An astounding lack of diversity in nursing

Nurses Announcements Archive

Published

https://allnurses.com/forums/f34/african-american-male-nurse-practitioners-4734.html

I pasted my comment from another thread (above) into its own thread because I'm interested in why y'all think there is such a lack of diversity in nursing and what you think the solutions should be.

This is a touchy subject, I know, so I only ask that you keep your comments respectful and constructive:

As a minority we experience many unnecessary, unexplainable things that our equal counterparts never even have to deal with, like be confused with all of the healthcare team auxillary members (CNA,house keeping,PT,RT,patient escort, lab tech, pharm tech, etc...) while having a badge that Ray Charles could see identifying us as an RN!!!!! When you pretend to yourself that it doesn't happen, it is because you have probably been guilty of it yourself. Have you noticed how receptive people are to a young (majority) male in scrubs/lab coat versus a minority male in scrubs/lab coat?????? The minority could actually be the MD and majority the scrub tech, but guess who gets the MD RESPECT?

Older thread I came across but wanted to comment on this:

First, some demographics: in the U.S. as of 2000, RNs are comprised of:

http://bhpr.hrsa.gov/healthworkforce/reports/changingdemo/composition.htm#3.3.2

White Female: 82%

non-Hispanic African American Female: 4.9%

Asian Female: 3.5%

Hispanic Female: 2%

Native American Female: 0.7%

Mixed/Other race Female: 1.2%

White Male: 4.7%

All other Male: 1.0%

3 points:

1. The key statistic here is that only ONE PERCENT of nurses are non-white males. If I mistake a minority male as being somebody OTHER than a nurse, sure, there might be some built-in cultural bias there, but it's just as likely that it's because of the rarity of such nurses in the first place.

Now, you might argue that the rarity is the real problem and I would agree. A profession that under-represents minorities by a factor of 3 and males by a factor of 9 needs to ask itself one potent question: why?

2. I think the OP has had a difficult time over the years finding fellow minority male NPs because those nurses would be a fraction of the ONE PERCENT total number of non-white male nurses. A small pool to swim in, to be sure.

3. As demographics change, nursing is simply going to be forced to address this issue of an astounding lack of diversity in its ranks. As our nation drops below 50% "white" in the next decade or two, it will simply become unfeasible to continue to recruit 86.6% of RNs (male and female combined) from the shrinking pool of whites in this nation. Think real hard about that last statistic: something is amiss in how we recruit nurses. Something's broken and needs to be fixed.

(disclaimer: it's not my intent to be biased against LVN/LPNs, however, I got my stats from government links that only tabulated RNs.)

~faith,

Timothy.

Specializes in Me Surge.
The most glaring statistic (men in nursing aside) is this:

Hispanics represent 14.5% of the gen pop but just over 2% of nursing.

I don't think it's an issue of minorities being 'turned away' at the door, but how to get them interested and prepared enough to knock on the door in the first place. I think nursing has an image problem.

~faith,

Timothy.

Why? Why spend more taxpayers ( because face it that's where it will come from) money trying to get more minorities into nursing. Noone recruited me, I knocked on doors and kicked down a few. Nursing schools accept students based on criteria not race so that's not an issue.

Specializes in Me Surge.
there has been recognition of lack of diversity in nursing by nursing leaders over the past 25 years. here are some of their efforts:

national efforts:

1998: ana addressing cultural diversity in profession

nursingworld | tan jan/feb '98: diversity: a continuing challenge

1999: ana advocates more diversity in nursing

2004: ana review: institute of medicine report on workforce diversity ...

[color=#660000]nursingworld | ojin: the many faces of diversity | web references

cultural diversity in nursing practice: ana position statement ... national institute of nursing research diversity programs and resources

decmber 2001, aacn: effective strategies for increasing diversity in nursing programs

2000: a national agenda for nursing workforce racial/ethnic diversity. national advisory council on nurse education and practice report to the secretary of health and human services and congress.

[color=#660000]books:

[color=#660000]strategies for recruitment, retention and graduation of minority nurses in colleges of nursing

[color=#660000]2002: [color=#660000]minority nurses in the new century

edited by hattie bessent , edd, rn, faan

a national survey of ethnic and racial minority nurses and a follow-up pilot project provide a wealth of data and insights for identifying and overcoming workplace barriers. these findings can contribute to diversity in the health care workforce by facilitating minority nurses in professional and leadership roles. 2002/96 pp.

for free contact hours on this topic, see the ce independent study module disparities in health care and

