No lunch for lunch break?

Nursing Students CNA/MA

Published

I work the 7-3 shift as a CNA at an assisted living facility. Lunch is served for the residents at 12:30pm and we serve them restaurant style and clean up when they are done eating.

After this time, around 2pm, a few CNA's and I prefer to take our lunch break. I've been working here for a little over a year and I always take my lunch break at 2pm after all the work in the dining room is done. No one has ever had a problem with it and I assumed it was OK because the Med tech and dietary staff and manager and front office people also take their break at this time.

In fact, most people take their break at this time because, obviously, this is the only time food is served and, obviously, people like to eat lunch on their lunch break. As far as I know, the manager and the people who work at the front office (The "higher up's") are the only ones allowed to leave work place premises to get lunch.

CNA's can never leave work (not even walk across the street to pick up a quick order) and I understand that because we must be here just in case the residents need help.

However, now they are enforcing a rule were we (just the CNA's) must take our lunch break around 10am and 11am, or basically spread out our lunch times because they do not want us all to take our lunch at the same time (2pm). Since most of us prefer to take our lunch at this time, there is no one working the floor to help the residents if they need help (except the front office, the nurse, CNA supervisor, Med tech and a few other people... That is, if they aren't taking their break at 2pm too ).

While I completely understand this and think it's ridiculous that there is no one to respond for the 30 minutes we are on break (unless the higher up's or Med tech was willing to help), I also think it's ridiculous that they expect us to take our lunch break at a time when there is no food while everyone else who works here have the privilege to go get McDonald's if they want to or have lunch past 12:30pm (the only time lunch is served). So they expect is to just sit in the break room for 30 minutes without food or bring our own lunch.

Something about this seems unfair and I am not happy. Is this normal or am I overreacting?

Up Vote Up Vote ×
Specializes in Acute Care, Rehab, Palliative.

Why would you not bring your own lunch?

Any where I have worked there have been set lunch breaks and there were usually two breaks so one half of the staff goes to first and the second half goes to second break>

Up Vote Up Vote ×

The only time lunch is served is between 12:00pm and 3pm, and we are not allowed to leave. The only people who seem to be allowed to leave or eat at those times is everyone, but the CNA's. There are times when I don't have food at home or time to prepare a lunch. Something about this seems unfair. But I completely understand that someone needs to be on the floor. But could that not be the Med tech or the nurse or CNA supervisor or allow some of us to break between 12pm and 1:30pm when all the residents are busy eating in the dining room so they would be free after 2pm to help residents in their rooms ?

Up Vote Up Vote ×
Why would you not bring your own lunch?

Any where I have worked there have been set lunch breaks and there were usually two breaks so one half of the staff goes to first and the second half goes to second break>

In these set lunch times, is there one half that must pack a lunch or eat nothing, while the other half has the privilege to leave to get food or eat from the dining room? If so, it is clear that one half is favored.

Up Vote Up Vote ×
Specializes in Acute Care, Rehab, Palliative.
In these set lunch times, is there one half that must pack a lunch or eat nothing, while the other half has the privilege to leave to get food or eat from the dining room? If so, it is clear that one half is favored.

Usually our cateria is open during both breaks but most people bring their lunches anyways.

Up Vote Up Vote ×
Specializes in Clinical Research, Outpt Women's Health.

This is pretty typical in health care.

Up Vote Up Vote ×

Usually our cateria is open during both breaks but most people bring their lunches anyways.

Oh, ours only serves after noon :(

Up Vote Up Vote ×
This is pretty typical in health care.

It is? This is my first healthcare job.

Up Vote Up Vote ×
Specializes in Utilization Management.

Take management and front office staff out of the equation. When they take their lunch break and where they go or don't go to get lunch is irrelevant to your position.

I'm really surprised everyone is allowed to take a lunch break at the same time. Who is taking care of the patients? It might only be 30 minutes, but a LOT can happen to unmonitored patients in 30 minutes. Break times for floor staff pretty much have to be staggered so someone (CNA, LPN, RN, whoever) is there if a patient needs help. How do you know the nurses' breaks aren't being given a designated time frame also?

Up Vote Up Vote ×
Specializes in Complex pedi to LTC/SA & now a manager.

I'm shocked you were all allowed to break at the same time. When I worked ER we had to split breaks over 3time periods. So buy on your day of and pack lunch for the week. Can you microwave at work? Buy some instant or frozen dinners and an ice pack and bring your lunch. When I worked nights the cafeteria didn't open until the end of or shift. The coffee shop was open and by no means was floor staff permitted to leave the facility during a shift to pick up food (sometimes we ordered delivery). Even in nursing school we brought our lunch on clinical days.

It's less fair that the whole CNA staff took lunch at the same time and it's irrelevant that other staff can leave for break. Plan ahead and bring your lunch or a snack. It's not an unrealistic expectation.

Up Vote Up Vote ×

Why can't half of you take break at 2, and the other half at 2:30? If lunch is served 12-3, then you all can eat a hot lunch.

Up Vote Up Vote ×

The nurse, CNA supervisor, Med tech, and one other CNA (if we aren't short) are free to answer calls. They usually take their break at 12:30 when we are busy serving the residents in the dining room so they are free at 2 so, no, the residents aren't completely alone after 2. There are two to three CNA's working the building, one Med tech and one nurse . It was were one CNA would take their break while the other two worked in the dining room to serve the residents because we don't need three people there so they would be free to help answer calls after 2, but then some people complained that the person taking their break at that time was slacking by making us work alone in the dining room. If it were fair, why not make it the other way around: CNA's eat lunch after noon while the others eat before noon? Maybe it's not meant to be fair and maybe I'm not explaining it well, but I really wanted to get an opinion from the people of this website because I trust you and I don't have much experience in healthcare.

Up Vote Up Vote ×
+ Add a Comment