Improper patient diagnoses and hospice care where I work is leading me to question the ethical practices within the organization. I'm ready to walk.
Updated: Published
In my previous employment, I worked for a company that owned and operated skilled nursing facilities throughout the western states. My position was at a newly acquired 64-bed facility in an area that was extremely aesthetically pleasing. In spite of the fact that the Executive Director lacked experience, he was given the opportunity because his brother held the same position at another facility. His father worked as an Executive Director before branching out on his own. At all costs, management positions are kept within the organization.
We use Whatsapp to communicate and someone asked if we had an EKG machine. Immediately the Executive Director replied, it's hanging on the wall outside of my office. Maybe I am being too critical, but I would think most would know the difference between an EKG machine & an AED.
May 2023 marked the beginning of my disenchantment.
One of our patients was referred with a diagnosis of GLF at admission. The patient had been receiving physical and occupational therapy for a week. To my surprise, he was evaluated by hospice and admitted with a dx of neoplasm of the liver. It is my opinion that he would eventually be an appropriate candidate for hospice care, but not at that time. He was prescribed MS Concentrate 20mg/mL, which was ordered to be given 0.25mL/6hrs scheduled and 0.25mL/2hrs PRN. In addition, he was also prescribed Ativan 2 mg/mL, which was ordered to be given 0.25mL/6hrs scheduled and 0.25mL/2hrs PRN.
Only one nurse administered the morphine and Ativan, and she was not even assigned to him. I for one did not based on my assessment. Despite never being assigned this patient, my colleague contacted the hospice provider to inform them that some nurses were not following orders.
Since the DON was on vacation, the ADON informed us that she had received a complaint from the hospice nurse. We were instructed to follow orders. MS Concentrate & Ativan dosage was also increased to 0.5mL/6 hours. This was then changed the next day to every 4 hours scheduled & 2 hours PRN. These changes were made without Hospice stepping foot in the facility to reevaluate the patient's needs.
It was just two weeks ago that this feisty patient was able to perform all of the activities of daily living without assistance, had a good appetite, and was participating in therapy, and now he barely gets out of bed and barely speaks. I was medicating as per the orders at this point.
After the DON returned, I sent her an email outlining my concerns and my opinion that he was not an appropriate candidate. In her reply, she agreed that he was not an appropriate candidate for hospice. His physician had called her to inform her that he had spoken to his wife and recommended that he be placed in hospice care.
At the time of his death, I was on duty, and his wife was by his side. When I contacted the hospice nurse, she informed me that she was not coming to the facility. However, she would call the mortuary to pick up the remains. It was shortly after midnight, and as I walked his widow to her car, she shared memories of the life they shared. Asked about his cancer, she replied that he had a golf-sized tumor on his liver about six years ago. It was removed, and he underwent treatment, and was cancer-free. I was confused at this point.
In the words of the widow, the resident was experiencing frequent falls, and his doctor informed her that it could be no other explanation than the return of cancer. Although there was no official diagnosis, she trusted what his physician said, since what else could it be?
The facility was acquired in October 2022. Various acute care hospitals refer patients to us, but most of them come from one hospital in particular. Considering we are strictly a skilled nursing facility, with no long-term care, hospice involvement is quite rare. By May 2023, we had two patients in hospice, and by June 2023, we had three more, making a total of five patients in hospice. I noticed that the same hospice provider was being used. During my time at other facilities, there have been as many as three different hospice providers.
I asked my colleague why we continue to use this hospice provider even though we know they provide substandard care.
What I was about to hear shocked me.
The hospice's founder and president is the father of our executive director.
During my fact-checking, I also discovered that the administrator of the hospital we received our referral from was a co-founder of the hospice. I met with the DON who informed me that it was the family's decision to choose this hospice provider as if these families were hospice connoisseurs. My position was clear that continuing to use this hospice provider was neither appropriate nor ethical.
I was having difficulty adjusting to the passing of my patient, which was made worse by the fact that he was referred by the hospital whose administrator co-founded the hospice. Whenever I was at work, I found excuses not to go in, and I felt ill every time I did. There was no doubt in my mind that it was time for me to resign.
