EBA 2011 - here we go again

World Australia

Published

On Wednesday Victorian nurses will be meeting at Dallas Brooks Hall in Melbourne to discuss the upcoming Enterprise Bargaining Agreement negotiations between ANF (who represents nurses) and the government.

The last EBA, in 2007, involved the nastiest intimidation I've seen in 19 years of industrial disputes in nursing, with blatant bullying from management. It took place after the introduction of WorkChoices, a Liberal Federal government policy that significantly diminished the capacity for employees to take industrial action. The first serious industrial action after the legislation was passed, the whole of unionised Australia watched this test case, and I suspect there's never been more pressure on admin to force us to back down.

That would certainly explain the unprecedented bullying tactics and threats I not only heard about but witnessed. Like many nurses, I was docked pay in 4/24 blocks for dropping my patient load by one and closing a bed - my hospital wouldn't let us put those closed beds in one area but compelled any nurse who stood by bed closures to sacrifice pay. I worked eight night shifts, in charge with a patient load, over two weekends, and was docked the lot.

We held strong, in the face of threats and with the possibility of fines and jail time for ordinary union members, and had the backing of workers across the country. I still get a little choked up remembering that walk from the buses to Festival Hall, the street lined with members of other unions cheering us on. I was convinced that, for the first time since 1986, we were going to have to back down or take strike action - the government had been totally unwilling to budge on anything, wanting not only to give us no pay or condition improvements but also to remove the world's first nurse: patient ratios.

And then the state secretary stepped on the stage, a little later than expected, fresh from a 12th-hour meeting. The government had conceded almost every point, in exchage for renegotiation in four years, rather than the usual three year term that would mean negotiations during the state election. The thousands of nurses present were jubilant, and it was just amazing. WorkChoices was removed by the incoming Federal Labor government soon after.

That four years has gone remarkably quickly, and here we are again. Despite a convincing number of studies demonstrating a clear relationship between a better educated nursing workforce and better patient outcomes (including the essential bottom line results of shorter bed stays, fewer complications, fewer transfers to ICU and fewer readmissions), once again the spectre of unlicensed staff replacing nurses is raised. Despite the massive improvement on retention and recruitment of ratios, they're also threatened. And now there are whispers of a new innovation - split shifts with time off between nursing periods, to reduce floor staff in quieter periods - four hours on, two hours off and two hours on, for example. I'm not sure when these hypothetically quieter periods are, but according to bean counters somewhere, they exist.

This is the seventh time I've been involved in a campaign of industrial action. I'm so tired of gearing up for this ritual every three (or, in this case, four) years. Of knowing that, in the end, we'll get what we want but only if enough of us fight hard enough. Of trying to engage junior nurses, who weren't here last time, in participating despite the short-term cost of missing out on a few hours of pay. Of having to educate the public, again, about how important it is to have qualified staff caring for them and for their families. Of convincing my non-nursing colleagues that this affects them, and their patients, too. Of short-sighted governments focusing on the biggest part of the salary budget as an expense instead of the whole point of patient stays, and a necessary evil to keep bed stays as short as they are. Of admin, who started out on the floor but have become more concerned about pleasing their superiors than supporting their staff.

But then I think of the support from patients, families and the general public. I think about how unifying it is to work together toward a common goal, one that benefits not only us but those coming in to the profession after us, and the recipients of our care. And I think about my family, and myself, who will one day need skilled nursing staff caring for them - educated nurses whose expertise can make the difference between life and death, between comfort and distress, between being heard and being a task. And I feel ready to do this again.

On Wednesday Victorian nurses will be meeting at Dallas Brooks Hall in Melbourne to decide how best to respond to offers that disrespect the work we do, the care we provide, and the indispensible role we play in the health and welfare of Victoria's citizens. For those AN members in the state, I hope to see you there. And I hope the rest of you will support us.

Yeah, this Qantas thing's ridiculous! I've just been hung up on by my (Liberal to the bone marrow) father when I interrupted his increasingly-loud tirade to say, for the third time in a minute and he sixth time in five that there's no point us talking about because neither of us will change our minds :rolleyes:

I don't know enough about the issues to say one way or the other but it seems as though most of the media and most (interviewed and aired) passengers hold Alan Joyce more responsible than the unions, which is interesting.

Part of me wonders how much of the decision was political - now the government and the Fair Work tribunal's involved there's already debate about whether the PM's too union friendly, which I can see being a huge campaign issue for the Libs come the federal election.

Mr Joyce was just given a 2 million dollar rise! and yet the airfares are still going up. He was booed at the shareholders meeting. He must have a hide as thick as an elephants! This leads to support of the workers. surely.

