The Patients Who Break Your Heart

From the earliest days of nursing school, when we were taught never to become "too involved" with our patients, we nurses find ourselves balancing precariously on the gossamer thread that separates caring for people and caring about them. Nurses Announcements Archive Article

Being only human, of course, we sometimes cross the line despite our best efforts...and the nurse whose restless dreams are unpopulated by the ghosts of past patients must surely be a rare bird indeed.

I'll never forget:

1 ) The 29-year-old mother of four who was dying of cervical cancer. Cervical cancer! How many such ailments are both so easily cured, and so tragic when not caught in time? I cared for her during only a single shift, but something still haunts me about the way her mother sat for hours smoothing her long black hair across the pillow, and the quiet dignity that never allowed one word of complaint, even as the bitter pain of the disease and the heartache of her husband's deportation to Mexico at a time when she needed him most gnawed at her.

Meanwhile, the children played quietly about the room as I performed the tasks which must be done; they seemed to know, somehow, that this was a solemn time, and yet they were polite and curious about what I was doing for their mother. I heard a few days later that she had passed on only a few hours after my shift ended; and my heart cried out angrily for an explanation which has never materialized, even to this day. I think maybe I am not meant to know...only to accept.

2 ) The elderly but still vibrant gentleman who had just been diagnosed with Stage III esophageal cancer and given an estimated six months to live. On the second evening after his diagnosis, he asked my advice on chemotherapy, radiation, and other matters; his mood was genial, and he seemed satisfied after I had presented him with several different options. At that point, he called his family together in his hospital room and talked with them for over two hours, after which discussion he put on his call light and asked me to walk with him around the floor for a short time. This I did gladly, as he was a very pleasant man and I enjoyed talking with him. Then he stopped me short with this six-word sentence: "I'm going to end my life".

Of course, words of caution immediately sprang to mind---"You mustn't think like that", "Don't give up hope, there are still things they can do for you"---but died on my lips as I looked into his earnest eyes. This man meant what he said, and no psych consult, antidepressant drugs, or pleadings would stop him. I knew that as well as I knew my own name. Still, I begged him to reconsider, citing the devastation his suicide would surely wreak on his family and friends. Finally, he said, "All right, I'll think about it...for your sake." I was so happy that he'd decided to hold off on harming himself, I hugged him right there in the hallway, and when I discharged him home the following evening, he reassured me that he would still 'think about it' before coming to any decision.

The next day---or so the local newspaper said---this dignified, self-determined man walked out into his garage and shot himself in the head. And I've never told anyone about the conversation we had that night in the hospital...until now.

These are the patients who break my heart. Who is yours?

All of the above, and more. I had a guy whose brother slept under his bed in the hospital at every admission because neither of them had homes. We ordered him trays in the name of people who were NPO.

The saddest ones, though, were back in the day of the early AIDS epidemic. I posted this on another thread last year.

I'm old enough that I worked ICU when the AIDS epidemic was just beginning, and I was in the San Francisco-Seattle axis where we had a lot of gay patients anyway. I must say that it was a time when I was not proud of a lot of my colleagues. I would take my patient assignment of some poor man with what was then a fatal pneumocystis pneumonia (thank god we have better treatment now) and soon a fearful face would peek around the door with the unspoken question: Would this nurse let me in to see my lover who is dying? So many wouldn't, would shoo them away saying, "Family only!" as if the patient would have any family members who would even acknowledge his existence. It absolutely broke my heart. "Please come in," I would say. "I'm sure he'd be so happy to have you here. Would you like to help me bathe him?" "Can I?" "Of course you can, I'm sure he'd prefer you to me at this point!" The tenderness between these guys was indescribable.

I had one experience, among so many, that was particularly heartbreaking. I was floated to a general surgery floor for a coupla summer days and for some reason we had a man with pulmonary failure on the "hot" side of the house, where the sun just baked the rooms all afternoon and no amount of air-conditioning would keep up with it. He wasn't my patient but I covered him when his nurse went to lunch, and his light went on. "Hey, Jen's at lunch. I'm GrnTea, what can I do for you?" He was lying in bed with the oxygen on, sweating and breathing with difficulty, and he said, "I'm just so hot. Can you help me?" So I got a basin of ice chips and alcohol (remember that? We did that before we had cooling blankets) and some washcloths and started to swab him down. And he started to cry. I stopped, startled, said, "What? What? Am I hurting you?" and he wept and wept and said (and this is where I start to cry now and every time I think of this story, thirty years later), "Nobody has touched me for three weeks." That poor man, in the hospital sick as a dog and knowing he was probably going to die very soon, and not one nurse had helped him bathe or eat or turn as he got weaker and weaker. It broke my heart.

The next day I went in and asked to care for him again. He had been found dead on the floor of his room, having taken off his oxygen to go to the bathroom, probably because he thought nobody would answer his light, and probably desaturated enough to pass out. And they didn't find him until change of shift because nobody looked in on him all night.

Specializes in Community, OB, Nursery.

Oh God, GrnTea. How very very sad....God bless you for reaching out to these men. I am sure they are waiting on the other side to thank you themselves.

I have been working as a CNA for 13 yrs and will be going back to school this fall for my RN. I am asked all the time by students who come in our building"how can you do this day in day out?' Usually this was asked aftera particularly difficult day. My answer has always been...I don't know I just do. Sometimes I find a little corner to go cry in and sometimes I go speak with "grandma" who is a retired nurse.

The hardest time I had with a patient wasa patient whom I cared for on the alzheimers unit. She remained a sweet lady right till the end and her family was the kind of family you dream about. I held her in my arms as she died. She had bled out and no one seemed to be able to stomach it. Her last request of me was to have a sip of my pop that I had in the room with me. I gave a small bit in a cup, she drank it smiled and took her last breath 30 min. later. I was "ok" while I cleaned her up and got her ready to go out. Then her daughter showed up and hugged me and I lost it. This lady was only my second post care and 12yrs later I could still tell you what she was wearing when she passed.

One of my favorite stories will always be of an elderly downs patient whos favorite thing to have was mt. dew. oh and paper to draw on. I always knew that if I was having a bad day I could go see her and it would be made better by seeing her mega watt smile.

These days its realizing what an impact you make on someones life. When I came back from vacation recently made to cry by two ladies that some of the nurses call "diva A and diva B".I'm not sure why, but I have never liked it. All these ladies said to me was " thank goodness you're back because no one else knows how to make the good milkshakes" I laughed and cried at the same time. Something so simple, that they liked to have a couple of times a week. I also care for a lady who likes for me to braid her hair and she falls asleep every time.

I try to tell the nursing and cna students that this is what gets me through the tough times and I hope it is what will get me through nursing school at 40. I never thought when I started this that I would like ltc, but now I can't see working anywhere else. I don't think I will ever be able to not get attatched, but I wouldn't change it for the world.

Thank you for your story