Positive Thinking Is Useless By Itself

In nursing and other aspects of life, positive thinking is doomed to fail unless the person takes appropriate actions to ensure a positive outcome. The purpose of this article is to discuss the drawbacks associated with positive thinking. Nurses Announcements Archive Article

According to San (2006), positive thinking can be described as the practice of embracing the affirmative in our thoughts, our feelings, our actions, our reactions and our speech. Positive thinkers are usually brimming with optimism and tend to look at the 'bright side.'

However, positive thinking is absolutely worthless without action. People who are blindly optimistic often get themselves into trouble because they either refuse to see danger ahead or they simply don't do anything about it because they simply trust that everything will turn out OK (Bouchard, 2010). For example, a nursing student who has just been placed on probation for the rest of the semester due to attendance problems says to himself, "Everything will be fine!"

However, he still has problems with chronic tardiness and misses clinical at least once monthly. Although this guy is thinking positively, he has not taken any concrete actions to solve the attendance issues. When the director of the nursing program forces him to withdraw at the end of the probationary period, he'll be the type of person who tells anyone with a sympathetic ear that he was a great student and that the director unfairly got rid of him.

You can sit there and hope, pray, project, imagine, fantasize, visualize, make up great affirmations and just about any other kind of positive thinking idea you can imagine, and not much will change - at least not without actually getting involved, without taking some form of action towards what you want more of in your life (Bishop, 2009).

For instance, the pre-nursing student says that she was born to be a nurse and thinks to herself, "I cannot imagine doing anything else with my life. I will be a nurse!" Even though she is thinking positive thoughts, she has performed poorly in the majority of the prerequisite courses, has a 1.9 grade point average, and is not taking action to repeat the classes or address her academic weak spots. When she is rejected by several nursing programs, she will likely tell people that the process of getting accepted into nursing school was not fair.

In a nutshell, positive thinking is not enough to make things happen. Rather, taking positive action makes things happen. You can read a great cake recipe, but until you actually buy the ingredients, follow the recipe, and wait while the cake changes from batter to cake in the heat of the oven, not much will take place (Bishop, 2009). Don't get me wrong - positive thinking is a good thing, and an optimistic outlook on life is certainly more uplifting than a negative viewpoint. In fact, positive thinking can be the precursor to positive action. However, positive thoughts are not enough to make our goals come to fruition. To turn our dreams into realities, we need to be honest with ourselves, completely realistic, and put in the hard work to get the things we want out of life.

Work-Cited / References

Bishop, R. (September 7, 2009). Why Positive Thinking Just Doesn't Work. Huffington Post. Retrieved July 25, 2012, from http://www.huffingtonpost.com/russell-bishop/why-positive-thinking-jus_b_278572.html

Bouchard, J. (August 16, 2010). Positive Thinking Is Useless. Think Like A Black Belt. Retrieved July 25, 2012, from http://thinklikeablackbelt.org/2010/08/16/positive-thinking-is-useless/

San, M. (April 12, 2006). What Is Positive Thinking? WebContent.com. Retrieved July 25, 2012, from http://www.webcontent.com/articles/6/1/What-is-Positive-Thinking/Page1.html

I think your talking about "procrastination" rather then positive attitude.

I'm talking how self-help techniques in general sometimes itself leads to a sense of accomplishment and satisfaction, even though nothing useful has been done. It's not a matter of putting things off (procrastination), but rather, lacking the drive to follow through with constructive action. It has the effect of a drug.

But I do agree with you, positive thinking alone does not accomplish anything. I have no idea what "The Secret" is but I have never heard a motivational speaker say that positive affirmations alone were enough. It is just a way to get people in the right mindset to accomplish their goals.

If you read The Secret, or see the flashy movie, they will tell you that having the right thoughts will attract the right people, the right opportunities, and the right stuff. I shook the DVD box thinking that the action plan/execution part may have been on the second disc, but there was no second disc.

Reality is a cold science of numbers. What is needed would be guarded/realistic optimism or defensive pessimism. There are just so many factors in human existence that are beyond our control, and no amount of prayers, positive thinking can bend reality. Action is needed within the spheres of control that we have influence over. As the late Stephen Covey explained, there are things within our control, events partially under our sway and the rest are totally beyond our grasp to change. We can only adapt to survive in every situation that we meet.

I like that. Positive but REALISTIC. I'll be starting the BSN program and I am going to remain positive but take action.

Specializes in Med/Surg, Academics.

The examples in the OP sound more like delusional thinking rather than the negative effects of positive thinking.

Exactly. It isn't to just think positive. Thinking without doing will not yield any positive results. Everyone must practice what they preach.

posted this in general student forum:

study while others are sleeping; work while others are loafing; prepare while others are playing; and dream while others are wishing.

~ william arthur ward

I used to be a VERY pessimistic person. I have always had faith and have always prayed but the glass half empty person was there. I also had a ton of anxiety, I would worry about this, what if that, etc. I now am a firm believer in positive thinking. Obviously, I won't just be lazy and expect the good things to happen. I have to WORK for them. But with my positive attitude, the work is fun. I actually enjoy every single day. Sure, I have things that try to irritate me throughout my day. I do not let them. Yes, I am a person who has read The Secret and The Power. I am going to start The Magic in the next month. I cannot tell you how it has influenced me to change my attitude about everything but it has and I am much happier. I agree with what most have said here... You have to take action and taking action with a happy attitude is much better than a negative attitude. The law of attraction is real, though. The more negative I think, the more negativity comes to me. The most positive I am, I have only positivity around me. My mom tried to tell me this my whole life and I never listened until a few years ago.

The law of attraction is real, though. The more negative I think, the more negativity comes to me. The most positive I am, I have only positivity around me.

And therefore, those who are victimized are at fault? Those who are hungry?

I'm not saying that it's beneficial to go through life with a foul attitude, but the power of attraction thing has some cultish qualities. I've heard it before, in various guises.

The Power of Negative Thinking, New York Times, 4 August 2012

"Oliver Burkeman is the author of the forthcoming book The Antidote: Happiness for People Who Can’t Stand Positive Thinking."

Specializes in CCRN, ED, Unit Manager.
I wonder who came up with that saying. It's not in the bible. In fact, the bible counsels the opposite, something to the effect, "Ask and ye shall receive."

_____

Edit: The saying was attributed to Benjamin Franklin (as Poor Richard, I presume), but it did not originate with him.

That isn't exactly the opposite. When Jesus said "knock," "ask," and "seek," He was telling you to act. If you don't ask, seek and knock... you won't receive, find or have a door opened for you.

Just my 0.02.

Specializes in CCRN, ED, Unit Manager.
And therefore, those who are victimized are at fault? Those who are hungry?

I'm not saying that it's beneficial to go through life with a foul attitude, but the power of attraction thing has some cultish qualities. I've heard it before, in various guises.

Wouldn't the laws of attraction mean that negative thinkers attract positivity?

*head explodes*

Specializes in Hospice / Ambulatory Clinic.

Do thoughts carry an ionic charge? or are thoughts neutral?