Looking for opinions...

Nurses General Nursing

Published

I didn't know where else to put this, so I'm posting it in the general discussion. I'm in somewhat of a situation. A little history: I worked as a phlebotomist for 2 years, nurse tech in medical intensive care unit for a year, then worked as a surgical ICU nurse for 3 years. I've been working as a clinical liaison for the past several months (long story why) and have been looking to get back into the ICU setting. This leads me to my predicament....

I have been offered a full-time days position at what I and many consider one of, if not THE, top ICUs in the state. The only problem is that it's about an hour to hour and fifteen minutes one-way from my house. It would be 3 12-hour shifts. I am anticipating a full-time ER offer tomorrow, but there's no telling what shift it may be. It could be nights, evenings, days, who knows. The thing is that job is about ten minutes from my house.

Now, I absolutely LOVE ICU nursing. I love everything about it and this unit that extended an offer is a predominant cardiac ICU. I've never work ER, but know I love dealing with traumas. The only problem is that a lot of 'junk' comes into the ER, especially at the location by my house. Considering money is similar and the fact that I love ICU nursing as much as I do (mind you, I don't dislike ER...I would prefer it second any day to ICU), would you take the ICU position or the ER position. I'm just trying to decide if the hour drive one-way would get to be too much. Friends of mine that are nurses and drive an hour one-way now say that it's not too bad...it's their 'down-time'. I just don't want to take either position and then regret it later.

If anyone can give me their opinions, what you would do, and why, I would REALLY appreciate it. I have prayed about it and am leaning VERY heavily toward the ICU. The only thing keeping me back is the drive. What do you all think??

Thanks in advance....

Specializes in Cardiology and ER Nursing.

Do you live where it snows? Something to consider. A 1 hour commute in the summer can easily turn into a 5 to 6 hour commute in the winter if you make it home at all.

Specializes in Cardiac ICU/SICU/MICU/Trauma ICU.
My husband drives an hour and 15 minutes each day to work and does not mind it. I could not do it. I know you said gas was not a concern. It does not bother my husband. Between he and I were spending 700/mo on gas. It really bothered me.

Maybe you could get a commuter car that gets good mileage. Also what about relocating in a few months if you really like it.

the ICU job is in New Orleans and I live just outside of Baton Rouge. it's probably cheaper for me to live here than to get a place in New Orleans....that and i think i'd rather NOT live in New Orleans....that's just me, though. i love going to NOLA, but don't care to live there....not right now anyway...

Do you live where it snows? Something to consider. A 1 hour commute in the summer can easily turn into a 5 to 6 hour commute in the winter if you make it home at all.

needless to say, i live in south Louisiana and there's no snow here. it's always hot here...

Specializes in Cardiology and ER Nursing.

Only hurricanes, tornadoes, and floods.

I would agree with one of the above posters who mentioned a place to crash when you work the 3 12's. You said that you have family back to go home to, but if you are working 3 12's straight (I'm not sure if you said if they were in a row or not), then you are not spending much time with them anyways after driving and sleeping. Just a thought.

Specializes in Cardiac ICU/SICU/MICU/Trauma ICU.
Only hurricanes, tornadoes, and floods.

bingo

Specializes in Cardiac ICU/SICU/MICU/Trauma ICU.
I would agree with one of the above posters who mentioned a place to crash when you work the 3 12's. You said that you have family back to go home to, but if you are working 3 12's straight (I'm not sure if you said if they were in a row or not), then you are not spending much time with them anyways after driving and sleeping. Just a thought.

you do have a good point. i have a few friends who are in anesthesia/medical school in new orleans so that may be an option to crash at their place (if they're willing)

Specializes in Medicine.

I would commute for my dream job! You could always come back closer to home if you find another job that suits you.

If gas is not an issue and you're working day shift, go for it. Just remember you will be up early in the morning and will have to pretty much sleep right after your shift to get a good night's sleep.

Congrats on landing the job!

Specializes in Assisted Living Nurse Manager.

I commute an hour to and from work five days a week. My car gets anywhere from 27 to 36 mpg depending on the weather. If I am driving head on into the wind milage sucks. I spend about 500 a month on gas. I have been doing this for 5 months and I live in a place where there is winter and then it takes me an hour and a half to get to work.

I would think only driving it three days a week might not be so bad, but after a 12 hour shift, not so sure. I guess you never know until you try!!!!

Good Luck!

How do you like driving? I enjoy it. I have Sirius satellite radio in the car and just chill out. By the time I get home from work, I am destressed and ready for my family. My husband hates driving! Totally stresses him out. If you don't mind the drive go for it! Follow your heart.

Specializes in ICU/CVICU/ER.

If it's your passion nothing should stop you from taking the job!! Plus I like to think of my commute as time to unwind on the way home!! Good luck...listen to your heart!!

Specializes in Med/Surg, Ortho, Telemetry.

:) Go with what you feel in your heart. I drive 45 minutes to work each night and I don't mind the drive because I enjoy where I work. There are hospitals a lot closer to my home that I could work at, but I prefer not to. If you love the ICU as much as you say you do, then the commute to work is nothing compared to all the great benefits to working at this hospital. Good Luck!!!:nurse:

+ Add a Comment