Ten Reasons Why American Health Care Is so Bad

Nurses Activism

Published

from the american prospect:

indeed, we have brand new data. the commonwealth fund just released a broad survey collecting health care attitudes and experiences from patients in australia, canada, germany, the netherlands, new zealand, the united kingdom, and the united states. here are summaries of some of the findings:

1. we spend the most. we spend more than any other country in the world. in 2005, our per capita -- so, per person -- spending was $6,697. the next highest in the study was canada, at $3,326. and remember -- that's "mean" spending, so it's the amount we spend divided by our population. but unlike in canada, about 16 percent of our population doesn't have insurance, and so often can't use the system. these facts should set the stage for all numbers that come after: every time you see a data point in which were dead last, or not leading the pack, remember that we spend twice as much as any of our competitors.

2. we don't pay doctors according to the quality of their care.

3. our wait times are low because many of us aren't getting care at all.

...

in just the past year, a full 25 percent of us didn't visit the doctor when sick because we couldn't afford it. twenty-three percent skipped a test, treatment, or follow-up recommended by a doctor. another 23 percent didn't fill a prescription. no other country is even close to this sort of income-based rationing.

...

4. most of us don't have a regular physician.

5. our care isn't particularly convenient.

6. our doctors don't listen to us.

7. we have high rates of chronic conditions.

8. ... but we're not treating them properly.

9. we're frequent victims of medical, medication, and lab errors.

10. most of us are dissatisfied with our current system.

source: http://prospect.org/cs/articles?article=ten_reasons_why_american_health_care_is_so_bad accessed 11/4/2007.

each of these points addresses health care disparities that are driven through a poorly designed system. the full text of the article is available here: http://prospect.org/cs/articles?article=ten_reasons_why_american_health_care_is_so_bad .

Just another reason to let the federal govt feed us, house us, and take care of all our needs with forced redistrubution of wealth right ?

Hi there...do you have any information, sources, references, or anything other than the pure gut conjecture on which this is based?

I'm going to take a guess....no?

Specializes in Family Nurse Practitioner.
Hi there...do you have any information, sources, references, or anything other than the pure gut conjecture on which this is based?

I'm going to take a guess....no?

Hi there, Yes my opinion, which I am entitled to

Specializes in Geriatrics, Home Health.
I just read your list again. I agree with you 100% that these are problems that need to be addressed. But one thing I just noticed is that 8 of 10 items on the list are issues that could be directly impacted by the patient. Not enough responsibility for healthcare woes in this country is being attributed to the patient. I have worked directly with recipients of both private and public sector healthcare for over 20 years and there is little difference in attitude among the healthcare consumer populations. Most see healthcare as a one-way relationship - make me feel better, but don't expect anything from me. Until this changes, there will be little improvement in the state of American healthcare delivery, no matter how much money we throw at it.

The September 2008 issue of Consumer Reports examined healthcare in the US. According to Consumer Reports, if everyone in the US took up healthy living tomorrow, we would still have the world's highest medical costs.

Hi there, Yes my opinion, which I am entitled to

Of course. But you might not want to frame it as utter fact, when in fact you are wrong. And you have been proven wrong by history and every single other industrialized country that exists other than the USA, etc etc.

So sure, if you want to maintain an utterly delusional belief in something that is so factually incorrect that it would almost be humorus (if it didn't involve the suffering and death of millions every year) that's fine. But please at least preface your opinion as such.

+ Add a Comment