Ctr Nsg Advocacy: Nurses upset over Univ of Alberta medical students "Medshow"

Published

from the center for nursing advocacy, inc.

news on nursing in the media

take action!

strangeways, here we come: university of alberta medical students have something important to say about nurses--especially their breasts!

edmonton_journal_thumb.gif

july 8, 2005 -- the edmonton journal published a fair piece by jodie sinnema on may 19 about the recent controversy surrounding the lyrics of a "nurses' song" performed by university of alberta medical students at their annual "medshow." it seems that nursing professors, the university provost, and even the medical school dean found something objectionable about the song's assertions that nurses were "wh*res" and "b*tches" whose "incompetence" threatened to "make our patients die." but at least the medical students felt nurses were qualified to "fill up my coffeepot" and "give good head," and the refrain urged nurses to "show me those boobs." the song seems to reflect virulent misogyny, ignorance of nursing, and professional insecurity, a perfect storm of dysfunction that persists in many clinical settings, harming patients and contributing to nursing burnout and the global nursing shortage. to the extent the song and the medical students' apparent non-apology are indicators of their career trajectory, it's bad news for patients and colleagues. but the students' conduct does suggest that the business outlook may be good for local malpractice and personal injury lawyers--and possibly even those who work in the criminal justice system!

click here to read more and join our letter-writing campaign...

Ah, so be cause it's a 56-year tradition, it was ok to have this sexist skit featuring a degrading song about nurses??? :uhoh3:

Read the lyrics to the song before you'd reply to my post, that is NOT "black humor", it is purely dragrading and insulting.

I agree with you. Seems like defamation to me. Unacceptable under any circumstances.

Specializes in Med/Surg, Geriatrics.

I am stunned and appalled. I'm going to write my letter right now.

Ah, so be cause it's a 56-year tradition, it was ok to have this sexist skit featuring a degrading song about nurses??? :uhoh3:

Read the lyrics to the song before you'd reply to my post, that is NOT "black humor", it is purely dragrading and insulting.

While you are on the subject of reading, go back and re-read mine. I noted that I wasn't surprised that such a song was sung at an event that has been singing insulting songs for 56 years. I didn't make any judgements anywhere in my post regarding the relative value of the venue or the song in particular.

Also, I didn't say the song was specifically in the category of "black humor." I said it occurred at an event known for bawdy, black humor. In case you missunderstood the reference - Bawdy: 1)Humorously coorifice; risqué. 2)Vulgar; lewd. I think the song clearly falls into the "vulgar" category. Again: a vulgar song at a vulgar event. I still don't see the surprise.

By the way, just because I'm not surprised doesn't mean I don't think the song stinks. I just think that a profession-wide letter writing campaign could be better directed at something other than seeking punative action against a handful of people who acted especially poorly at an event tailored to catering to bad taste.

I'm sorry.. just can't get overly energized about a bunch of students being insulting at a show that's run for 56 years on a theme of being insulting. Apparently, this show has historically used themes that make fun of all sorts of anatomical landmarks, including butt-cracks and phalluses. This wasn't a speech by the class president during freshman orientation; it wasn't an isolated skit performed at the alumni banquet. It was a demonstration of poor taste at a show known for poor taste.

I guess I'm surprised that anyone would be surprised at college students going "over the top" at this thing. I'm more worried that the credibility of the issues in the letter are going to be fogged over by using a known, bawdy, "black humor" event as a basis for action. I'd rather see such energy directed toward a letter writing campaign targeting local, state, and national politicians and business leaders based on real impacts to patient outcomes.

Yes, we should address other issues, as well. But at what point do you decide what's important enough to get "excited" about? For these doctors to come up with this means that on some level they THINK this-would you want to work with a doc who found this song funny? Would you still not get too excited if a doc you worked with hummed or "jokingly" sang this song, or something like it. I'm not "overly excited"; I'm disgusted, and doing something (however small, about it)

I personally appreciate anyone who helps address this issue. Not only is it demeaning to nursing as a whole, it hits pretty close to home.

I once told a very close personal friend, who is also an anesthesiologist, about some of the comments said on the Student Doctor site. He was horrified, but then added that he thought nurses hated doctors. If doctors think that we hate them, I can't help but wonder if this "song" holds just a little bit of honesty to its creators.

Did that make sense? :uhoh21:

Specializes in Gerontological Nursing, Acute Rehab.
Medshow is about parody, fun N jeers and is a fundraise per the news article.....someone got carried away big time.

I think sending the med students to a weeks worth of ride along with a homecare RN or 3 12 hour shifts on a rehab floor would be just amends.

Carried away is one thing....this left me speechless (and that doesn't happen too often!)

After doing my 12 hour weekend shifts at my acute care rehab, I wholeheartedly agree that it would be a real eye opener to some of these med students.

By the way, this nurse will show them her boobs....and squirt them right in the eye with some good ol' breastmilk!

Specializes in Rodeo Nursing (Neuro).

I wrote a letter.

In seven years that I've worked in healthcare, including the last two as a nursing student, and three weeks (wheew!) of orientation as a graduate nurse, the women I work with have shown me nothing but encouragement and support. I am honored to know them, and proud to work alongside them.

I would be embarassed to be a man, if these medical students were men.

Call me old-fashioned, but I just think adulthood ought to be among the pre-requisites to work in any health profession.

When I was a child, I spake like a child...until my Dad smacked me upside the head and told me to grow up.

Call me old-fashioned, but I just think adulthood ought to be among the pre-requisites to work in any health profession.

Well said! I couldn't agree more!

When I was a child, I spake like a child...until my Dad smacked me upside the head and told me to grow up.

Are we related? :)

Specializes in Rodeo Nursing (Neuro).
Well said! I couldn't agree more!

Are we related? :)

Hello, Brother Nurse.

Damn, that sounds good, doesn't it?

Hello, Brother Nurse.

Damn, that sounds good, doesn't it?

:rotfl:

Well I sent a letter and even got one back from the Dean of Medicine...we'll see what transpires or if his apology and dismay was all 'lip service'. He promises he will followup with the Dean of Nursing to incorporate professional respect for nurses into the curriculum.

Anyone else get a reply?? Hope you all wrote letters...

Well I sent a letter and even got one back from the Dean of Medicine...we'll see what transpires or if his apology and dismay was all 'lip service'. He promises he will followup with the Dean of Nursing to incorporate professional respect for nurses into the curriculum.

Anyone else get a reply?? Hope you all wrote letters...

Yeah, i got one too. So did others that I know of. I thought it was weak and very canned, so I sent one back. I hope it makes him think.

+ Join the Discussion