Does god make mistakes?

I ran my fingers through his beautiful wavy hair. 3 years old next week! Wow, who would have thought! I looked to his face. Those eyelashes were longer than any I have ever seen. I swear I could feel a breeze when he blinks! Nurses Announcements Archive Article

Updated:  

I looked up at the doctor across the crib who is still hovering over him and checking his ventilator and trachea. Wildly he flailed as the doctor touched his abdomen. I tried to calm him by holding his hand. This is the first I noticed his fingers, some webbed together nearly to the ends, and the digits not coming from the palm in a normal way, but more like a sunburst. I looked more closely at him then. His legs were small and his feet were clubfoot. He has a feeding tube in his distended abdomen. His lips were cracked and crusted and through his open mouth, I could see several jagged sharp teeth coming from his gums at odd angles. Froth poured from his nose. Through his cheeks he had 4 pins on each side that were screwed into his jaw. The doctor was "lengthening" his jaw, it had been broken during surgery and slowly each day, the screws were separated further and further. It looked incredibly painful.

When the doctor had finished the exam, I asked, "Is he receiving physical therapy?" I wondered about his contractures in his legs. The doctor looked at me and sort of laughed. "No! I am trying to convince him mom to sign a DNR order, but she won't! This is his life, this is the best he is ever going to have. This is no life for anyone. He should not have ever gotten this far."

I looked back at the baby. His head is the size of a basketball. His features so close together they would fit in the palm of my hand. His ears line up at his jaw. He blinked and looked right through me, not even seeing me. Maybe the doctor is right, I thought. This would really be a nightmare life to have.

Back in one of my classes, we had a discussion about ethics. I think I wrote something that seemed right to me at the time; honestly, I may have just blown it off and answered what sounded good. I wish I had given it more thought. What right does anyone have to keep this child alive in this state? Why not just disconnect him from the ventilator and let him rest in peace?

Again, I ran my fingers through his hair. I changed his diaper. His bottom was so raw, it was nearly bleeding. He has chronic liquid diarrhea. I applied his barrier ointment liberally. He wears adult diapers. Size small.... This is no life, is it Little One? I looked at him and he seemed to look right into my eyes. "God doesn't make mistakes" someone said. I turned to see who was there. No one. Startled, I returned my gaze to his eyes, and he blinked, his stare gazed through me once again.

Rattled, I weighed his diaper, removed my gloves and gown and washed my hands. I sat down at the desk next to him in ICU where his paperwork is. As I was filling out his charts, his mom came in the room. We talked as she put on her gown and gloves. She climbed on the stool next to his crib and said "Hi Papa!"

I watched as they interacted. I saw the way he responded only to her, to her touch, her voice. They were connected. I saw the look of love in her eyes for him. Her face lit up, her eyes - I am not sure I have ever seen so much love in someone's eyes. I felt mesmerized by the scene, I could not stop staring at them. She talked to him and played with his hair until he fell asleep, and then she came to sit in the chair beside me.

She began to tell me about him, her family. He was the 2nd born child. She had had 8 pregnancies. After he was born, he was immediately flown by helicopter to this hospital, and she did not get to see him for over a week. He has had a lot of surgeries, she said, but he's getting better. He is my gift from God, she said. We all love him so much, his older brother wants their clothes to match so I have to buy them matching clothes, like twins! They love each other so much! He gets so happy when his older brother comes to read him stories and they like to watch cartoons together!

I wondered how much of this was fantasized in her mind - a strange way of coping with his chronic illness, I guess. Denial maybe?

But, it shook my foundation, my thoughts on who gets to "pull the plug". Who has the "right to be God"...50 years ago, he would have been dead and buried. Now, through technology, he is kept alive. Who is right? Who is wrong?

We, as nursing students, are encouraged to Know What We Believe. That way, down the road, we won't be shaken to our core when faced with situations such as this. I thought I knew what I believed. Now it is in my face. A mother looking down with kindness, compassion, care, love, gentleness and hope on her child who only seems to see her and respond to her touch and her voice.

A child that seems genuinely thrilled when she is near.

I now understood just why the mother could not sign the papers. She knew it better than anyone. God does not make mistakes.

Specializes in telemetry, medsurg, homecare, psychiatry.

"The child must know that he is a miracle,

that since the beginning of the world there hasn't been,

and until the end of the world there will not be, another child like him."

Pablo Casals

1 Votes
Specializes in mother/care taker/student.

Thank you for sharing, your story has truly touched my :redpinkhe. God does not make mistakes, God created this child to to open the minds and hearts of many. God placed him/her with an unconditional, loving, and selfless mother. Praise and Glory to God and this mother!

