Mount St. Mary's College or El Camino College??

Published

Hi!

I got accepted to both Mount St. Mary's College (which, starting Jan 1, 2015, will change from a college to a university) and El Camino College for their nursing programs and I keep toggling between the two schools.

I know that the Mount, is a great nursing school, but the cost is very expensive and has a lower NCLEX pass rate. El Co also has a great nursing program and I would probably save about 10k-15k (depending on how much I receive for financial aid from MSMC) if I decide to go with El Co, but what troubles me is that it is a community college.

This is my list of pros and cons:

MOUNT ST. MARY'S

PROS:

*Stereotype of private schools may come in handy when applying for jobs? Not sure if this applies to nursing...

*Reputation of school and program is long-standing (however, I've read one negative review about how RNs perceive their nursing students to be prepared-wise)

*Becoming a university soon

*Hospital affiliations (UCLA, Children's Hospital of LA)

*Contacts I've made there

*Small school and program

*Easier to get into their RN-BSN program afterward when you're already a student of theirs

*Beautiful campus

CONS:

*Expensive (I know of students paying $600-$900 a month with fin aid!)

*Consistently low NCLEX pass rate is a huge concern (they use Kaplan instead of ATI to prepare for NCLEX (ElCo uses ATI)...could this attribute to their scores?)

*Commute (30/45/60 mins (depending on traffic) vs 15 mins to ElCo)

*Networking further from home

*Potentially unsafe location

EL CAMINO

PROS:

*Rigorous program fully prepares students for NCLEX and jobs (from what I've heard)

*Reputation of nursing program is strong among nursing students

*Commute is very short (15 mins from home)

*Hospital affiliations (Torrance Memorial, Providence Little Company of Mary)

*Networking closer to home

*Affordable, way less expensive than MSMC

*Familiar with El Co since I went there for pre-nursing

*Contacts I've made there (offices, depths, profs, stud, etc)

*Small program

*Potentially safe location

CONS:

*Stereotype of 2-yr schools when applying to jobs? Not sure if this applies to nursing...

*No RN-BSN program connected to school to easily apply to afterward

Right now, I'm having a hard time deciding on which nursing program to attend! I would really appreciate hearing your thoughts. Please let me know what you think!!

Thanks!

Specializes in Oncology.

I'd highly advise against an ADN program at all at this point if you can get into a BSN program immediately and afford the financial and time commitment to go directly BSN. Many hospitals, the one I work at included, won't hire ADN prepared nurses at all now.

If those are your only options, the cheaper community college with the higher NCLEX pass rate is a no-brainer to me.

Thank you so much for your insight blondy2061h, MSN, RN.

Both nursing programs are ADN programs, it's just that MSMC offers their own RN to BSN for the third year, making it much more like getting into a BSN program in the first place!

Going to El Camino would mean saving money at first, but then I'd be applying and hoping to get into RN to BSN programs afterward. (I've heard mixed reviews about how hard it is to get into RN to BSN programs, so not sure about competitiveness, actually.)

Affordability is a huge factor which would force me to lean toward El Co, however, I'm eager to find out what kind of financial aid package MSMC will offer me.

If I could make it work expense-wise, I would go with the Mount. If there is absolutely no way, don't shut the door. Get your ASN at EC, and keep MSMC in mind for a BSN in the future.

True, thanks caliotter3, I'm going to get more information about their RN to BSN program for non-MSMC applicants.

I went back and forth forever with the same thoughts. I decided to go with the ADN program which i am currently enrolled. I couldn't be happier with my choice. I will enroll to a BSN program while i study/wait to take NCLEX. Is it true that BSN nurses are being hired faster than ADN? Yes! But, that doesn't mean they arent hiring ADN's at all. I know a few people who took really good jobs at reputable hospitals here in L.A. While it may be harder without a BSN, its not impossible.

Everyones situation is unique and our reasons for choosing one school over another are also unique. Do what you feel is right and that will be the best choice. Be soooooo thankful you have an option. A lot of people out there would love to be in your shoes rather than receiving rejection letters. Congratulations on getting in and good luck to you! ?

Also, my school (and other community colleges), has a collaboration program. You get your BSN simultaneously during the winter and summer. Check with the comm college and see what they offer.

El Camino has a great program. My God Mother is the Dean of that program. Visit the school, they have many opportunities for transferring into a BSN program. A ADN is and ADN regardless of where it is taken. You can choose to go the expensive route or the less expensive for the same degree and License.

If my scheduling was good at work I would be there but with my job I can't.

I don't know what you decided but to anyone that reads this in the future A big chunk of the LACCD school have a bridge ADN-BSN program. This program works with CSULA so people do the ADN work during fall and spring; BSN during winter and summer. Each school has 10 slots. I went to a meeting and the only schools that seemed to take advantage where PCC and LACC.

Go to El Camino, Mount St Mary's has a way lower NCLEX score and it cost way more. It would suck if you go some where like that, pay so much and still struggle with the NCLEX.

Oh and El Camino is a great school and it's closer to you. And I believe they do have a connection with a BSN program. You really need to go online and recheck this. I believe they are connected to Cal-state Dominguez. Or you could just go to WGU and obtain your BSN from there.

+ Add a Comment