I think all the politcal parties are as bad as each other, :argue: I do not know how they can sleep at night, many of them, especially those independent ones(that few voted for) that are running the country!! Our constitutionalfathers will be rolling around in their graves.:no:

Specializes in Med/Surg/Ortho/HH/Radiology-Now Retired.
yeah, this qantas thing's ridiculous! i've just been hung up on by my (liberal to the bone marrow) father when i interrupted his increasingly-loud tirade to say, for the third time in a minute and he sixth time in five that there's no point us talking about because neither of us will change our minds :rolleyes:

:lol2::lol2::lol2: ahhh, ya gotta love the liberals! -[ fyi: i'm "nothing" at present! :D] grew up in a union town, belonged to unions all my adult life until retirement, was staunch labor in my early adult life. now .... the jury's out!:lol2:

i don't know enough about the issues to say one way or the other but it seems as though most of the media and most (interviewed and aired) passengers hold alan joyce more responsible than the unions, which is interesting.

don't get me started on that weasel!

part of me wonders how much of the decision was political - now the government and the fair work tribunal's involved there's already debate about whether the pm's too union friendly, which i can see being a huge campaign issue for the libs come the federal election.

of course! they'll jump on that like a full-back on the ball!

Specializes in Medical.

I think Alan Joyce's agenda is to kill Qantas.

Specializes in Med/Surg/Ortho/HH/Radiology-Now Retired.

It saddens me that this once worlds best airline has come to this.

Yet the loons in power keep alllowing into this country .......

oh never mind!

Specializes in Medical.

I feel a little traitorous but have joined Virgin's Velocity program. I think Qantas canbe saved but it'll take government intervention, significant industrial change (to protect our aviation industry) amd the ousting of the entire board.

Specializes in Medical.

I've been pretty slack with the EBA updates, but in summary:

- the overwhelming majority of members voted to be able to take industrial action

- last Friday we voted to implement soft protected action, limited to wearing campaign shirts, passing out information to patients and relatives, and stopping the collection of non-essential data

- the conditions of protected action mean a minimum of three working days notice to employers, with the action starting at 7AM tomorrow

- over the weekend a confidential letter from VHIA was leaked to The Age: they want to stall and delay so we have to go to arbitration, as Fair Work can't dictate hours, the number or qualifications of employees to employers, allowing them to replace nurses with aides, abolosh ratios and bring in split and short shifts

- yesterday ANF served VHIA notice that beds might close as of Saturday, with a members' meeting scheduled for Firday

- today a 51-page document by VHIA was leaked: it tells employers to photograph and document the names of emplyees taking unprotected action, details how to stand them down, and advises locking them out of the hospital

- the government denies that this will be done, which means either that they're lying or that they leaked it as an intimidation tactic

And now we wait.

Specializes in Surgical, quality,management.

I have just started back to work today but was in the office on a Quality & Patient Safety day so was stuck in meetings all day but it was a sea of red!! Seems really soft action though with the 2 rolling emergency beds seeing I work on the emergency surgery ward!

Specializes in Medical.

We really, really want to keep our action protected for as long as possible, and give the government no grounds for forcing us into arbitration. Fair Work Australia cannot make any determination about the three issues we care most about: qualifications of the workforce, staffing levels, and hours.

I know for a lot of nurses it feels like we should be more forceful, but there's a well-mapped strategy in play. We also have to keep the public on side - they're the key to our success, as well as being who we serve.

This interview on 1377MTR by Lawrence Mooney with State Secretary Lisa Fitzpatrick explains where we're up to as of this morning:

Specializes in Surgical, quality,management.

Was at the rally today. Was amazing but the public still seem to think it is about pay raises. It is about patient safety!!!

The rally was amazing the amount of nurses that turned up was impressive.

Specializes in Medical.

Good work, K+ :) I was gutted to be on the other side of the planet, particularly as the conference hasn't been nearly as useful as I'd hoped. I hear from friends who were there that there was a lot of community support, which is fantastic!

There's a great article in the Sydney Morning Herald that explains why ratios are important, so at least the news is slowly getting out there. But every time I read or hear "pay dispute" and "strike" I want to yell! I also want to ask the reporters how they'll explain it if we do end up (heaven forbid) escalating to actual withdrawal of labour - "Yeah, I know we said they were on strike last month, but they were really working all along, just being threatened and not always paid. Now, though, they really are on strike. Truly ruly. Oh, and it's all about the money. Over to you, Peter."

Specializes in Med/Surg/Ortho/HH/Radiology-Now Retired.

I saw something on the TV news this morning, but missed the details of the report.

I got the impression that things were shifting in favour of the ANF, but don't quote me.

My experience has always been that the public are supportive and encouraging of nurses fighting for better outcomes, regardless of it being wages, conditions etc.

Most folks who have ever engaged with the health industry as a "consumer" or "consumer" support person, know only too well how nurses are the backbone and deserve a fair go and decent wages, conditions etc.

Keep up the good fight kiddo, the baton's in your hands now! :hug:

But .... if you ever need a back-up! ....... :D

Specializes in Medical.

As always, Grace, I appreciate the support :)

I know it's going to upset a lot of ANF members, who are resolved and strong, but the latest directive is to halt industrial action by 9AM tomorrow so we can re-enter negotiations. It sounds, from Lisa's letter, as though this was a really difficult decision, and I hope my colleagues have the same faith I do in our executive's ability to see the big picture, strategise, and win us what we want :)

+ Add a Comment