On-call or cancelled? That is the question!

A new on-call policy at our facility has stirred up a lot of emotions in the nurses. Some good, competent nurses are talking about leaving.

  1. Was this article clear & relevant?

    • 9
      Yes, very clear & relevant
    • 7
      Somewhat clear
    • 0
      No, not at all
    • 1
      Somewhat relevant
    • 1
      Needs a lot of work

18 members have participated

Hello:

What is the cancellation/on-call policy at your facility? Last week, my facility instituted a new/updated on-call/cancellation policy. Basically, nurses are no longer cancelled, they are placed on-call, for their whole shift, up to the last two hours of their shift. Additionally, nurses are now being paid $3.00 per hour, for every hour they are on-call. Personal time can be used in addition to this new on-call premium, or nurses can elect not to use their personal time and only receive the $3.00 per hour. Previously, nurses were paid zero/zilch/nada/nothing for being on-call (which only lasted for up to 4hours, at which time the nurse was either cancelled for the rest of the shift or called to report to work by 11am/2300hrs).

So, the differences in the new policy are: Nurses are not cancelled, they are placed on-call for their whole shift (up to 5am/1700hrs); nurses are paid an on-call payment of $3.00 per every hour they are on-call; nurses can be called to work at anytime during their shift once they are placed on-call; and nurses can be placed on-call as late as 2 hours before their shift begins. Also, nurses are to report within 1hour after being notified they need to come to work.

As you might imagine, there are more negative responses towards this policy than positive responses. For example, night shift nurses are especially concerned about their safety/leaving their homes in the dead of night (sleepy, driving, safety); many nurses live more than an hour away; since nurses are now on-call their whole shift, other plans still cannot be made or events will be missed because there is no longer a time limit that a nurse can reasonably expect not to be called in to work (even at 2am or 4am); once a nurse is called in, the nurse is guaranteed to work the rest of the shift. More than a few single nurses with young children have been asking, "What am I supposed to do with my child(ren) once I am placed on call?" One nurse mentioned that she uses a night-care service, but she cannot drop off her child after 8pm.

To be fair, so far, those of us who have been placed on-call were called either not called in to work at all, or were called at 2am (night shift) notifying us that we were not needed for the rest of our shift. But, I think many of us had already decided that we were going to bed, whether we were called or not.

I predict that not many nurses will be signing up for overtime because those on OT are usually the first to be cancelled, and now, since there is no cancellation, only on-call, why put yourself in the position to wait around to be called for only $3.00? At least, if you only work your 3-12hr shifts, it is unlikely that you will be cancelled (or rare), and if you are not scheduled on a given day, if the census is high, they will call you and ask you to work (at least in this case, you're not waiting to be called to come in after being placed on-call).

Let me close by saying these are the kinds of policies that I believe put good, competent, staff in the position or mindset to leave the unit/employer/profession. At the very least, policies like these put nurses more at risk of receiving disciplinary warnings because they are made to feel there is no work-life balance. Other nurses talk about how, "All this is not worth $3.00," and still others say, "Well, they're gonna write me up because how can I be expected to come in at 1am or even 3am, and work for the rest of my shift." The nurses who are single parents feel even more stress because they feel their kids' safety and lives are now at risk.

Bottom-line: many nurses are saying, "It seems no matter what, nothing gets better for us; we're damned if we do, damned if we don't. Management just doesn't care about us, yet, we're supposed to be the caring/compassionate profession."

What say you? Maybe you have some good suggestions, thoughts, and ideas!

I worked at a hospital that implemented this policy. I don't need $2 an hour for multiple shifts a pay period if I could afford no pay I wouldn't be working as a nurse. This hospital soon lost many of it best nurses to other local hospitals, naturally management had no idea why they couldn't retain their best staff members.

Do you think they ever realized what the problem was?

We currently have a hospital wide budget problem and all departments are cancelling RN's but they must remain available the entire shift. We do not receive any payment for being on call.

Specializes in Oncology.

So these are your scheduled shifts people are placed on call for? So presumably parents already have childcare set up and night shifters should be expecting to be up all night?

We currently have a hospital wide budget problem and all departments are cancelling RN's but they must remain available the entire shift. We do not receive any payment for being on call.

