3 Reasons Why Nursing Schools are Turning Away Candidates During a Nursing Shortage

Did you know that over 56,000 qualified nursing school applicants were turned away in 2017? This number is shocking by itself but added to the fact that we are in the midst of a nursing shortage, makes it downright confusing. Learn why this is happening at nursing schools across the country. Nurses Announcements Archive

Published

Over 56,000 qualified nursing school applicants were turned away in 2017. You read that right - 56,000. This is happening while hospitals and clinics continue to report a nursing shortage. According to Becker's Hospital Review, some of these qualified applicants are graduating high school with a 3.5 GPA or higher. These are candidates that will likely be successful nursing students.

You may be wondering why this is happening in the middle of a nursing shortage. Let's discuss the statistics, reasons for the problem, and a few solutions.

The Statistics

Here are a few concerning statistics about the number of aspiring nurses being turned away each year by nursing programs:

  • The National League of Nurses reported that up to 45% of ADN applicants and 36% of BSN applicants were turned away in 2014
  • Cabrillo College in Aptos, California reported having hundreds on their wait list for a 60-seat nursing program
  • Many schools are saying that applicants will be on wait-lists for up to six years and some schools are discontinuing wait lists altogether

The Reasons

To fix the problem, you need to understand why thousands of students are turned down each year by nursing schools across the country.

Not Enough Instructors

Nursing faculty positions go unfilled year and year. In fact, the American Association of Colleges of Nursing reported in their Special Survey on Vacant Faculty positions that the United States has an annual national nursing faculty vacancy rate of slightly over 7%. This equates to about two teachers for every nursing program out there. And, over 90% of these vacancies require or prefer the nurse filling the position to have a doctoral degree.

The survey went on to break down the vacancies by region. The most substantial number of vacancies can be found in the Midwest, with nearly 10% of all faculty positions remaining unfilled. Just behind that region was the South (9.7%), North Atlantic (9.5%), and finally the West (9%). If you look at the issue by type of institution - 9.6% of all vacancies are found at public colleges. And, one more break down tells us that the largest number of vacancies are in Baccalaureate programs (14.6%).

Do Nurses Want to Be Instructors?

Being a nursing instructor may be of interest to many nurses until they begin doing their homework about the position and salaries. Up to 18% of all faculty positions do not have a tenure system at the institution, and another 32.6% of the jobs just don't qualify. The amount of education required for these vacant positions appears to be another barrier. Over 22% of all vacant positions required a doctoral degree.

The special report by the AACN also reports that many schools have insufficient funds to hire new faculty. And, in some schools, the administration doesn't support the additional faculty positions, even though they are turning away potential students.

Clinical Space Shortage

All programs require a significant amount of hands-on experience in a clinical setting. Finding nursing units available for clinicals can be a challenge for nursing programs. If we had enough faculty, would they receive the training they needed? The answer is probably, no.

Many schools are reporting that there are a limited number of clinical spaces for students to get this experience. And, finding preceptors in specialty areas can be another barrier. This has further compounded the need to turn away qualified nursing school applicants.

Higher Clinical Nurse Salaries

As clinical nursing salaries continue to grow, nursing faculty salaries have not been able to compete. Up to 33.9% of schools with faculty vacancies reported that noncompetitive wages were to blame for the inability to fill the position. In fact, the AACN reported in March 2016 that a masters-prepared faculty member made an average of $77,022 per year. Compare this to a masters-prepared nurse practitioner salary of $87,000, and you can easily see why these positions are difficult to fill.

The Answers

Identifying the problem is only half the bottle. Let's explore a few solutions to this nursing dilemma.

Bridge Programs

Many nurses choose nursing as a second career. Or, they start out as an LPN or ADN and move up to a master's or doctoral prepared nurse later on in their career. Professionals can make these transitions with the use of bridge programs.

These programs allow qualified candidates to continue their education when it's convenient for them. These programs have adopted an online format over the past several years, making it even easier for nurses to continue to work and advance their education. With the help of bridge programs, some of these faculty positions could be filled.

Think Outside the Box for Clinical Sites

As our healthcare environment moves away from extended hospital stays, nursing programs need to consider new locations for clinicals. Instructors are now turning to rehab centers and nursing facilities to gain exposure to patients who were once kept after surgeries and other procedures.

Nursing jobs are changing too. Looking for preceptors in-home care, hospice, and other community-based settings is crucial for the future of nursing education. And, it gives students exposure to non-hospital nursing career options.

Create a Competitive Salary Structure

Teaching is such an essential career, yet, teachers across all industries seem to have lower paying salaries. There is undoubtedly a demand for more nursing instructors, so this needs to be rectified.

If you are interested in pursuing a career as a nurse faculty member - you can increase your earning potential based on the location and type of school. You may also look at roles, such as nurse education director, to improve your salary.

