- 0Jul 2, '02 by woo 2what states have whistleblower protection, i know i should know this but i really don,t thanks
- 0Jul 2, '02 by RustyhammerTo tell you the truth I don't feel protected at all. Should I "blow the whistle" I feel that my job will certainly be in jeopardy. New Mexico is a "free will" state which means you are free to be fired at any time with or without reason.
However, I was looking for a job when I found this one and I don't feel as I would hold back if I knew of fraud or simular crimes.
- 0Jul 3, '02 by -jtThe nursing unions in NY, led by the New York State Nurses Assoc just got it passed last month, after a 4 yr battle for it.
You can find all the other states & where they are with the staffing law, mandatory ot law, whistleblower law & many others that affect us by going to the governmental affairs page on the American Nurses Assoc website. Click federal & state
- 0Jul 4, '02 by fedupnurseNew Jersey. Look under CEPA for Conscientious Employee Protection Act. Apparently some of the ramifications can be loss of medicare funding for 6 months, loss of Magnet if you have that lame designation, and unfair labor pratice violations.
It is a great idea that is very long overdue. I'm not sure what other states have whistleblower protection but there are quite a few that either do have it or are working on it.
- 0Jul 4, '02 by NRSKarenRN, RN, BSN Adminfrom ana government relations....
click on link below to check out map for which states have passed whistleblower legislation or have introduced state bills.
federal legislation introduced under medicare regulations,
bipartisan patient protection act of 2001, s. 1052 , upon passing, would force facilities to loose medicare funds or ability to accept medicare clients upon guilty judgement if facility violates whistleblower provisions.
whistleblower laws prevent employers from taking retaliatory action against nurses through actions including suspension, demotion, harassment or discharge for reporting improper quality of patient care. across the nation, nurses are speaking out or "blowing the whistle" against workplace conditions that jeopardize patients and staff and they need legal protection. with the restructuring of health care and its cost cutting measures, nurses are frustrated as they try to provide quality patient care while staffing levels, resources and support are often inadequate.
as part of the american nurses association's (ana) nationwide state legislative agenda, ana, in cooperation with state nurses associations, is promoting strong whistleblower laws on the state level that provide legal protection so nurses can be patient advocates without fear of reprisal. on the federal level, ana has been actively pushing for the enactment of the bipartisan patient protection act of 2001, s. 1052 which includes a whistleblower provision for nurses and other health care professionals.
in 2002 legislation enacted in md prevents retaliatory action against any individually licensed or certified employee who discloses to a supervisor or board an activity, policy or practice that is in violation of a law, rule, or regulation. ny enacted legislation prevents an employer from taking retaliatory action against an employee who discloses to a supervisor or a public body an activity that constitutes improper quality of care or refuses to participate in that activity. the law also establishes a fund that consists of money received from civil penalties related to this law to be used for improving quality of patient care. whistleblower legislation is also being considered in ct, fl, hi, ia, il, and ri.
in 2001, whistleblower legislation enacted in or prevents a hospital from taking retaliatory action against nursing staff for disclosure of an activity, policy or practice of the hospital that is in violation of a law or professional standard of practice and that poses a risk to patients. the law also protects the nurse from participating in any activity that the nursing staff believes poses a risk to the patient. wv law prevents retaliation or discrimination against any health care worker who reports wrongdoing or waste or advocates on behalf of a patient in regards to care
national and state legislation affecting nursing found here:
- 0Jul 4, '02 by adrienurseAlthough this is a little bit off topic, the following is a prime example of how things can go very wrong for nurses, and how knowing your rights is so important.
I wonder if any of you are aware of the nightmare that occured
here in my hometown a few years ago. Below is an unofficial version of what happened. Has been referred to as the Health Sciences Centre Pediatric Cardiac Surgery Incident.
The facts of this infamous incident have become public only after a publicly funded inquest was done, and the incident is truly frightening -- especially if you are a nurse. A few years ago, the largest tertiary care facility in Winnipeg decided to start a pediatric cardiac surgery program at the HSC. It seems that not a lot reasearch was done in the feasibility of such a venture, and it appears to have been mostly a political move rather than being pased on specific population needs, or available professional support.
Anyway, a surgeon was recruited from the States with little actual experience, but seemingly based on the fact that he was a graduate of Harvard School of Medicine. It seems that from the start, there were concerns from the OR nurses working with this doctor. Reports or his gross incompetance were widely ignored and, resulted only in a "there, there" attitude from administration. Some nurses were disciplined due to their refusal to work with this doctor, or for voicing concerns directly to him. The specific details that have released of what occured during these surgeries, are truly frightening. The concerns were reported to the local College of Physicians and Surgeons, and did not result in his dismissial. Eventually it was determined that this surgeon was responsible for 12 infant deaths on the operating table. It appears that only when the parents and families of the dead started demanding answers, that the plug was pulled on the program and the surgeon was terminated. Details of the public inquest are available on the net and I will direct anyone there who is interested. Scarry thing is, this Docter was able to return to the States without the incident being on his record, and is presently working in California.Last edit by adrienurse on Jul 4, '02
- 0Jul 4, '02 by fiestynurseWhistleblower law for health care workers passed in 2000 in California. California Senate Bill 97 was passed and signed by Governor Gray Davis. This bill extends whistle blower protections to all employees who work in acute care facilities. Under the provisions of this legislation, employees may not retaliate against employees who file complaints regarding unsafe patient care. Violators are subject to fines.
Suicide note written by Mary Hochman, RN, right before she walked down to Tajiguas beach in California on a September day in 2000 and shot herself in the heart with a .38 caliber revolver:
" Since I became a whistleblower my entire life has been ruined. I tried to do the right thing to protect my patients. I have no job. I cannot pay my bills. I have no faith in nursing. If a nurse reports wrongdoing to the State her life will be ruined like mine. She will lose her patients, her friends at work, her seniority.
Medical records can be changed by administrators and no one will do anything. Nurses notes were replaced by a nurse who wasn't even in the building on the stated date. Another nurses notes were destroyed. Is there anyone out there who understands how important it is that nurses be able to report wrongdoing. These nurses must be protected when they report to the state.
If a nurse cannot protect her patients I do not want to be a nurse. This has taken all hope away from me. I cannot continue to watch my husband and my daughter suffer because I was a whistleblower."
Mary had reported patient abuse at a nursing home. Because of her, this nursing home was shut down.Last edit by fiestynurse on Jul 4, '02
- 0Jul 4, '02 by adrienurseFYI RE: Winnipeg Whistleblowing Incident
Official Inquest Report:
http://freedomtocare.org/page123.htmLast edit by adrienurse on Jul 4, '02