Entry into Practice: Diploma Programs for Registered Nursing

Diploma programs are the oldest and most traditional type of nursing education in the United States. Specialties Educators Article

Updated:  

These programs are two to three years in duration and provide nursing education primarily in the hospital setting. Graduates of these programs receive a diploma as opposed to a college degree. Most diploma programs are now affiliated with colleges or universities that grant college credit for certain courses.

Many hospital schools of nursing collaborate with nearby colleges to provide basic humanities and science courses. Graduates receive credits to apply towards an associate or baccalaureate of science degree. In some cases, students earn dual credentials, a hospital diploma and an associate degree.

Diploma graduates take the same state licensing examination for registered nursing as graduates of associate degree and baccalaureate programs.

Diploma nursing programs were the earliest nursing programs, starting in the United States in the late 1870s as hospital-based training programs in cities such as New York, Boston, Philadelphia, Chicago, and Hartford. The inspiring force for diploma programs was the Nightingale School of Nursing founded by Florence Nightingale in London in 1860. These first nursing school models then quickly spread across the nation. As the number of hospitals expanded, the need for nurses increased, and hospitals developed their own training programs, which became the main source of nursing staff.

The earliest programs were taught by physicians and were only a few weeks in length. The curriculum was not standardized and there was very little theory or classroom experience. The nursing students provided free labor for the hospitals, as they often worked 12 to 18 hours a day, 6 to 7 days a week. During their training period in the hospital, the students learned nursing skills through copious hands-on experience.

Diploma programs later evolved into courses taught from a nursing perspective by nurse graduates, and gradually increased the amount of time required for completion. By the latter half of the 1900s, most programs were three years in length. Early graduates such as Linda Richard wrote rudimentary nursing textbooks and began offering specialty training to provide nursing staff for hospitals and clinics.

Until the 1960s, diploma programs were the major source of registered nurse graduates. These programs were at their pinnacle in the 1950s and 1960s, with approximately 1300 diploma schools in operation throughout the United States. In recent years, however, the number of diploma programs has dwindled to less than 10 % of all entrance RN education programs, producing only 6 % of RN graduates. Their decline became obvious during the 1970s, as nursing education made the shift from apprentice-type instruction based in the hospitals to instruction at the college and university level. Also, many hospitals could no longer afford to subsidize diploma nursing education. In 2004, there were only 68 diploma programs left in the United States.

Diploma nursing programs currently provide a solid foundation in biology and social science aspects of nursing practice, with a strong emphasis on clinical experiences in direct patient care. They generally provide more hours of clinical instruction than any other type of entry-level program. The curriculum is similar to that of associate degree nursing programs, with the primary difference being the additional clinical hours and hands-on experience. Graduates are adept in clinical skills and find employment in acute care, long-term care, and community health care facilities.

Most remaining diploma schools in the United States are located in the Midwest and East. Many programs still thrive in Pennsylvania and New Jersey. There are two diploma programs left in North Carolina: Watts School of Nursing (the oldest nursing school in the state) and Mercy School of Nursing.

Some of the most outstanding nurses I have had the pleasure of knowing during my career were graduates of diploma programs.

Specializes in Gerontological, cardiac, med-surg, peds.
nurse2009 said:
Its funny you say this since a hospital in my area stated they only are going to hire new grads from ASN or BSN programs no diploma nurses. I was shocked I thought we were the ones that always had the best hands on experience. I guess that is not good enough at this time in the economy crisis but I'm not going to let that get me down..There loss will be someone elses gain. Just move on to bigger and better things to come.

This is indeed sad. And, like you said - their loss. Yes, keep looking and I'm sure a good job will open up for you.

1 Votes
Specializes in Community Health, Med-Surg, Home Health.

I also believe that Diploma graduates came out more prepared with both, skills and the ability to correlate their education with practice. They didn't seem to be overwhelmed, had a greater deal of confidence and were very productive. I had hoped that even my practical nursing course offered more, but didn't. I feel that I missed out on a great deal.

1 Votes
Specializes in I spent 21 years in OB.

I found your article very interesting and would like to add on a little more information.

I am an 1985 graduate of the Ravenswood Hospital School of Nursing, Chicago, Illinois. It is and was a proven fact that nurses that graduated from a hospital school of nursing usually scored higher on the state boards and also had a lower number of new nurses failing the boards.

The simple reason for that was the extensive clinical training we received as students. If the state boards were made up of information learned in college courses required for a BSN maybe the college graduates would do better then the diploma grad. The school I graduated from had a 98% passing rate. The reason for this is when sitting for boards we were able to relate the question to a patient we had in clinicals, the deep research we did on our care plans to name only a few reasons.

As diploma graduates we did have A&P, Micro, English, Pharmacology, Chemistry. No we did not take classes such as statistics.

I am proud of my school of nursing and it is a very sad day every time I have heard of another diploma program closing their doors.

As a preceptor in Obstetrics I have watched many new BSN or Associate degree nurses who were completely lacking in clinical skills. Who would I want taking care of me or one of my loved ones. A clinically adapt nurse or a college educated (book smart nurse) Let me add that there are many excellent nurses with higher education but don't ever forget those of use who have graduated from diploma schools.