Hello there. First and foremost I apologize if I upset you in any way. Having been born and raised in the Philippines, my command of English isn't strong and I often find myself struggling to find the right words or how to deliver them. Hospice was the saving grace for my mother, as well as for me when she passed away. My original post was not intended to be about hospice or about this particular patient or patients. In my post I intended to discuss ethical decision making as well as Medicare waste and fraud. The circumstances surrounding a handful of hospice patients led to the discovery of unethical decision making and possibly illegal conduct. However, this is neither here nor there. Right now, what concerns me is my inability to write in a way that does not lead the reader to make assumptions about what I intend to convey. Here is where I would appreciate your assistance. In your response to my post, would you mind pointing out where you read those statements I allegedly made? And more importantly, could you suggest another way for me to convey those alleged statements. I truly believe that I will benefit from this exercise in hopes that the next time, I will be able to make myself understood. Thank you again. ?
FolksBtrippin said:You can't assume the patient wasn't appropriate for hospice based on the info you got from the wife, and it isn't your job to decide that the patient is appropriate or not appropriate for hospice. That is the job of the hospice, they have to prove that the patient is appropriate to admit, and also that the patient remains appropriate over time. In hindsight, the patient died, are you suggesting that the patient was killed by the morphine dosing? That seems unlikely. When you held morphine "based on your assessment" did you call the hospice nurse? And why did you hold it? Respirations under 12 would have been a reason and hospice would have responded appropriately to your report. You should have been communicating your concerns with the hospice nurse. Hospice is in charge of the care, not the facility. You did not act appropriately and should not have held orders without communication.
MarilynM said:I was surprised to see the comment about MsO4 Not killing people, when it it indeed a Respiratory Depressant. I have been a Nurse for over 25 years, and have worked Hospice. It is kind of shocking that the Primary Physician assumed that this Patient was having frequent falls due to his Hx of Liver Cancer. No One requested any tests? Yikes.
As for reporting, my Stepfather had a fall due to Femoral Neck Fx after he stood up. He also suffered a Clavicular Fx upon falling. They sent him to hospital and did surgery on hip. He was discharged to a "Rehab Facility" 2 days post op. Shocking, really IMO. In less than 2 weeks, he had the absolute WORST St 4 Decubitus encompassing his buttocks that I have ever seen. I was working for the State at the time, and reporting to DHS/HHS was mandatory for any suspected neglect and abuse for my patients, so I reported it. I had a photo to share with them. Two Gentlemen drove to see me (From San Antonio, 135 miles) and interview. A Detective and a Lead Investigator. I felt certain that something would be done, and changes at that facility would be forced. To my disbelief, a few months later I received a letter stating that the case was closed. In this Litigious Society, we were not filing a Civil Case, although, my Mother should have considered it. When you can provide encompassing data to that degree, I really expected it to be cut and dried. So, Good Luck finding the appropriate reporting agency. BTW, My Stepdad was referred to a Very Good Hospice Inpatient site on a Thursday, received appropriate care and died the following Tuesday. God Rest his Soul. There was no coming back from that neglect. They used a combination of Haldol, MsO4 and Ativan that they put into a gel cap and inserted Rectally. Very Effective.
I'm so sorry you dad had to endure that lack of care. I agree with you about the reporting thing being very disheartening. I reported serious hospital violations to the state of Texas as well and nothing happened. I got the same letter saying my complaint investigated and done. If no one is being held accountable except for a scapegoat nurse here and there as sacrificial lambs, where is the integrity of our field?
I wish more people had the resources to sue and that administration had to pay it out of their own pockets.
toomuchbaloney
16,060 Posts
Details are important.
SNF nursing staff or administrators do not make the determination of hospice appropriateness, the primary physician and Hospice physicianmake that determination in with input from the patient an be family. The hospice plan of care is multidisciplinary and agreed upon by the hospice team and patient/ family. The SNF shouldn't be changing the plan or withholding ordered meds without consultation with the hospice team.
If you are working with a hospice patient and you have concerns about the POC, collaborate with the hospice team and if that is not fruitful make your case to CMS to address your concerns.