I WILL NOT work for free. I must be paid to sit at someone's beck and call. I have no idea how people don't revolt in a situation like this. The employer has claimed to have a budget problem and then said RNs will work for free! Yes, that is exactly, precisely what they have said, that you will GIVE THEM your time, with no compensation. What the world!

I work in a unionized facility. If there is a low census offering, it goes to those who request, then volunteers, then perdiem nurses, then travel nurses and finally regular scheduled nurses (both full and part-time). We rotate the full and part-time nurses. No mandatory on call, though we can agree. If they need someone on call and we won't be, the either tell us to come to work or be off without call. On call time is $3.50/hr (I think) & $4.00/hr on holidays. Just to be clear-there is no mandatory call. Also, no mandatory low census if perdiem or travel nurses are working. It is grievable and our contract upholds this. If a nurse is low census or it is even not her/his turn of the regular staff, it will result in being paid their regular pay as well as accrual of benefits.

Okay that is actually a pretty terrible policy. The hospital I worked for was a small one so everyone got low censused every once in a while. We were called 2hrs prior to start of shift if we were low census. If we didnt go in at all, we got 4 hours of our normal pay automatically. If we got called in, we got however many hours we worked instead of the 4 hours. Most od us live within an hour away but the policy was flexible for those who lived outside of that. Since it was such a small hospital we csn usually tell if our census would increase enough to need to call in our LC nurse. We would end up sending a "be ready" text. That gave them time to get stuff ready of needed. Most of us keep an extra set of scrubs in the car for emergencies anyway.

I got called into work when I had my kids for an emergency delivery. I wasn't on that day but had the most experience. I had no one to watch my children so my boss told me to bring them with me. She watched them and I went into the OR for the emergency section. I stayed, recovered mom and baby, charted, and left both patients with the on duty nurse and the one who was originally called in but was stuck in traffic and wouldn't get there in time. Ended up being there for about 4 hours. Small town hospital, but a lot of support. It's hard to find that nowadays

I don't understand why nurses tolerate this. No way I would. I am a full time professional and I will work hard those 40 hours. In return, I will be paid accordingly. $3 an hour to wait? No.

The policy at my

hospital is similar-ish. We do not know about on call/call off status until usually 30 minutes prior to the shift (with some staff living 1+ hours away that is kind of annoying), and if we are placed on call, we have to be there within 30 minutes (leeway is of course given for those who live farther away, but they need to get there ASAP). We are placed on call for the duration of the shift, though there is usually reasonable doubt that if it is within probably 1-2 hours of your shift end, you are probably not needed (but must still be available).

The additional on call pay is I believe 2.00 or 2.50 for a weekday on call and 3.00 for a weekend on call, and if you get called in, you get that extra during the hours you work.

However, we are also given the option to refuse the on call/call off, in which case it would be offered to the person next in line based on rotation.

This is the only nursing job that I have experienced, so with it being the only thing I have known, it doesn't really seem too bad for us. I can see how changing from one to the other would be rough though...

Our contract states that Staffing has to call us 1.5 hours before our scheduled start time and that they can only ASK us if we want to be placed on standby. If you don't want standby, you are cancelled for your shift and oh can use or not use PTO to cover.

if you want to be placed on standby, it's $4 an hour and the OT for whatever you work if you get called in, with a minimum of 3 hours guaranteed.

Specializes in Pediatric Critical Care.

Your hospital's policy doesn't sound terribly out of the ordinary to me, but it also doesn't sound like a place that is worried much about nurse morale. At my (former) hospital, the higher-ups suddenly decided that (among other staffing changes) not only would they no longer be offering bonuses for working overtime shifts, but they would also be mandating that all nurses sign up for an extra shift once every four weeks to increase staffing. Morale plummeted and several really strong nurses left.

Easy option, buy a mobile phone (cell) cheaply just for work, turn it off or throw it in a drawer when you don't want to be contacted. In fact in the UK being contacted at home unless you expressly consent to it is potentially illegal under the Human Rights Act in the UK as you have a right to privacy. People have to volunteer for extra shifts in advance unless as I say you have consented. The only time you can be called at home is when there has been declared a 'major incident' such a major accident or terrorist incident or if you have been in contact with patients who later turn out to be infected by something dangerous etc.

Managers tend to back off swiftly if staff know their rights and can actually be disciplined for their actions, if a grievance procedure is started.

Specializes in PCCN.

another reason to not go into the nurse "profession "

:roflmao: professionn LOL