Hospital Denies Patient left to watch baby die

Specialties Ob/Gyn

Published

there has to be more to this story - i will post more as it comes up on our news

http://www.abc.net.au/news/newsitems/s1013917.htm

last update: saturday, december 20, 2003. 8:21am (aedt)

hospital denies patient left to watch baby die

a sydney hospital is refuting claims by a patient that she was left alone in a corridor to give birth and then watch her premature baby die.

karen middleton has told a sydney newspaper that she was originally turned away from westmead hospital in the city's south-west after being diagnosed with constipation.

ms middleton claims when she returned to the hospital some weeks later she went into labour 10 minutes after an ultrasound had been completed and staff had assured her no birth was imminent.

she says despite asking for help, she was left to hold her dead child for over an hour.

head of women's and children's health at westmead hospital, associate professor peter illingworth, says the hospital followed the correct procedures.

"this is a tragic case of a woman who gave birth to a baby at stage of her pregnancy before the baby had any chance of survival," he said.

"westmead hospital did nothing wrong in providing her care - she was examined thoroughly by a doctor and a midwife was with her during the birth.

"the midwife decided quite correctly and in consultation with the mother the right thing to do was to leave the baby in the mother's arms."

print email

Specializes in ICU.
Originally posted by fergus51

She obviously doesn't understand what happened from a medical pov. The article says she was 5 months pregnant. I don't care how long the baby survived (90 minutes or 3 hours), there is NO WAY that child could have been saved with medical treatment. It sounds like this woman is just having a hard time accepting that fact.

I totally agree and in fact the media has been relatively "silient" on this - I had to hunt further information down - I think the orignal report was put in the media and then they came to realise that something did not sound right.

Specializes in Specializes in L/D, newborn, GYN, LTC, Dialysis.

This sounds like a horrendous personal tragedy sensationalized by the media-----a common trick to gain ratings......

the victims are the mom, the baby who died tragically, and quite possibly, the staff they SAID did "nothing" while the baby died. Come ON---5 mo gestation is NOwhere near viable. And I too, doubt the woman stood in a hallway the whole time, it just does not seem right and something we would never do where I work------but if she did, that is a stinking shame, too.

Wish we could really KNOW what went on in truth.

Broke the baby's nose?! That's not possible. Not even on a term kid.:confused:

I think the sad thing here is that this woman has some mental issues that need addressing. I wish her peace.

+ Add a Comment