:cry: :nurse:

Gramobrn

Pingree Grove, Il.

1 Votes

Thanks for this article, diploma grad of 1982

1 Votes
grandmamaryof7 said:
I found your article very interesting and would like to add on a little more information.

I am an 1985 graduate of the Ravenswood Hospital School of Nursing, Chicago, Illinois. It is and was a proven fact that nurses that graduated from a hospital school of nursing usually scored higher on the state boards and also had a lower number of new nurses failing the boards.

The simple reason for that was the extensive clinical training we received as students. If the state boards were made up of information learned in college courses required for a BSN maybe the college graduates would do better then the diploma grad. The school I graduated from had a 98% passing rate. The reason for this is when sitting for boards we were able to relate the question to a patient we had in clinicals, the deep research we did on our care plans to name only a few reasons.

As diploma graduates we did have A&P, Micro, English, Pharmacology, Chemistry. No we did not take classes such as statistics.

I am proud of my school of nursing and it is a very sad day every time I have heard of another diploma program closing their doors.

As a preceptor in Obstetrics I have watched many new BSN or Associate degree nurses who were completely lacking in clinical skills. Who would I want taking care of me or one of my loved ones. A clinically adapt nurse or a college educated (book smart nurse) Let me add that there are many excellent nurses with higher education but don't ever forget those of use who have graduated from diploma schools.

From a newly graduate of a Diploma nurse thank you for your kind words and knowledge. Our class had 100% pass rate on the NCLEX.

1 Votes
Specializes in Gerontological, cardiac, med-surg, peds.
grandmamaryof7 said:
I found your article very interesting and would like to add on a little more information.

I am an 1985 graduate of the Ravenswood Hospital School of Nursing, Chicago, Illinois. It is and was a proven fact that nurses that graduated from a hospital school of nursing usually scored higher on the state boards and also had a lower number of new nurses failing the boards.

The simple reason for that was the extensive clinical training we received as students. If the state boards were made up of information learned in college courses required for a BSN maybe the college graduates would do better then the diploma grad. The school I graduated from had a 98% passing rate. The reason for this is when sitting for boards we were able to relate the question to a patient we had in clinicals, the deep research we did on our care plans to name only a few reasons.

As diploma graduates we did have A&P, Micro, English, Pharmacology, Chemistry. No we did not take classes such as statistics.

I am proud of my school of nursing and it is a very sad day every time I have heard of another diploma program closing their doors.

As a preceptor in Obstetrics I have watched many new BSN or Associate degree nurses who were completely lacking in clinical skills. Who would I want taking care of me or one of my loved ones. A clinically adapt nurse or a college educated (book smart nurse) Let me add that there are many excellent nurses with higher education but don't ever forget those of use who have graduated from diploma schools.

Thank you for sharing ?

1 Votes

I must admit as a graduate of an Associate Degree Program who later went on to receive a non nursing Bachelor's Degree that I did not have the extensive clinical experience that Diploma school graduates received and neither did I end up with an absolute loyalty to hospital based and/or Western allopathic healing methods. I do think that University based education for nursing has opened doors beyond the nurse as physician assistant or believing that Western Medicine holds all the means of healing. My own practice has evolved with a more integrated approach to nursing. I see the role of nurses as one that works with patients and families to help advocate for a healing environment and to explore with patients how that might look. In our culture this most often means machines and medications, surgery and technology. If the hospital is where you decide to bring your nursing care, it is important that you learn how to utilize the tools in that environment as they represent the healing "environment" in those places and the means to healing that a patient may believe in. At other times, patients opt for other pathways to healing and nursing needs to be able to integrate these other belief systems and pathways to best serve the needs of those patients and families. So while we might thank Diploma schools for teaching us to utilize the tools of Western Medicine and medical practitioners, I am glad that I received the more broadly based education with a liberal arts education that helps me to think beyond current models of healing and health care. I have worked in hospitals and community health institutions and feel that if the practitioners and patients in those settings require that I understand and am able to manage the technological tools that patients have opted for, those settings can take the time to teach me how to use them. I prefer that nursing education be increasingly focused on what it means to serve patients according to their needs, their beliefs and what makes them most comfortable and that we advocate for a plan of care based on choice, understanding and generous listening. Someday, maybe we will work for patients and not for institutions. When that occurs we will need a broadly based education to help us to understand and explore all the options available for serving the needs of those who are suffering from dis-ease.

1 Votes
Specializes in I spent 21 years in OB.

I just read your reply to me.

I was taught the holistic approach to nursing not just the technicalities of nursing. I will say that I take what you wrote as an insult to all nurses out there who graduated from diploma schools.

What ever made you think that all we know is technology, and hands on nursing?

Much of our education was based on family, patient, extended family, listening sometimes just sitting next to a mother who's baby was stillborn letting her cry, scream or whatever she or her family needs. I have spent over 24 years in the obstetrical field of nursing, believe me obstetrics takes in every aspect of a human being and their family. I also work with hospice patients this is very saturated with cultures and beliefs. Don't label diploma grads as machines with no feelings or brains to look at the whole picture.