1 Votes

My great niece was born and her parents were told to take her home and love her until she died. She had a very high spina bifada and never raised her head. Even as family members looking in, there were times that we all wondered "Why"?She did not speak, we did not know what she could hear or if she could see. She was total care. Her parents did not see her as a disability. They loved her and praised her birth. The connection between my nephew and his wife was there in the loving way that Victoria looked at them. Every year they had a celebraton of life on her birthday. There were times that over 100 people were there to celebrate her existence. She touched many lifes. Sadly, one year ago we lost our Victoria. She was nine years old. Her shunt blocked and her brain herniated. She had suffered many things in the nine years that she was here on earth. She had coded more than once and could no longer regulate her own body temperature. Many testimonials were given at her funeral and how she had touched peoples lives. I see my niece and nephew in the reflection of that baby's life in your story. It is hard not to question when people are given such great sadnesses. But, like in your story, my niece and nephew never questioned God. Their strength and faith grew even stronger in the caring of Victoria. These parents do not see it as tragedies. They rejoice and deal with each day as it comes.

1 Votes

Beautiful story.

For the record, I personally believe Jesus came to show us HOW to suffer in the face of coldhearted people and stay pure. To find it in ourselves to forgive even as the cruelties of illness or other people drive nails into us.

1 Votes

Thanks for sharing such a heartfelt story. That was very well written.

1 Votes

Beautiful.

It's nice to know there are some that still hold belief in their hearts especially in a society that is trying so hard to remove God from everything and then wonder why things are so bad.

I am hoping those who read this article will be encouraged to keep nursing and caring for those who are in need and give glory to where it is due

1 Votes
Specializes in psychiatric, UR analyst, fraud, DME,MedB.

Amen ! I do not know why some people are so embarrassed or hesistant w/ their faith and belief ....what's with that??? I could not imagine a Godless existence. Be it a Goddess or God, this is still acceptance that someone , or something is much bigger and way much powerful than us . Some scientist do not believe in anything that they can not prove, but the deeper they try to solve something , the more they realize that "things" will not be in it 's perfect order , (such as the universe), if left by itself. Now think about it.............................:nurse:

1 Votes

so timely for me right now.

I have just graduated from an RN program. a month before my grad my dad needed emergency brain surgery for an injury he sustained at work. Due to a series of complications, what should have been a relatively easy surgery turned into him being put into a medically induced coma. It has been over a month now, and he is slowly coming back to us.

All the while, there have been great nurses, and there have been horrible nurses. I have learned such valuable things from both kinds. We have had thoughtless and hurtful things said to us, in front of us, and within earshot unbeknownst to them. There have been things said in the presence of my father who was in a deep coma, that I am sure he heard, because now that he is semi-lucid, he nods 'yes' when I ask him certain things to see if he remembers anything from when he was 'out'. My father has been treated as a 'throw-away' patient in the ICU because he is 72 and a brain injury. A few of his nurses never even bothered to get the back-story, and did not know that he worked for a month with a chronic subdural bleed after his original concussion, that he is ridiculously healthy and active and strong in real life. That he is tough as nails. That he beat terminal cancer 24 years ago when told he had 3 months to live. That he was put into a coma by his neurologist, he didn't go into a coma because of his injury. They treated him (and us) like he was a hopeless case, a vegetable. We were actually told by one nurse that his treatment was a waste of time.

The biggest thing I have learned is that it is not up to us to cast judgement on a family's choices for their loved ones. It is not up to us to share our opinion or use diagnostic or prognostic language. Our job is to support patients and their families wherever they are at, nothing more than that. The grief, the reality, the anguish and doom and gloom will take care if itself, trust me. We don't need to add to it.

I will never again judge anyone for not signing a DNR. I will never again judge anyone for any decision they make at any time. People do what they need to do at any given moment and it is up to us to be advocates for them.

I went to my graduation this past week, and cried as I crossed the stage because my dad should have been there to see me. I also felt guilty for being there because I was not sure he was getting the care he needed while I was 4h away. I did not trust his nurses to care for him without me there advocating. It occurred to me again and again that this should never be the case. Nurses should ALWAYS be our advocates. I have not felt that yet during this experience. I have told the nurse-manager of the ICU this.

He is slowly making a recovery, is awake and is starting to move his body, his arms and legs. His eyes open, and when his trach was plugged he spoke his first words to my mother in over a month- she told him she couldn't wait to get him home to his own bed. His response? 'What are we waiting for?' followed by a chuckle. The floor is abuzz with the news of my dad's awakening.

All this from a man who we were told would not survive, and his life was not worth the effort we were making.

As nurses, this is not up to us to decide.

1 Votes

Can I just ask how old he was?

