Hasidic Jew Admitted for Bone Marrow Transplant
This is a great idea for an article contest! My first thought that came to mind was the month long journey our unit took with a young Hasidic Jew who was admitted for his stem cell transplant. Yoshi was 25 and traveled from New York city to our Boston hospital to have a bone marrow transplant for CTCL. (Cutaneous T-cell lymphoma.) For those who don't live in the leukemia/lymphoma world, this is a rare type of lymphoma that presents with open weeping, bleeding difficult to heal skin lesions anywhere on the body. The only definitive treatment for these sores is chemo followed by a transplant.
Prior to Yoshi's BMT admit, he had endured many rounds of chemotherapy, so he was somewhat familiar with the drill. He had a steady parade of Hasidic visitors- all from Boston. What we didn't realize is how closely knit this community is- and once the Boston Hasidic Jews heard that "one of their own" was in their city, they rallied and came to visit on a regular basis. It didn't matter that they didn't know him, they were there to support him through his treatment. On Shabbat (Friday, the Sabbath), the Rebbe (Rabbi) would come with many more visitors and have a modified woship service. Every visitor came with food- tons of Kosher food. They couldn't cook in our kitchen as it wasn't Kosher- so they brought their own hotplate! It was an honor to be approached by a bearded young man with a plate heaping full of food. Unfortunately, not all the staff embraced their show of gratitude with acceptance. Some nurses (and housekeeping staff) complained and moaned when they saw these visitors approach the kitchen with their food and hotplate... They were loud, took up a lot of space and monopolized the kitchen while they were cooking!
So the many chemo visits helped us to identify what was going to be important for this young man, and also draw up a contract. As the weeks of treatment passed, we began to see that the transplant admission was potentially fraught with problems. Coming in for chemo is a routine admission- the actual transplant a bigger deal. One must expect to stay 3-6 weeks on average while marrow recovery takes place. The patient is much much more immunocompromised for a longer period, and preventing infection that much more important. Though patients generally recover faster today due to growth factors, they still expect to get pretty sick- fevers, chills, mouth sores, diarrhea, possible sepsis, respiratory failure, etc etc. There is a slight chance that they won't recover.
Hasidic Jews don't worship with both sexes together- they are extremely modest. Yoshi preferred male nurses and docs, but that wasn't always possible. He frequently had a room full of visitors- as many as 10 men in huge fur hats, coats. Visiting hours didn't apply to his visitors. He was able to eat through his chemo treatments, so his room was usually covered with boxes, jars, bags of Kosher food- more then one person could reasonably eat in a 4 day period! One of his visitors even brought him a HUGE stuffed toy horse- what reason- I never did find out. As this is an adult BMT unit, we don't allow overnight visitors unless the patient is eminently dying or there is a language barrier and we need the visitor to translate.
Prior to his BMT admit, the team sat down with Yoshi and his father. (His wife would stay behind in NYC.) It was agreed to keep visitors to 4, that food would be cleaned up and put away at the end of every day, that he could have one visitor stay with him at sundown on Friday night. Observant Jews are not permitted to do any work on the Sabbath. Pushing the call light- is work! Pushing the steel plate to enter and exit the unit- is work! I still remember the 3 or 4 men patiently waiting at the entrance of the unit for someone to come and push the steel plate. When they were ready to leave, again would stand patiently until someone noticed and let them out. (I never did find out how they got to the street level from the 8th floor- walking down 8 flights of stairs seems more work then pushing two elevator buttons, but what do I know?) He had to agree to sometimes having female nurses and doctors- who had to examine him. Even in his modesty, he complied. In general most Hasidic Jews have tremendous respect for the medical community and are compliant with rules and treatment.
