Published
when taking vitals, how many of you do it manually and how many do it with the machine?I trust my ear alot more than the machine. The machine is good if they are available, but my experience has been that the machine can give false readings, high or low. If in doubt I always recheck manually. Pet peeve of mine: Nursing students who rely on the machine, they should always do their manually. It is a time for learning, and in my opinion, the machine is a time saving device.
I agree.
The most accurate BP measurement is a manual one done by a properly trained person, using a mercury spygometer, everything else is downhill from there.
For speed of use, a handheld spyg is good, but remember to get it calibrated every 6 mos (JACHO). One big issue I see sometimes with this is that nurses (more usually CNA's) don't use properly sized cuffs -- which can cause a major difference in BP.
As for automatics, I really think (even with callibration) they should be restricted to contineous monitoring as ordered by physician (ie.. icu pt. that the physician wants to make sure BP doesn't drop precipitiously). Maybe at night if the patient needs a q2 BP -- for purposes of patient comfort. I don't think they have any place in routine use.
The most accurate BP measurement is a manual one done by a properly trained person, using a mercury spygometer, everything else is downhill from there.
Actually, the automatic cuffs built into the monitors, like are used in any ICU - including our NICU - match up VERY closely to the pressures we get off the A-line, which is about the most accurate BP measurement you can get. I don't know if the portable Dynamaps are as sensitive as the monitor cuffs, but just because it is automatic and not manual does not necessarily mean it is not accurate.
chicagrl72
131 Posts
when taking vitals, how many of you do it manually and how many do it with the machine?
as far as i know most students are taught to do it manually which i think is great
my only hosp experience when i was in labor was being hooked up to the machine and i HATED it
the nurses and midwives kept saying how high my bp was and the machine was making all those noises .....i am sure that raised it a bit !!!!!!!!!!
just wondering about the REAL WORLD of nursing
do you use the sphygmomonometer (sp?) or machine