The Ethics of Managing Your Personal Time

Ethics involves more than how we treat our patients; it involves how we treat our coworkers as well. Nurses Announcements Archive Article

There's a lot said about ethics in nursing, and much of it -- most of it, probably -- pertains toward the ethical treatment of patients. Not charting meds you haven't given or procedures you haven't done, admitting your med errors and setting about to mitigate the damage just as soon as you realize you've made an error, truth and honor in communicating with other members of the health care team. Those are all examples of nursing ethics and I won't denigrate their value. But it seems to me that managing your personal time is as much about ethics as any of those other topics.

Nursing, especially hospital nursing, is a job that must be covered 24/7/365. Nights, weekends, holidays and the night of the biggest blizzard or biggest tornado of the year notwithstanding, our patients must be cared for. If your nurse manager is getting married and everyone wants to be there, someone still has to work. If a valued colleague is being buried and everyone wants to be there, someone still has to work.

I will never forget the day a popular night nurse was being married and 7 of the 13 nurses scheduled for the night shift developed sudden cases of the flu. Six of them were front and center trying to catch the bouquet when the manager snapped a picture . . . and all of them were sitting in her office on Monday morning signing letters of reprimand.

Most of us have so many hours of sick time. We're supposed to use it to cover actual illnesses, although many have extended that to cover mental health days as well. That's great if you can manage it. Our hospital's attendance policy is so strict and so unreasonable that it mandates coming to work sick even while the written policy explicitly forbids it. If you're disciplined for using more than three sick days a year and you've already had food poisoning, an abcessed tooth with a fever of 104 and a child who broke their arm jumping off the roof just as you were leaving for work, you're either going to come to work with the flu or risk being disciplined. You'll probably base your decision less upon how contagious you might be and more upon how many occurences you've already had, where you are in the disciplinary continuum and how much of a rule-follower you are.

It seems to me that ethics ought to be about managing our personal time off -- and I'm mostly talking about sick calls here -- in such a manner that you'd be happy to explain your decision making process on "Sixty Minutes" , to your priest in the confessional or to St. Peter. If you're not sick on Christmas Day, please don't call in sick and force the rest of us to work short. None of us want to be there on Christmas, either, and we'd appreciate a chance to sit down for lunch to enjoy the potluck we've all contributed to. If you're not scheduled off the day of the unit picnic, and you can't arrange to trade shifts with someone who isn't interested in going, please show up for work. Calling in sick that day is just not cool. Nor is it ethical.

If your water heater explodes giving you second degree burns, by all means, call in sick. That's what sick time is for. But most people never have that experience and I find it difficult to believe you've had it happen three times so far this year. Ditto with the death in the family excuse. How many grandmothers did you have, anyway? Even if we counted step-grandparents and great grandparents, eight seems to be a bit excessive.

It ought to go without saying that we treat our co-workers with honor and integrity. Unfortunately, it needs to be said.

Don't blow off your call shifts. Saying "I forgot" just does not fly -- especially the second and third time it happens. If you're not in the ER or the funeral home, come to work on your scheduled Christmas and Thanksgiving and if your grandmother isn't dying, don't say she is so you can avoid work. There are times it sucks to be a hospital nurse and come to work when everyone else is having a good time. That's what we signed up for, though, so that's what we ought to do.

Specializes in CCU, SICU, CVSICU, Precepting & Teaching.
i find it hard to believe that for a 'caring' profession, people can be so uncaring to each other. what do people go into nursing for? makes me wonder if it's been for the right reasons.

sigh . . . another keeper of the morality of reasons for going into nursing. there are lots of valid reasons for going into nursing, and it's not for any of us to decide if someone else's reasons for becoming a nurse are "the right reasons."

Specializes in Geriatrics, Dialysis.

I guess I'm fortunate. Where I work there are not many nurse call-ins, and when there are you can pretty much guarantee that nurse is actually ill. We did have a CNA awhile bsck that called in and then posted pictures on FB of herself drinking at a party when she should have been at work...she didn't last at work more than a couple weeks after that. No, she wasn't fired .We have a no fault call in policy, we are not even suppose to ask why somebody is calling though most callers volunteer their reason for missing work when they call. I think her co-workers made her life at work so miserable after that incident that she ended up quitting.

