Talk me into getting a LPN diploma over a CMA Associates

[AmeliaBe]

So, I'm finishing my associates degree in liberal arts this semester. Yay me! Especially considering it took me 20 years to do it! I'm in the process of figuring out where I want to transfer. Because of my experience in the birth work world (doula), I really would like to work in women's reproductive health (planned parenthood or a women's health clinic). So, I've decided that instead of going on to get a four year degree, I'm going to get another two year. My options are:

LPN diploma

Medical Assistant Associates degree

RN

I'm really leaning away from the RN, for the silliest of reasons. I don't ever want to be responsible for someone's life. I would rather be the low man on the totem pole for a ton of reasons.

So the choice then is between LPN and CMA. I know there *can* be a difference in salary, but that isn't my major consideration.

Mostly, I want to work with patients, don't mind a 50/50 split between clinical work and paperwork/office duties. I'm just trying to figure out which direction is going to offer me the best end result. And can't seem to get a straight answer anywhere.

So, what have you? Any thoughts one way or the other?

[8130]

LPN for sure! I have worked with CMAs for years and their frustrations are always the same: the medical coursework they took does not get them anywhere as far as advancing to an RN or anything else for that matter. I know you aren't interested in the RN route but someday if you change your mind you will be starting at square one. It always used to be that LPNs would at least get credit for some of their courses...please fact check this piece though to be sure it's still accurate. Overall I think LPNs have more opportunities too.

[lindsay199, BSN]

Get an LPN. No question.

I am a CMA and this is one of the biggest regrets I have. When I chose to go back to nursing school, I was at a huge disadvantage because of my degree!

Reasons:

1. If you change your mind, MUCH easier to get an RN.

2. LPN probably is a little more patient based, if you had to choose, since CMAs are trained on so much office stuff.

3. Pay is usually slightly higher, but comparable, for LPN > CMAs.

4. When people call you a "nurse", you don't have to correct them and say "actually... I'm just a medical assistant".

Best of Luck! I have really enjoyed being a CMA if you do end up choosing that... but I work with many LPNs who seem to just have a slight advantage.