What are your thoughts about nursing schools turning away qualified applicants? Have you experienced a long wait-list or other issue related to starting your nursing education? We would love to hear your thoughts and experiences.

Specializes in Workforce Development, Education, Advancement.
There has been a nursing shortage for at least 30 years; as that was the situation in 1987 when I went to work and is still the situation now. In the southeast wages are lower than many other parts of the country; the main problem is wages. Most look at nursing and the risks/hazards in that career field and ask why would I become a nurse. They think with 4 years of education (other than nursing) there would be less risk and higher wages

Hi Wolfbuddy! You raise some excellent points about the nursing shortage and the motivations of those entering the profession. The wages have increased over the last 20 years, or so, however, I agree that there are other professions that you can come out of college making significantly more money. The nursing shortage is a complex issue with many moving pieces. I'm not sure there will ever be a real solution. Instead, we have to attempt to solve the problems as they arise and see how the whole thing turns out.

Thanks so much for your insightful comments.

Melissa

Specializes in burn ICU, SICU, ER, Trauma Rapid Response.
I am not sure why the author used a secondary source (Beckers via CNN via AACN) to cite for the article, but most of the data mentioned comes direct from the AACN and is located here: Nursing Shortage.

The primary BLS data is here: Registered Nurses : Occupational Outlook Handbook: : U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics and here Registered Nurses.

There are a few difficult issues being discussed here, and some of them are rather hotly debated.

I am not sure most people would debate there is a dearth of qualified nursing faculty and this is magnified by the fact that nursing programs are lucrative business for colleges and universities at a time when demand for nursing spots is peaking. At the same time there is quite a bit of attrition, over 10% a year, most to non-academic nursing jobs. There is also significant retirement attrition as nursing faculty is aging. The market hasn't fully corrected to this and while faculty pay has increased in the past decade it doesn't seem to match demand nor clinical wages especially as faculty are expected to have terminal degrees.

Clinical education, which lies partly out of academia control, is a difficult bottleneck as nursing is changed with more acuity and higher ratios making less room for clinical education. I wasn't around for the days of resident nursing education but perhaps that model will come back into favor as hospitals look to cut non-billable costs.

Last but not least, the nursing shortage debate. There is absolutely a purveyed and perceived nursing shortage that is supported by data from the BLS based on predictions. The data from the AACN tells me nothing more than there is a high demand for nursing students, it doesn't say anything about a demand for nurses. There is also some reasonable counters to the BLS predictions: nursing wages have remained relatively stagnant in the face of a "shortage" and the number of underemployed nurses has been reported as high as 20-25% even though unemployment is low at 2-3% for RNs. There are lots of employers posting jobs they don't intend to fill seems to be the word on the street.

My two cents.

The sourses provided do not count the number of available RNs and compare them to the number RNs needed.

In my BSN program we did exactly that for the state of Wisconsin. We found that there were plenty of nurses available, but that a lot of them choose to work in other fields due to the pay, benifits and working conditions being offered in Wisconsin's hospitals and nursing homes.

Specializes in burn ICU, SICU, ER, Trauma Rapid Response.

A shortage of nurses willing to accept the stagnant pay, poor benifits, and unsafe working conditions being offered in NO WAY indicates a shortage of nurses

1 Votes
Hi there Katillac - Thanks so much for your comments. If you follow the links in the OP, you can see that I have used various articles as evidence that students are being turned away. I agree that graduating more students is not likely not going to solve anything. The issues related to nursing shortages and other staffing issues go far deeper than one area, like education. However, I think it is imperative that we learn more about the issues, form our own opinions, and decide how best to act to make a postiive impact for our healthcare industry and the future of nursing.

Thanks again for your thoughts. ~Melissa

Melissa,

I didn't and don't question nursing students are being turned away from nursing schools. I question what seemed to be your premise, that students being turned away has a causative relationship to a general nursing shortage perceived by some. I'm glad you agree graduating more nurses won't solve anything. Odd that your article - from title forward - suggested you think otherwise.

Specializes in retire-numerous.

Yes--there is a nursing shortages of nurses who WANT to take care of patients--all the ins and outs of their care--and on a General Floor--Nurses who are in it for the hours that they work--willing to work and know that you will work week ends-holidays-kids birthdays and programs-and various shifts--the last several years, before I retired, I saw the new grads on their way out to a 9 to 5 job, no weekends, no holidays and "hospital work" was just a stepping stone--I feel for us older generation who will have "who" to care for us.

1 Votes
3 hours ago, hannahgb said:

I saw the new grads on their way out to a 9 to 5 job, no weekends, no holidays and "hospital work" was just a stepping stone--I feel for us older generation who will have "who" to care for us.

Yes, oddly it did not seem to be that way so much before the advent of behemoth healthcare corporations and so-called professionals being treated like consumables.

I feel for you and the situation you describe, too, but your ire is misdirected.

+ Add a Comment