Specializes in Mixed Level-1 ICU.

"If you're not sick on Christmas Day, please don't call in sick and force the rest of us to work short."

Nothing frosts me more than this perverted perspective. Nurses....you are not responsible for safely and professionally staffing your unit. But management has always loved the fact that you feel that way.

If your unit enters crisis mode whenever a person call in, you need to find a new hospital.

Until we all realize that it's staffing policies based solely on cost reduction that result in overworked nurses and patients at risk, this nurse guilt foolishness will continue ad nauseum.

Specializes in CCU, SICU, CVSICU, Precepting & Teaching.
"if you're not sick on christmas day, please don't call in sick and force the rest of us to work short."

nothing frosts me more than this perverted perspective. nurses....you are not responsible for safely and professionally staffing your unit. but management has always loved the fact that you feel that way.

if your unit enters crisis mode whenever a person call in, you need to find a new hospital.

until we all realize that it's staffing policies based solely on cost reduction that result in overworked nurses and patients at risk, this nurse guilt foolishness will continue ad nauseum.

i must be missing your point. to me, the above quote makes perfect sense. if you're scheduled to work christmas day, work. unless you're really ill. if you don't work, your colleagues -- who might also prefer to spend the holiday off the clock -- are going to be working short. think what would happen if everyone who didn't feel like working christmas day called in sick. there's no way management could staff the unit if everyone did that! personal responsibility -- have some.

Very well said, i work at a nhcc and we had a few "forget they were scheduled" on july 4m, and having less na's put the whole shift in stress, your trying to do your job plus theirs. when others call in you are taking from the patients care and what they deserve, as well as creating more work for your coworkers, our job is paitent care first and foremost, and if these coworkers have so many "funerals" to attend, maybe they should find a different profession. loved your article.

Specializes in Acute Care Hosp, Nursing Home, Clinics.

I totally agree. How many times have we been left to try and keep it together somehow when people call off for a frivilous reason. I had a C.N.A. call in on a Friday because she just found out she had cancer but she would be back on Monday. After empathazing with her situation and telling her if she needed additional time off, we would support her in her time of need, she said no, she would be back on Monday. On Monday she did return but was overheard while on break telling her friends she really went to visit relatives in another city. This post says what needs to be said about those who abuse time off with no regard to the people who are left to try pick up the slack when people call in for no good reason.

i would have guilt on my face to besides shaking hoping i wouldnt get caught! thats why we have morals

Very good article. Reminds me of the time when all the employees of a nursing home attended a Christmas party and left one nurse and one CNA to take care of the 172 residents. That one was obviously a blatant disregard for the poor people who made the employment there possible.

172? My blood pressure went up a notch just thinking about that.

Interesting read and funny too!

I think a lot rests on the management.

Having strict rules about calling out does curb the call outs.

i'm thinking how did the nurse and cna get all those treatments done and they deserved a huge rasie!! i work on a nursing home as well from 6:45-4, i have 26 to care for and barely get my tx and charting done! *ode*

While I do not endorse lying, I can honestly say that there have been times that I thought "really? Couldn't come up with SOMETHING better than that?" when staff at my facility call off.

I have gotten the old "I have a headache" call off six hours before a nurse's shift is due to start.

"I didn't sleep well last night" is also irritating.

"I ran over my neighbor's bike.". ???

And my personal favorite thus far: "I can't make it in to work today because my mom was supposed to leave my socks in the mailbox, and she didn't.". Just WOW....

Specializes in Geriatrics, Dialysis.
While I do not endorse lying, I can honestly say that there have been times that I thought "really? Couldn't come up with SOMETHING better than that?" when staff at my facility call off.

I have gotten the old "I have a headache" call off six hours before a nurse's shift is due to start.

"I didn't sleep well last night" is also irritating.

"I ran over my neighbor's bike.". ???

And my personal favorite thus far: "I can't make it in to work today because my mom was supposed to leave my socks in the mailbox, and she didn't.". Just WOW....

socks in the mailbox! That is a new one, and at least scores originality points.