1 Votes

Beautifully written, thank you for sharing! I'm very often thankful that God is God and I am not. Because if I were, things sure wouldn't get done right!

1 Votes
alaur74 said:
so timely for me right now.

I have just graduated from an RN program. a month before my grad my dad needed emergency brain surgery for an injury he sustained at work. Due to a series of complications, what should have been a relatively easy surgery turned into him being put into a medically induced coma. It has been over a month now, and he is slowly coming back to us.

All the while, there have been great nurses, and there have been horrible nurses. I have learned such valuable things from both kinds. We have had thoughtless and hurtful things said to us, in front of us, and within earshot unbeknownst to them. There have been things said in the presence of my father who was in a deep coma, that I am sure he heard, because now that he is semi-lucid, he nods 'yes' when I ask him certain things to see if he remembers anything from when he was 'out'. My father has been treated as a 'throw-away' patient in the ICU because he is 72 and a brain injury. A few of his nurses never even bothered to get the back-story, and did not know that he worked for a month with a chronic subdural bleed after his original concussion, that he is ridiculously healthy and active and strong in real life. That he is tough as nails. That he beat terminal cancer 24 years ago when told he had 3 months to live. That he was put into a coma by his neurologist, he didn't go into a coma because of his injury. They treated him (and us) like he was a hopeless case, a vegetable. We were actually told by one nurse that his treatment was a waste of time.

The biggest thing I have learned is that it is not up to us to cast judgement on a family's choices for their loved ones. It is not up to us to share our opinion or use diagnostic or prognostic language. Our job is to support patients and their families wherever they are at, nothing more than that. The grief, the reality, the anguish and doom and gloom will take care if itself, trust me. We don't need to add to it.

I will never again judge anyone for not signing a DNR. I will never again judge anyone for any decision they make at any time. People do what they need to do at any given moment and it is up to us to be advocates for them.

I went to my graduation this past week, and cried as I crossed the stage because my dad should have been there to see me. I also felt guilty for being there because I was not sure he was getting the care he needed while I was 4h away. I did not trust his nurses to care for him without me there advocating. It occurred to me again and again that this should never be the case. Nurses should ALWAYS be our advocates. I have not felt that yet during this experience. I have told the nurse-manager of the ICU this.

He is slowly making a recovery, is awake and is starting to move his body, his arms and legs. His eyes open, and when his trach was plugged he spoke his first words to my mother in over a month- she told him she couldn't wait to get him home to his own bed. His response? 'What are we waiting for?' followed by a chuckle. The floor is abuzz with the news of my dad's awakening.

All this from a man who we were told would not survive, and his life was not worth the effort we were making.

As nurses, this is not up to us to decide.

I can. When watch a 97 year old with terminal cancer, end stage COPD, and end stage CHF get her chest caved in and the family is screaming to do everything, yes I judge. In my head, not to them of course. And I judge the ones who rescind their family members own DNR for selfish reasons. I actually heard someone rescind it because they argued with their dad and they want him to live to make it right. I've been there. I made the decision and it was hard. But it can be done.

1 Votes
floridanurse1983 said:
I can. When watch a 97 year old with terminal cancer, end stage COPD, and end stage CHF get her chest caved in and the family is screaming to do everything, yes I judge. In my head, not to them of course. And I judge the ones who rescind their family members own DNR for selfish reasons. I actually heard someone rescind it because they argued with their dad and they want him to live to make it right. I've been there. I made the decision and it was hard. But it can be done.

I have to agree, at least partially. I can understand and empathize with those who don't want to let their loved ones go. It's an incredibly hard thing to do. And as healthcare workers, I think it's very important for us to understand that though some measures may be painful and have little chance of saving a life or resulting in a reasonable quality of life, a slim chance is not the same thing as no chance - there are some people who would genuinely want that slim chance for themselves, and their family might be honoring their wishes. I prefer not to judge or disdain someone making a hard end of life decision that I feel is wrong and perhaps cruel or hurtful - I know how difficult their situation is, how readily the mind clings to any glimmer of hope however remote, how much love and pain are tied up in that decision. I may falter in similar circumstances.

Still, what worries me about this thread is the notion that family and providers aren't ultimately responsible for the decisions we all make in a healthcare setting. God didn't cut a hole in a terminally ill infant's throat to ventilate him; God didn't break the 90-year-old's ribs with CPR to keep her heart beating for a few more days despite her advanced metastatic cancer. People did that. Own it.

Abdicating responsibility for the most difficult decisions might make you feel better. It can also be careless, callous, thoughtless, or cruel. The OP is beautifully written. It's also dangerous. I don't condone pointless medical torture. Neither should anyone, regardless of belief system.

1 Votes