Ten Reasons Why American Health Care Is so Bad

Nurses Activism

Published

from the american prospect:

indeed, we have brand new data. the commonwealth fund just released a broad survey collecting health care attitudes and experiences from patients in australia, canada, germany, the netherlands, new zealand, the united kingdom, and the united states. here are summaries of some of the findings:

1. we spend the most. we spend more than any other country in the world. in 2005, our per capita -- so, per person -- spending was $6,697. the next highest in the study was canada, at $3,326. and remember -- that's "mean" spending, so it's the amount we spend divided by our population. but unlike in canada, about 16 percent of our population doesn't have insurance, and so often can't use the system. these facts should set the stage for all numbers that come after: every time you see a data point in which were dead last, or not leading the pack, remember that we spend twice as much as any of our competitors.

2. we don't pay doctors according to the quality of their care.

3. our wait times are low because many of us aren't getting care at all.

...

in just the past year, a full 25 percent of us didn't visit the doctor when sick because we couldn't afford it. twenty-three percent skipped a test, treatment, or follow-up recommended by a doctor. another 23 percent didn't fill a prescription. no other country is even close to this sort of income-based rationing.

...

4. most of us don't have a regular physician.

5. our care isn't particularly convenient.

6. our doctors don't listen to us.

7. we have high rates of chronic conditions.

8. ... but we're not treating them properly.

9. we're frequent victims of medical, medication, and lab errors.

10. most of us are dissatisfied with our current system.

source: http://prospect.org/cs/articles?article=ten_reasons_why_american_health_care_is_so_bad accessed 11/4/2007.

each of these points addresses health care disparities that are driven through a poorly designed system. the full text of the article is available here: http://prospect.org/cs/articles?article=ten_reasons_why_american_health_care_is_so_bad .

The failure of health care delivery in this country is that it is driven by profit motive. Access to health care, in my mind, is a human rights issue, like access to education. We need to remove the big business model and start focusing on accessiblity for all, instead of having a system based on making $ for CEOs and shareholders.

Specializes in ICU/CCU/TRAUMA/ECMO/BURN/PACU/.
The failure of health care delivery in this country is that it is driven by profit motive. Access to health care, in my mind, is a human rights issue, like access to education. We need to remove the big business model and start focusing on accessiblity for all, instead of having a system based on making $ for CEOs and shareholders.

I agree. The most important reason why American health care is so dysfunctional, is that we have lacked the political will to fix it; until now. I think this is our time as a nation, as individuals, to make a single payer, universal health care system a priority.

Many senators and members of congress, including some liberal ones, thought the idea was unworkable. HELLO? The election is over and the message is clear, Americans are serious about reform. It's the for-profit insurance industry and pharmaceutical industry that's blocked this from debate. They've used their full political power and economic power to block it, and if we follow their money into the campaign contribution coffers of key senators and members of congress, well, it doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out how this legalized form of "bribery" translates into a lack a meaningful reform agenda.

In California, Governor Schwarzenegger said it best. He said when you take something from the special interests, they expect something in return. He ought to know. At the behest of his big PhRMA and insurance company "death by spreadsheet" cronies, he has heartlessly, not once, but twice, refused to sign California's single-payer bill, SB 840.

The current system works well for the parasites who make a hefty profit at the expense of the most vulnerable among us, those who are sick or injured. Hubert Humphrey, the 38th Vice President of the United States once said, "...the moral test of government is how that government treats those who are in the dawn of life, the children; those who are in the twilight of life, the elderly; those who are in the shadows of life; the sick, the needy and the handicapped. "

We do have a successful and popular single-payer system of health care, (publicly funded, privately delivered), in this country: MediCare. We need to improve and expand MediCare to cover everybody. We have legislation that will accomplish just that, H.R. 676 The United States National Health Insurance Act.

It has 93 Congressional co-sponsors. Check here to see if your congressional representative is on the list. If not, write to them and call their local district office. As nurses we have tremendous moral suasion. Let them know that our patients are sicker and at higher risk of death because of lack of access to basic, medically necessary care, and that it doesn't have to be this way. Now, we have a new, young President and it's up to us to hold him to the promise that "business as usual" will not be tolerated.

President-elect Obama is on record as saying that he will sign the legislation if it gets to his desk. Dr. Steffie Woolhandler, a co-founder of Physicians for a National Health Plan said this, "I actually think politics is the art of creating the possible, and what's possible is what people believe is possible. You have the power as a group to make a statement that universal health care is the only ethical policy alternative and that the only proven way to get universal health care is through nonprofit national health insurance."

"Health care is not just another commodity. It is not a gift to be rationed on ability to pay. It is time to make national health insurance a priority, so that the basic right to health care can finally become a reality for every American." Ted Kennedy, United States Senator.

Yes, we can!:redbeathe

Specializes in ER,ICU,L+D,OR.
Actually the senate voted the Iraq war resolution and 29 democrats voted for it and 21 against. I actually believe John Edwards and Hillary Clinton were both present and voted 'yea' to pass it as a senate. Its ok it's a trendy and mighty popular viewpoint. Why would the lack of the Iraq war support the funding of health - it wouldn't. I mean we recently promised 16 month pullout, right? As you will see that will not happen, but it worked for the campaign.