[color=#660000]welcome to minority fellowship program

...for nearly three decades, the mfp has aided ethnic nurses in attaining advanced degrees in mental health related areas. the two-fold intent is to expand and enhance the scientific knowledge of mental health care, and to provide quality culturally relevant care to a diverse group of individuals and families within the national and throughout the global community. since its inception in 1974, the program has nurtured more than 200 fellows, and these individuals now work in a variety of settings. they are leaders in research, clinical practice, public policy, administration, and community service... http://ana.org/emfp/about/

legislation and funding:

us code: title 42,part c--increasing nursing workforce diversity

in carrying out subsection (a) of this section, the secretary shall take into consideration the recommendations of the first, second and third invitational congresses for minority nurse leaders on "caring for the emerging majority," in 1992, 1993 and 1997, and consult with nursing associations including the american nurses association, the national league for nursing, the american association of colleges of nursing, the national black nurses association, the national association of hispanic nurses, the association of asian american and pacific islander nurses, the native american indian and alaskan nurses association, and the national council of state boards of nursing. http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/42/usc_sec_42_00000296---m000-.html

nursing workforce diveristy programthe nursing workforce diversity program (nwdp) is a principal hrsa ... public health service act to increase nursing education opportunities for individuals ...

bhpr.hrsa.gov/kidscareers/nursing_workforce.htm

nursing workforce diversity grants (nwd)purpose, the purpose of the nursing workforce diversity (nwd) program is to provide federal funding for projects to increase nursing education opportunities

2007: nwd budget justification-program description - the goal of the nursing workforce diversity program is to improve the diversity of the nursing workforce to meet the increasing need ...

www.hrsa.gov/about/budgetjustification07/nursingworkforcediversity.htm

individual state/facility efforts:

penn nursing: diversity in education

appointment of clifford jordan to teaching faculty, school of nursing, 1966 by dean dorothy mereness ...

nov 06: nurse retention and workforce diversity in nyc--final report

recruitment and retention of hispanic nursing students

the california endowment - march 27, 2002 - central valley nursing ...

national health foundation + calif. - nurse workforce presentation.ppt

2007:

the relationship between cultural competence education and ...

thanks for the information. it looks like much is being done to increase diversity.

trudy you have put in some good points as have many others

i know black mds who will not hire a white nurse in their clinics, i know women who look down on males as not 'real' nurses . on the other hand i have had female pts who would want a male rn to put in ivs..by the way i really hate the term male rn i think that they should be viewed as nurses and for the gender

the idea of educating the lpns to rn status is a very good one, they know what nursing entails and you will have less of those accepting a opening in a program and then dropping out when reality bites the fire out of them a drop out reduces the population of nurses

too many minorities tach their children to blame discrimination for every setback..sometimes this is true but you will have to ignore these people and show them by example what you are made of

because the racial makeup of this area there are many black mds, rns, lpns

male and female = this is prpably because of the knowledge that their jobs will not be outsourced, that this will give a good paycheck to support self and fly, they will receive respect from their peers and patients..some are advancing to higher paying jobs and large percentage of their children are going to college and beyond

nursing is hard work and it is not based on gender, race etc..your future is in your hands

Bottom line......it needs to be the best qualified get the shot no matter WHAT they look like! Whoever can survive the rigors of nursing school and the profession plus be damn good at what they do - should be the nurses.

Recruiting "minorities" presents an option to a group that might not have seen nursing as an option. Also, just because you are recruiting "minorities" does not mean you are not getting the best "qualified" nurses.

A large majority of scholarships at our school are for minority nurses... But I'm thinking you have to get them interested in the first place! Interesting post.

Specializes in Oncology/Haemetology/HIV.

As a Jewish woman, NO ONE recruited me to nursing. I came to nursing on my own.

I had no scholarships. I worked full time, helped raise a child throughout school.

Much of my family (Christian and Jewish) did not approve of me going into nursing. It isn't a "clean" profession nor prestigious. I was told that I was "too smart" to be a nurse. My father (exmilitary and a police officer) thought nursing school was a waste of money-go to college for "good job" -not nursing. Many of my friends from minority groups had families that voiced the same concerns.

I am really tired of the idea that we must "recruit" diversity. Invariably, if there were larger numbers of minorities in nursing, someone would complain that the majority is consigning minorities to a profession, that is dirty, messy, working class and treated in a subordinate manner. But because the majority of nurses are not of a minority class, nursing suddenly is a preferred job that people supposedly are being excluded from. The undesirable aspects that make it less than glamorous are glossed over.

Page after page? I don't think so. Where? Where?! I just finished grad school and I only remember perhaps 1 or 2 scholarships that had race as a factor in the scholarship but it certainly was not the only requirement, income and gpa was also a factor. In fact, I did not qualify for any of them myself mainly because of income. So far, I've completed two degrees and I have yet to fall into this bonanza of minority scholarships that is presumed to be dropped into our laps. I have a student loan also plus I worked the entire time I was in graduate school.