Male Hasidic Jews wear full beards, white dress shirts and black pants and dress coat. After he was admitted, Yoshi maintained this dress during his entire transplant, though he did lose much of his beard and hair. He had open oozing lesions on his arms, back and abdomen- that by the end of the day, had oozed on his white dress shirt. Ugh. His visitors faithfully kept him in clean white shirts. The actual transplant was quite an ordeal, he got very sick. His friends didn't understand that when he had bleeding mough sores and ulcers down his GI tract, that he couldn't eat. The food still flowed, it just was eaten by visitors and not Yoshi. We had to constantly reinforce the "food put away by end of the day" rule- they seemed to be mystified by our hypervigilence with hygeiene. We repeatedly reminded them about the need to reduce bacteria in the room- hand washing, gels, no sick contacts, etc. I was explaining to one young man that bacteria could pose Yoshi great harm, only to come back later and find the visitor on the floor. He explained that he was "looking for the bacteria." These men typically spend many many hours studying and discussing the Torah-(the first 5 books of the Bible), but after doing my own research of this culture, often don't have more then an 8th grade education. This visitor didn't have a concept of what bacteria are- invisible to the eye but potentially lethal.
Yoshi had specific times in the day when he studied the Torah and prayed- and I knew during this time he didn't like to be disturbed. He was scheduled for a CT scan at 2pm, and he had to get washed up and changed into a hospital johnnie. I reminded him in the morning, and as it got closer to 1, he was still in white shirt and black pants. Getting nervous, I interrupted him while he was reading- and he gave me what I thought was the "thumb's up" sign. Great! He's going to get ready. Only to come back later, and he's still reading and hasn't changed. Once again, I interrupted, to get the same thumb. He put everything away later, and explained he was trying to signal that at 1pm he would get ready. They believe that you can't point your finger up- it's disrespectful to Adonai. (The Lord) Clearly I didn't get it!
Yoshi made it through his transplant thankfully. Unfortunately after he returned home to NY, his lymphoma returned, and he and his wife decided not to return for more treatment. He died last year, and his wife sent us a wonderful thank you letter- that she was impressed that we showed Yoshi and his visitors respect and bent a lot of rules to accommodate his faith. I was struck by how tight this community is, and how they rally to support their members. I hope too, that our staff learned a bit of tolerence and acceptance of those from a different faith and lifestyle. I grew up in a very liberal Jewish home, and really didn't know much about this branch of Judiasm.
I am not so naive as to not recognize the difficulties that particularly the younger members of this faith experience living a very conservative and simple lifestyle in the 21st "techno" century. Observant members must dress differently, are forbidden movies, TV, and a lot of modern conveniences. Knowing some of the challenges Yoshi faced, makes me even more impressed that he made it through one of the more aggressive therapies.
oncnursemsn has '30' year(s) of experience and specializes in 'Education and oncology'. From 'Boston, MA'; Joined Dec '07; Posts: 244; Likes: 385.Jan 6, '09 by Elvish, BSN, RNWow, wow, WOW. This is an incredible story, Jess. Thank you for sharing it.Jan 6, '09 by JeanettePNPVery nicely written and I appreciate the patience and respect that you showed to Yossi and his family. So sad that he did not make it after going through all that
To clarify some things in your post:
Pushing the call light- is work! Pushing the steel plate to enter and exit the unit- is work! I still remember the 3 or 4 men patiently waiting at the entrance of the unit for someone to come and push the steel plate. When they were ready to leave, again would stand patiently until someone noticed and let them out. (I never did find out how they got to the street level from the 8th floor- walking down 8 flights of stairs seems more work then pushing two elevator buttons, but what do I know?)
