Published
How do you all do it? Ear, rectal or underarm and add a degree? I am having a debate with a friend over the best way. She says the nurses in the hospital she delivered @ did it under the arm, but her pediatrician says that is not the most accurate way and to do it rectally.
I have been in NICU for 26+ yrs. We don't do rectal temps period, anymore. ...I think rectal temps are barbaric and should only be done in extreme circumstances (an extremely cold or hot infant or child, etc).
I work in a Level III NICU that is in the VO (Vermont Oxford) network. For those who do not know, the VO is a non-profit network of nearly 500 hospitals worldwide that are committed to improving care for newborns. VO is now requesting an initial rectal temp at birth, then subsequent ones can be axillary. The rectal temp is simply the most accurate temp you can get (there is not a baby SwanGanz on the market yet ). The digital thermometers on the market now has a temp sensing tip that is less than 1/4 of an inch long. You do not have to insert the probe any farther than the sensor. Even a 500 gram baby is big enough to have that done safely.
Just to play devil's advocate, for those who think a rectal temp is "barbaric" or "antiquated" how do you feel about giving rectal Tylenol or a suppository? The temp probe is a lot smaller than those are.
I wouldn't give suppositories with every set of vitals. That's what's crazy to me (doing rectal temps again and again). There are times when its necessary and that isn't every 4 hours routinely.
I never said that we do them with every set of vitals:rolleyes:. I said that we do them with the first set on admission. As I mentioned, I was playing Devil's Advocate when I asked about giving suppositories. So many in this thread said how a rectal temp is barbaric or old-fashioned or antiquated, they didn't say "repeated rectal temps." Our ED (a level I peds ED) does rectals as the first temp as well. It has been proven time and again to be the most accurate temp (other than SG's). Years ago, before the quick digital thermometers we have now, of course it was dangerous to put a glass rod in a little one's orifice and hold them down for five minutes. Today it is less that 15 seconds.
Should they be done routinely? No, probably not. But on admission or if an axillary temp is really wacky repeatedly, I think they are valid.
I never said that we do them with every set of vitals:rolleyes:. I said that we do them with the first set on admission. As I mentioned, I was playing Devil's Advocate when I asked about giving suppositories. So many in this thread said how a rectal temp is barbaric or old-fashioned or antiquated, they didn't say "repeated rectal temps." Our ED (a level I peds ED) does rectals as the first temp as well. It has been proven time and again to be the most accurate temp (other than SG's). Years ago, before the quick digital thermometers we have now, of course it was dangerous to put a glass rod in a little one's orifice and hold them down for five minutes. Today it is less that 15 seconds.Should they be done routinely? No, probably not. But on admission or if an axillary temp is really wacky repeatedly, I think they are valid.
I think most people would agree with that. I've said we do rectals if the axillary is wacky, just not routinely. I think routinely is what's archaic.
Personally though I don't even know why a rectal on admission is necessary if the axillary or temporal or oral is normal and I wouldn't let that be done to my child without a good reason.
The reason I said I wouldn't give a suppository with every set of vitals was just to explain why I see rectal temps and suppositories differently. We do temps every 4 hours so no one I know would recommend doing it rectally as a routine.
I think most people would agree with that. I've said we do rectals if the axillary is wacky, just not routinely. I think routinely is what's archaic.Personally though I don't even know why a rectal on admission is necessary if the axillary or temporal or oral is normal and I wouldn't let that be done to my child without a good reason.
The reason I said I wouldn't give a suppository with every set of vitals was just to explain why I see rectal temps and suppositories differently. We do temps every 4 hours so no one I know would recommend doing it rectally as a routine.
Now I gotcha
We never did them until about two weeks ago when the request came from the Vermont Oxford neonatal network for an initial rectal temp.
In the ER where I work, we get a temp out in triage axillary then when they get back to the ER Room , we do it rectally. I have seen a kid with a 98 ax temp have a temp of 104 rectally. THat is the way we do it and that is what our doctors prefer. If the child can hold the probe under their tongue, then oral is okay.
fergus51
6,620 Posts
Getting "the most" accurate isn't always worth it if it means risking bowel damage. If people are doing that routinely on every baby all the time that's unecessary.