I have become a bereavement instructor and counselor for fetal and neonatal deaths.

How many diploma grads do you think never expanded on their knowledge learned, yes learned in a diploma school who taught the holistic approach to nursing.

Again let me say I am insulted by your comments.

Kudos to Diploma Programs

1 Votes

I am sorry if you felt insulted by my post, I did not mean to denigrate diploma school graduates and if I did so I apologize. I merely meant to say that I do not think that nursing practice suffers because we do not graduate with the clinical experience that diploma schools graduates were afforded. I also did not mean to imply that diploma school graduates are the lesser in any way or that they do not continue their education as may all nursing graduates. I certainly don't want to play which of us makes the better nurse, there are benefits and shortfalls to most programs and I do think that hospitals can spend more time and money orienting nurses to the scope and tools of practice in that setting. In most schools we learn about the tools of the medical trade, which has changed time and time again over the last 100 years and what we utilize now will again change in the next 100 years. In my obviously inept way, I am suggesting that the basics of nursing education include much more than the much sought after readiness to work in a hospital setting and certainly don't mean to suggest that diploma school graduates have not learned more than how to run machinery. So many nurses leave university based schools feeling less than because they have not done such or such a procedure or mastered such and such a machine...I sometimes fear that they do not understand that these are tools of the trade and not the heart and soul of nursing practice that I believe has more to do with helping people through illness and life events using whatever tools are preferred and available.

Sorry if I have offended you...truly. This conversation about entry-level into nursing education divides us more than helping us to understand who we are. I have worked on the floor with Master's level, BSN level, Diploma level graduates all on the same night and it can turn out that the best nurse on the floor is the Nurses Aide...because he/she has the heart and soul and a calling to providing comfort and care...and that could be any one of us.

1 Votes
grandmamaryof7 said:
I just read your reply to me.

I was taught the holistic approach to nursing not just the technicalities of nursing. I will say that I take what you wrote as an insult to all nurses out there who graduated from diploma schools.

What ever made you think that all we know is technology, and hands on nursing?

Much of our education was based on family, patient, extended family, listening sometimes just sitting next to a mother who's baby was stillborn letting her cry, scream or whatever she or her family needs. I have spent over 24 years in the obstetrical field of nursing, believe me obstetrics takes in every aspect of a human being and their family. I also work with hospice patients this is very saturated with cultures and beliefs. Don't label diploma grads as machines with no feelings or brains to look at the whole picture.

I have become a bereavement instructor and counselor for fetal and neonatal deaths.

How many diploma grads do you think never expanded on their knowledge learned, yes learned in a diploma school who taught the holistic approach to nursing.

Again let me say I am insulted by your comments.

Kudos to Diploma Programs

ITA. I got a much broader and more inclusive education in nursing in the diploma program I attended in the mid-'80s than students have gotten in the ADN and BSN programs in which I have taught or otherwise had experience since then. I get really tired of the assumption by many that diploma programs turned out robotic technicians who performed rote tasks without thinking. My classmates and I graduated with much better critical thinking skills and clinical judgment than the students and new grads I see today. I deeply regret the loss of most of the diploma programs in the US -- I'm sorry to keep saying the same thing over and over on this board, but I believe strongly that nursing has really "thrown the baby out with the bathwater" in nursing education. We used to turn out much better prepared/educated nurses than we do now. From where I am now in my career, I truly worry about the future of nursing (in the US, at least) ...

1 Votes

Wow its so refreshing to hear that there are people who are proud of the diploma programmes in RN. I completed mine in 1996. I have met people different nursing collages, but still have to meet someone with a Diploma like me. I have always known that Diploma Nurses are best trained nurses because they know a lot about taking care of patients, rvs, medications and all aspects of nursing. I have seen BSN nurses who come from college with no clue of what needs to be done in the ward. One thing I know is that even though our diplomas are looked down at, we are full of knowledge. I am proud of my diploma

1 Votes
Specializes in I spent 21 years in OB.
ITA. I got a much broader and more inclusive education in nursing in the diploma program I attended in the mid-'80s than students have gotten in the ADN and BSN programs in which I have taught or otherwise had experience since then. I get really tired of the assumption by many that diploma programs turned out robotic technicians who performed rote tasks without thinking. My classmates and I graduated with much better critical thinking skills and clinical judgment than the students and new grads I see today. I deeply regret the loss of most of the diploma programs in the US -- I'm sorry to keep saying the same thing over and over on this board, but I believe strongly that nursing has really "thrown the baby out with the bathwater" in nursing education. We used to turn out much better prepared/educated nurses than we do now. From where I am now in my career, I truly worry about the future of nursing (in the US, at least) ...

Just wanted to thank you fellow Diploma grad. for your input. Maybe with enough oil to the squeaky wheel they will wake up and realize that what we got in diploma programs did in fact turn out wonderful nurses. And they need to add some of that to the programs of today.

I also graduated in the mid 80's, 1985 and 40 years old.