Simple stop paying for the illegal war and health care would be affordable for all.

Agree'd. I think it is sad but feel letting them go bankrupt and start from scratch as a necessary development. Of course the government might like to 'own' them a bit - the healthcare doesn't need the benefit as the gov already owns/controls a good portion of this industry.

Actually a complete total restructuring of the auto industry is totally in order see as they have completely been unable to this themselves at all.

I do not even understand what this could mean - it's just trying to infer something negative on the gov of AK - for unk reason. Do you really think that moms who drive SUVs are preventing children from getting health care - really?

I didnt refer to Caribou Barbie in anyway. But now that you bring it up. She makes her own negative inferances for herself. She does not need any help from me.

And if Soccer moms drove more fuel efficient cars rather than those traditional big old SUVs they drive. Then we could reduce our dependence on foriegn oil and maybe then that war would be over. The war is only about one thing, One thing only. OIL and more OIL

Specializes in ER,ICU,L+D,OR.
RN4MERCY, thank you for the personalized posting,

However, my inquiry on what this statement meant by 46 meant,

"What is more important SUVs for soccer moms or health care for the children."

was not answered.

I appreciate your best guesses but it was not your posting.

v/r

Well excuse me for taking a few days off to work and not responding sooner. Really now which is more important, SUVs for soccer moms or health care for the children and under privileged. By continuing to buy and drive these SUVs we are continuing our reliance on OIL, Oil at any cost. This includes American soldiers lives, Continuing outflow of catastrophically large amounts of our money to countries that hate us. And takes away from the amounts of money, that would far more caover the comparative pittance it would take to fund health care. Seems simple to me.

I honestly do not know any nurse that doesn't give the best care they are capable of giving. Our healthcare system has alot to be desired. There are alot worse. In a perfect world no mistakes would happen, however , we do not live in a perfect world do we?:coollook:

Specializes in Critical care, tele, Medical-Surgical.
I honestly do not know any nurse that doesn't give the best care they are capable of giving. Our healthcare system has alot to be desired. There are alot worse. In a perfect world no mistakes would happen, however , we do not live in a perfect world do we?:coollook:

All too often we are under staffed. We can only be in ine place at at time.

Some of us think our advocacy extends to improving conditions that are not in the interest or our patients.

Safe staffing helps activist nurses and our wonderful colleagues who can then truly provide the care we all want to give.

I would like to see real reform in our healthcare system by the poeple who give the care. If Washington would listen to the Nurses,RT's,PT's,OT's,PA's,Nurse Prac's, MD's,DO's and then formulate a plan based on the PATIENT we would have a good starting point.:redbeathe

Specializes in Med Surg, Tele, PH, CM.

I just read your list again. I agree with you 100% that these are problems that need to be addressed. But one thing I just noticed is that 8 of 10 items on the list are issues that could be directly impacted by the patient. Not enough responsibility for healthcare woes in this country is being attributed to the patient. I have worked directly with recipients of both private and public sector healthcare for over 20 years and there is little difference in attitude among the healthcare consumer populations. Most see healthcare as a one-way relationship - make me feel better, but don't expect anything from me. Until this changes, there will be little improvement in the state of American healthcare delivery, no matter how much money we throw at it.

Specializes in Med Surg, Tele, PH, CM.
Really now which is more important, SUVs for soccer moms or health care for the children and under privileged. quote]

I get really tired of people commenting on children not having adequate healthcare. Every state has a CHIP program to cover children whose parents cannot afford healthcare premiums. The income elegibility requirements are very liberal.If this leaves uninsured children, it is because parents who can afford insurance choose not to pay the premiums - perhaps to pay for the SUVs. Whose fault is that?

Specializes in Family Nurse Practitioner.

Just another reason to let the federal govt feed us, house us, and take care of all our needs with forced redistrubution of wealth right ?

Specializes in Critical care, tele, Medical-Surgical.

It is not the childrens fault.

214,000 Ohio kids uninsured

Advocates call for federal action

...The advocacy group said the 214,000 uninsured Ohio children between 2005 and 2007 are the 11th most of any state, with 7.4 percent of children uninsured.

In Kentucky, 8.4 percent of children are without health insurance, while the 89,000 total ranked No. 29.

The study came before the economic slowdown hit this summer.

Families USA called on Congress and the new administration to reauthorize and expand the State Children's Health Insurance Program. President Bush vetoed an expansion last year....

...Texas has the most uninsured children, at 1.4 million, and the highest percentage of children uninsured, at 20.5 percent. ...

http://news.cincinnati.com/article/20081129/NEWS01/811290353

I get really tired of people commenting on children not having adequate healthcare. Every state has a CHIP program to cover children whose parents cannot afford healthcare premiums. The income elegibility requirements are very liberal.If this leaves uninsured children, it is because parents who can afford insurance choose not to pay the premiums - perhaps to pay for the SUVs. Whose fault is that?

So let me guess, you believe that a father should be able to stop child support payments, because, hey...who's fault is that? :rolleyes: Please, your argument is as ridiculous as it is pathetic.

+ Add a Comment