The Elephant in the Room

That our emotions and our health are intertwined, rather than separate parts within the whole is becoming more generally accepted in the mainstream. As health care providers, we talk about providing care for the mind, body, and spirit, but are we really walking our talk? In the Emergency Department, we are experts in diagnosing physical ailments, but we face significant obstacles when it comes to addressing the mind-body connection in a meaningful way. Specialties Emergency Article

We know that lifestyle choices affect our physical health. Smoking, drinking alcohol to excess, eating too much junk food, inactivity....these things cause real physical problems for many people. The diabetic who drinks Coca Cola, the person with COPD who smokes a pack a day, we see it day in and day out in the Emergency Department.

But there is another dimension to our physical health that those of us on the front lines get a frequent glimpse into. It's the mind-body connection. I firmly believe in the mind-body connection. I believe that we can make ourselves sick simply through psychological and emotional means. I believe that if you have emotional pain so intense that you try to suppress it or deny it, it will come out in physical complaints. Takotsubo Cardiomyopathy is a good example of this.

We've all seen it- the 30-year-old female with increased stress in her life presenting to the Emergency Department for vomiting and abdominal pain, for the sixth time this year. And, for the sixth time this year, we will be performing blood tests, ultrasounds and CT scans, and pumping her full of Dilaudid and Phenergan, which will not "touch her pain" no matter how much we give her. The only relief she will experience is if she is so full of pain medication that she is completely snowed.

She will tell us that her symptoms are well controlled with the medication we've already given her, but then after a heated phone conversation with a significant person in her life, her nausea has returned and her pain has increased. We overhear parts of her phone conversation, where she says things like "I didn't ask for this" and "I can't help it" and "It's not my fault", and we silently roll our eyes at the hyperbole and drama of it all.

And you know what? She's partly right. Most likely, she grew up in a dysfunctional household with an alcoholic mother and a stepfather who sexually abused her from the ages of 5-15, until she was finally able to get out of the house by running away, getting pregnant, or hooking up with another abusive man. She is right. She didn't ask for that, and that is not her fault. It's not her fault that she has no tools to deal with the stresses in her life that might seem like normal life stressors for a lot of us.

And so, she comes to the Emergency Department because her belly hurts and she can't stop throwing up. And she's irritating because she tells us exactly where to put her IV, and breaks down into sobs if it takes more than one try, and tells us she's a 12/10 pain after having had multiple repeat doses of Dilaudid, and none of her blood work or imaging studies reveal any physical cause for her symptoms. She wants blankets and ice chips and help to the bathroom, seemingly unaware that we are dealing with other people who are actively trying to die.

And then there is the Elephant in the Room. He's sitting there in the corner staring at us, but we cannot make eye contact, we cannot acknowledge him. We dutifully push the Dilaudid and Ativan, because the doctor ordered them and "pain is what the patient says it is and exists when the patient says it does", all under the watchful eye of the Elephant in the Room.

I think it's time we start naming that Elephant. I think it's time we start bringing him into the clinical picture. I think we can do this in a way that is compassionate and gentle and respectful. We talk about nurturing the mind, body, and spirit of each and every patient, but do we really do that?

And, I think I am dreaming. Because naming the Elephant in the Room does not help the bottom line. As long as health care is profit driven, this will ever be the case.

Elephant in the Room, I know who you are and what you're up to. Just because I don't acknowledge you does not mean I'm not onto you. Someday, I will name you. Just wait and see.

Specializes in Emergency/ICU.

We start out as nurses wanting to help heal the sick, but realize we can only help fix their bodies. We can't fix their lives, though we wish we could. Beautiful dream, though.

Specializes in Pediatrics, Emergency, Trauma.
This just isn't isolated to the E.D. These are the people that get admitted want their dilaudid and we spend thousands of dollars trying to figure out what is wrong with them.[/quote']

It's also in LTC.

I've been brave enough to spot the elephant and pull it out for the benefit of my patients; risky, yes, but effective...even if it means pulling out my mental health book once in a while...it's necessary, since I dance with my elephant :cheeky: I've been willing to point it out more than ever.

Specializes in Pediatrics, Emergency, Trauma.
We start out as nurses wanting to help heal the sick but realize we can only help fix their bodies. We can't fix their lives, though we wish we could. Beautiful dream, though.[/quote']

Eh, we don't fix...we goal set...I've equated nursing in terms if our "art" part is like life coaching...I give your the knowledge, you have to do the work; if you can't don't or won't do the work, I will do what I can WITHIN REASON. It's an empowering approach; helped me stay sane THIs long. :cheeky:

Great post!

Sometimes it's not so easy to identify who the elephant is.

His name is Trauma, often. Sometimes it's Alienation, Pain, or Anxiety.

If you're interested in exploring this topic further, I recommend Anita Moorjani's book "Dying to be Me." Anita had stage 4 Hodgkin's Lymphoma and was given 36 hrs to live, when she had a near death experience. During her NDE, she learned that all disease begins as a result of disturbances in a person's energy field before physical symptoms manifest. She says she was given a choice to return to her body and she did. A month later, her cancer spontaneously regressed and today she is cancer-free.

I suspect a lot of us nurses intuitively know that a person's thoughts and especially emotions play a big role in setting the stage for disease. Of course, lifestyle behaviors play a big part too. But this is where the US health care system is failing. It disregards the mind-spirit-body connection and writes off alternative treatments that address this as "fluff." It can be very frustrating to work in the health care system knowing this. I often feel helpless and unable to recommend things that I know would really help my pts.

Specializes in ER.

To some extent mental health issues exist BECAUSE the patient doesn't want to talk about ior deal with the pain. Trying to get someone to deal with "the elephant" would be almost impossible without an ongoing relationship- and that doesn't happen in the ER. If the patient is convinced that her physical symptoms are from a physical cause...we can't risk making her feel sidelined because all her symptoms are from mental health problems. Even when just a portion of the problem is emotional and 90% is physical, patients may think we're blowing off the real cause if we start talking emotions.

I see this as best addressed by the PCP, but not all PCPs are able or willing to do so.

Specializes in Emergency, Trauma, Critical Care.

Great post! Our docs are getting brave, if they see that the pt has already had recent work ups at our place, we do tell them, "you are not getting DIlaudid." Amazing the cures we are giving as they walk right out the door pulling their own IV out. I had 2 last shift...

Specializes in Emergency Nursing.
Great post! Our docs are getting brave, if they see that the pt has already had recent work ups at our place, we do tell them, "you are not getting DIlaudid." Amazing the cures we are giving as they walk right out the door pulling their own IV out. I had 2 last shift...

I just hate the inconsistencies between docs. Some are adamant about "not feeding the beast" and they deny the patient pain meds. Others just medicate them because it's the easy way out.

On the other hand, there are docs who don't medicate anyone.... even the ones who are truly in acute pain.

Ah, the elephant in my ER is called 'HCAPS' or 'press ganey survey'

Specializes in Patient care.

Awesome article. Can soooo relate:yes: