Do Nurses Practice What They Preach? Part 2

Nurses General Nursing

Published

Please Note: I do not agree with following article 100% due to the article proclaiming the benefit of drinking whole milk. Nonetheless, this article really depicts what is actually happening within the nursing profession. Not to flame. Just the facts.

Does a healthy lifestyle pay off? Apr. 29, 2002

Provided by: CANOE

Written by: Dr. Gifford-Jones

Have you ever wondered how much benefit you gain from being good? Saying "no" to rich desserts you've enjoyed for years. Tossing away tobacco, too many martinis and other vices. After all, why give up these pleasures if the return is only marginal? Now a Harvard study answers this question. And the findings even shocked researchers.

Dr. Meir Stampfer is Professor of Epidemiology and Nutrition at The Harvard Medical School. He reports a huge study involving 84,129 women. It's called the "Nurses Health Study" in which researchers have followed the habits of these nurses for over 20 years.

Stampfer confirms that a good lifestyle definitely reduces the risk of disease. But that's not earth-shaking news. We'd all have to be living in another world not to know that controlling weight is a prudent health move. That it's wise to avoid nicotine in the lungs, eat less fat and make exercise a lifelong habit. This study simply confirmed these previously known facts.

So what is so special about this report? Earlier studies had shown the risk of heart disease if patients were only partly virtuous. This study shows what happens when they decide to be totally virtuous. And the cumulative effect surprised everyone.

For instance, nurses who did all the right things were rewarded with a phenomenal decrease in coronary heart disease. They were 82% less likely to develop the nation's number one killer than those who were less virtuous.

The report contains other surprises. One would have thought that nurses, of all people, would be prudent about health issues. After all, they've already demonstrated an interest in health by becoming nurses and are dedicated enough about good living to enroll in the study.

But only a mere 3% of nurses were making all the right choices. And we know that this figure would be even lower for the general population.

Where did nurses fall off the heart-health bandwagon? Dr. Stampfer reports they skidded off at every fork in the road.

For instance, 25% of nurses smoked. A shockingly high number were obese. And exercise for many was placed on the back-burner.

Stampfer says the study also shows nurses were eating enormous amounts of fat in fast foods. But even those nurses who thought they were eating healthy diets by cutting back on all sorts of fat were still going astray by believing that all fats were bad.

For instance, most parents are unaware of the difference between the beneficial fats in milk and those in processed foods that can be harmful. The fat in milk contains 64 different fatty acids and many of these are only available in milk which is fresh, unrefined and unaltered by any manufacturing process. It is the preferred fat.

It's also been shown that growing children need the fat in whole milk. Children experience rapid growth during the first few years of life. This makes them nutritionally vulnerable if they do not have sufficient dietary fat. It's also poorly understood that children need whole milk up to 18 years of age.

Today, shoppers can choose from a large number of low fat products. But herein lies the trap. To make up for the lost fat something else must be added, and it's usually sugar. By choosing low fat products loaded with sugar, consumers are trading one evil for an even greater one.

This report is great news for those people who have eliminated several questionable habits. But it's disconcerting that 97% of nurses have such a bad track record. Time and time again we see how easy it is to talk about healthy lifestyle. But it's not easy to convince people to follow it. At the moment, all the recent nutritional research hasn't made much impact on either nurses or the general population. North Americans have a long way to go to reach Nirvana.

http://chealth.canoe.ca/columns.asp?columnistid=6&articleid=491

Specializes in Med-Surg, Trauma, Ortho, Neuro, Cardiac.

Deb, I'm really not going to get into it because I'm the only one who seems to not be offended by him and I do have to open my mind to the fact that so many people are. So I'm not going to waste my breath.

But I wholeheartedly agree that delivery is very important. But I feel his heart is in the right place. He's passionate about it and I know it's hard to look beyond the delivery, the message is an important one. The article above is frightening. We aren't going to be there to care for preventable chronic illnesses because we ourselves are going to be chronically ill.

However, I'm not sensitive to the title "DO NURSES PRACTICE WHAT THEY PREACH". Probably that might stem from the fact that I have issues with the health of nurses myself. Other people obviously don't give a second thought to the health habits of their peers. Nutrition, health and wellness is somewhat of an interest of mine.

But perhaps it's the word "preach" that's offensive?? Nurses actually don't preach health do we.

I guess I've said what I need to say. I know not everyone, if not no one, sees things as I do, and I'm o.k. with that.

I hope I'm not coming across as all self-righteous myself.

Thanks for listening.

Specializes in Specializes in L/D, newborn, GYN, LTC, Dialysis.

I guess we could get into a war of words......and...rights versus responsiblities, Tweety. Like I said, I see your points. And no, I will not preach to coworkers or patients about their habits. Do I care? Yes---- and i do let them know....but delivery, like I said, is everything. Why shut a mind or ears before you have hardly begun?

Other than that, I will not get into it with you about how I feel about the delivery of these threads; again, each is entitled to his/her opinion here. Good day, now. And no "hard" feelings.

Specializes in Med-Surg, Trauma, Ortho, Neuro, Cardiac.
Specializes in Obstetrics, M/S, Psych.

I'm with you, Tweety. All of us, nurses or whoever would benefit from better health practices. No one is perfect and we can all make an effort to improve our own lifestyle choices. I take no offense at the OP delivery either. As he said, he was merely stating facts. It's anyone's choice to be offended by them.

This old chestnut again!!!!

Thing is like everybody else in the world, we, (Nurses) are human, we sucummb to the same temptations as everybody else. We know what is good for you, but like millions out there we choose whether we do the "good" things or the "bad" things.

using the wrong word. I don't see healthy living as virtuous.

http://www.dictionaty.com

vir-tu-ous ( P ) Pronunciation Key (vûrch-s)

adj.

Having or showing virtue, especially moral excellence: led a virtuous life.

Possessing or characterized by chastity; pure: a virtuous woman. See Synonyms at moral.

These are the virtues that I think of and as far as virtues in nursing I think selflessness to care for others can come from a smoker an obese or tea totiller (sp)

Specializes in Med-Surg, Trauma, Ortho, Neuro, Cardiac.
Originally posted by Karen30

This old chestnut again!!!!

Thing is like everybody else in the world, we, (Nurses) are human, we sucummb to the same temptations as everybody else. We know what is good for you, but like millions out there we choose whether we do the "good" things or the "bad" things.

I know we are reflection of the society we live in. Society is getting fatter and so are we along with them. But unlike the "millions out there" we care for the ones who ravage their body. There's an irony that we ravage ourselves, IMHO. I think the same thing about resp. therapists that smoke. I wonder "how could they smoke knowing what they know".

But I wonder without judgement against the person. I understand.

Specializes in Med-Surg, Trauma, Ortho, Neuro, Cardiac.
Originally posted by CCU NRS

using the wrong word. I don't see healthy living as virtuous.

http://www.dictionaty.com

vir-tu-ous ( P ) Pronunciation Key (vûrch-s)

adj.

Having or showing virtue, especially moral excellence: led a virtuous life.

Possessing or characterized by chastity; pure: a virtuous woman. See Synonyms at moral.

These are the virtues that I think of and as far as virtues in nursing I think selflessness to care for others can come from a smoker an obese or tea totiller (sp)

I don't believe anyone was saying these nurses were providing poor health care.

I would rather be cared for someone with compassion, etc. How they live their lives really doesn't matter much to me if I'm the sick one.

The point being we know and see the ravages of unhealthy living day by by. One would think the stats would be better in this profession, but maybe that's too pollyannaish of me, or too judgemental. But I don't think the article said they weren't good nurses.

Originally posted by 3rdShiftGuy

But I wonder without judgement against the person. I understand.

:kiss

Originally posted by 3rdShiftGuy

I don't believe anyone was saying these nurses were providing poor health care.

I would rather be cared for someone with compassion, etc. How they live their lives really doesn't matter much to me if I'm the sick one.

The point being we know and see the ravages of unhealthy living day by by. One would think the stats would be better in this profession, but maybe that's too pollyannaish of me, or too judgemental. But I don't think the article said they weren't good nurses.

I was just saying that I feel this is the wrong word t use to descibe someone that takes care of the entire self, body, mind and soul I would think a good word would be hearty or healthful or wholesome even

There is only one way to nervana. It's CHOCOLATE.

Originally posted by Agnus

There is only one way to nervana. It's CHOCOLATE.

DEFINATELY!!! :D

+ Add a Comment