Please stop spreading falsehoods, they only perpetuate prejudices. NOW you may go back to your regularly scheduled debate.

I agree I saw ONE minority scholarship that I would qualify for and only 3 total minorities out of the pages and pages that I printed off at school some months back. I don't understand why people want to perpetuate this myth of monies and services that are out there for the taking for minorities. :confused: In any case I don't see why recruitment of minorities (which encompases a large and diverse group of people) should irritate people. It's not like recrruitment = automatic acceptance to a program. I too have found that a lot of nrsing students are "legacy" students. We have six males in our class, I am african american and we started with 4 asians. Decent diversity by regular NS stats.

Bottom line......it needs to be the best qualified get the shot no matter WHAT they look like! Whoever can survive the rigors of nursing school and the profession plus be damn good at what they do - should be the nurses.

Exactly!

Deep down I thought I would "prefer" a male nurse when I was in labor, but i found that I was so tired, so uncomfortable and just generally "done" with being pregnant that I didn't care who was my nurse or who was the doctor on call, I just wanted the kid out.

Page after page? I don't think so. Where?

Please stop spreading falsehoods, they only perpetuate prejudices. NOW you may go back to your regularly scheduled debate.

Ok, I will call your raise.

Discovernursing.com

Search criteria

State: Mississippi

Gpa 3.5

Ethnicity No restriction

Program Undergraduate

In spite of these criteria it returned 32 scholarships funded by various institutions far far away. Which require committing to working there for X amount of time. Which I believe falls into my criteria of terms I'm not willing to accept.

BSN or LPN bridge programs-3

Religious affiliation-4

Gender (opposite)- 2

Ethnicity - 8

with no location restrictions

Other -3

other includes criteria such as participation in equine activites, go figure

All - 1

all includes my criteria, adn, with no gender or ethnicity requirements

From what I'm seeing this website has exactly ONE scholarship that I am eligible for. I will also note that on the search page where the criteria are listed it claims that it has 31 scholarships avaliable based upon ethnicity. For some reason caucasian isn't one of the catagories.

Let us try minoritynurse.com. I'm not even gonna bother to count number of scholarships on it, there is a number of them. Or for that matter count the number of related websites.

Let us try caucasiannurse.com. Internet explorer cannot display the webpage. No joy there.

In previous post my concluding incomplete sentence was supposed to say that if some indian tribe wants to pay for one of it's people to go to school and then come back and be a nurse on their reservation, I have absolutely no problem with that. I'm pretty sure I wrote or intended to write something similar to that, not sure what happened to it.

I agree that my post could be seen as inflammatory. But in my opinion the fact that it may not be politically correct does not make it any less true. Perhaps you have found some websites that have a few pages of scholarships that meet my critieria, please feel free to share.

Specializes in Tele, ICU, ER.

Honestly, I get tired of hearing the diversity thing, too. I'm SORRY I'm caucasion, ok? I shouldn't feel like I have to apologize.

I didn't get handed anything, my parents weren't college educated and I certainly didn't get my desire to be a nurse from them. Was something I grew up and wanted to do (at 36!). Before that, I'd joined the military. And I worked full-time and paid upfront for my education, thank you. Didn't qualify for anything, even with 4 kids at home. I'd have LOVED to be able to work part time or not at all, AND have financial aid money left over after paying tuition, as many of my fellow classmates did. Didn't qualify.

I don't think we're ever going to see an end to racism as long as ANY distinctions are made for any race. I hate the history months. Why not, instead, topic history months? SCIENCE history month, or MATH history month, or even (heaven forbid) HEALTH history month - all highlighting contributors of ALL races. Just think - not only teach kids the progression of our society based on all sorts of cool things, but also introduce them to career possibilities in the process!

If you MUST have specific scholarships, base them on income need and then on scholastic effort. Note I said effort, NOT gpa. That covers schools that are overcrowded and have other educational challenges. The kid who showed up to school every day, volunteered in the library and participated in extracurricular activities - the one who has already shown that he/she wants to put in the EFFORT. If we do that, will many minorities benefit. Absolutely! And that's great! But it won't be BASED on skin color or nationality.

Take race OUT of opportunities - base it on other objective, measurable criteria. If you WANT to end racism, quit putting such emphasis on it! Not everything that goes wrong is the fault of race or racism. Sometimes crap happens, sometimes life's not fair, someone doesn't like you - doesn't always mean race is a factor. I'm quite capable of liking or disliking someone on much stronger evidence that the color of anyone's skin.

But when I see official nursing associations that I am excluded from, based on my color, I think: so it was bad back then but now it's ok as long as it's not YOU? If it's wrong, it's wrong.

Sorry for the rant but sheesh!

+ Add a Comment