourself of it afterward. It looks to me like you'd be good at Healing Touch. Their website has instructions for the "Self Chakra Connection", a real easy way to soothe yourself and reconnect body and soul when you're frazzled.

Specializes in ICU.
As long as we're talking about our "druthers," I'd rather have a nurse who had common sense/clinical skills AND scored a 120% on tests! I knew a whole lot of these types in the ICU's at my hospital. They were phenomenal nurses.

It really doesn't have to be either/or.

True. It doesn't have to be either/or in all cases. That being said, there are plenty folks in a critical care training program who can recite the text, score 120% on the tests, appear confident, yet are totally CLUELESS/Incompetent re: taking care of real patients.

As with many things in life, it's a balancing act. I don't want a nurse with great empathy (yet technically incompetent) taking care of me/mine. Nor would I want a brainiac who is technically capable yet clueless in terms of human interaction/feelings/empathy/common sense.

Neither A nor B. Somewhere in between is my "preferred" caregiver.

+ Add a Comment