Observant members must dress differently, are forbidden movies, TV, and a lot of modern conveniences. Knowing some of the challenges Yoshi faced, makes me even more impressed that he made it through one of the more aggressive therapies.Jan 7, '09 by Brian, ADNThanks for sharing your experiences. I found it quite enlightening to learn of other cultures.Jan 7, '09 by zuziJess thank you SOOOOOOOO MUCH! You bring me back memories that I think was forgoten. The Monte Royal memories, the houses from there and people and the first kosher food, loooool and the first "please don't touch this or that ".... I really loved that place! Looking at them.. even if you are an outsider... you fell the "belonging". I have a lot of memories from that times...my first meomories here..... Boston is an amazing city...I wished to live and work there! Are special people for special hearts!Jan 7, '09 by Silverdragon102, RN AdminThis just shows how diverse religion can be and the importance on knowing just a little can make a difference in recovery etc. Yes ground rules need to be set down but a small detour here and now does make the difference as long as it isn't abusedJan 7, '09 by missjennmbThat was a beautiful and very informative story. Thank you so much for sharing it.Jan 7, '09 by achot chavi[quote=oncnursemsn;3357120]
these men typically spend many many hours studying and discussing the torah-(the first 5 books of the bible), but after doing my own research of this culture, often don't have more then an 8th grade education. this visitor didn't have a concept of what bacteria are- invisible to the eye but potentially lethal.
many hasidic and ultra orthodox men do finish 12th grade and college as well. when they say they are learning the torah, it includes much more than just the 5 books of the written bible. it also includes the many books of the prophets, the 6 books of the mishneh, as well as the many encyclopedic- like talmud that gives over the tradition of the oral torah. in addition they learn many books of jewish ethics and jewish law, interpretations and opinions, statistics, etc.
some of the basic jewish laws reflect an understanding of the need for hygiene including the need to wash hands -way before it became understood and popularized in the modern world.
the visitor was clearly an exception to the rule.Jan 7, '09 by oramarOh the poor young man, I am so glad he had such a great support system. I am also glad that he had such wonderful medical professionals to care for him.Jan 7, '09 by nurse32Being different brings a lot of stares to say the least. Discrimination and mean remarks by nurses and other health care professionals is not rare.
It is stories like these, stories of tolerance and understanding that warms my heart.
In nursing school I had a professor that spent a lot of time teaching how important it is to understand the cultures that are prevalent in the community we will be working. She was a great example herself. She used to manage a Hospital Unit in a county that has a huge orthodox Jewish community.
Every Friday night when she made her rounds she always made sure to ask the patients if they want their beds adjusted, or if they want their lights on or off (Using electricity is forbidden on the Shabbos).
As a Chasidic Woman myself I have been awed by the many nurses that really cared and looked beyond our differences.
My father, a rabbi, lived in a nursing home for a few years before his passing. Every day after his wonderful nurse got him out of bed he made sure to tell her, "God bless you." And he meant it.
She (my father's nurse) taught me what it means to be a cultural competent nurse.
It is people like you that make this world a better place.Last edit by nurse32 on Jan 8, '09Jan 8, '09 by rentalnurseI worked at a Jewish Hosp in Balt and we had a kosher dining room cafeteria and non kosher one. Best food ever took some getting used to having hasidic patients what was consider norm for them compared to us and all the rules for the sabbath. went to discharge a patient and she couldnt sign her name because it was work. and to do a patient clothing inventory was a hoot, learned a lot of names for different 'religious' clothing.Jan 8, '09 by oncnursemsn(((achot chavi))) Thank you! I deeply apologize if I insinuated that the majority of Ultra Orthodox or Hasidic followers aren't well educated- I believe that the young man looking on the floor for bacteria was probably in the minority. I certainly know many faithful spend years, decades even in studies, and it's certainly more then just the Torah. Thank you for adding an important distinction.
I'm not a big fan of the Streisand film "Yentl", but it does put an emphasis on studies, debate, and the thoughtful consideration of G-d's words.Jan 8, '09 by FlareThank you for posting such a great article. I have always been fascinated by cultures different than my own, particularly the Hasidic Jewish community. I grew up with lots of very liberal jewish friends and was astounded to learn about not being able to do any work (even tearing toilet paper according to a woman i met through one of my jobs).
Must Read Topics