Who Let the Dogs Out in Nursing?

Dogs have long been considered man’s best friend. Sometimes “yes” and sometimes “no”. This article discusses the differences between service, therapy and support dogs and provides examples of dogs at work in nursing practice settings. Nurses Disabilities Article

Updated:  

Anyone who knows me knows I LOVE dogs (especially black labs)! My daughter, Lauren, is 28 and diagnosed on the autism spectrum. She has a service dog from Canine Companions for Independence. Mr. Toy (Toyon is his real name) has helped Lauren in many ways and quickly became the love and joy of our family.

But all dogs (wearing a vest) are not the same!

Service dogs work tirelessly to assist people with a variety of disabilities and healthcare challenges. Service dogs assist people with paralysis, hearing loss, vision loss and PTSD. They alert people who suffer from epilepsy or diabetes and help to deescalate behavioral challenges for people on the autism spectrum.

Service dogs are considered a reasonable accommodation under the Americans with Disabilities Act- if the service dog's work or task is directly related to the person's disability. The dog's handler is trained and responsible for the dog's care and behavior.

"Under the ADA, State and local governments, businesses, and nonprofit organizations that serve the public generally must allow service animals to accompany people with disabilities in all areas of the facility where the public is normally allowed to go. For example, in a hospital, it would be inappropriate to exclude a service animal from areas such as patient rooms, clinics, cafeterias, or examination rooms. However, it may be appropriate to exclude a service animal from operating rooms or burn units where the animal's presence may compromise a sterile environment." (ADA, 2010)

Service dogs

A service dog is individually trained to do work or perform tasks for the benefit of an individual with a disability, including a physical, sensory, psychiatric, intellectual, or other mental disability. Tasks performed can include, among other things, pulling a wheelchair, retrieving dropped items, alerting a person to a sound, reminding a person to take medication, or pressing an elevator button.

Service dogs at work

A pediatric nurse practitioner works with her service dog at a children's hospital in Colorado. Staff and patients have come to know and love her dog as much as she does! (Canine Companions for Independence).

A hospital administrator, who suffered a spinal cord injury, works with his service dog making rounds throughout the hospital. Pollyanna, an almost-white yellow Lab has been trained to turn on lights, open and close doors, go for help, warn about obstacles and retrieve keys or dropped items (Associated Press, 2015).

A nurse with vision loss due to retinitis pigmentosa works as a diabetic nurse educator. She graduated with a master's in nursing education. She recalls" I don't know whose smile is bigger in the graduation photo--my guide dog's or mine....the entire audience gave us a standing ovation as we crossed the stage to receive our degree" (Maheady, 2006, p.46).

A nursing student who suffers from dysautonomia (which causes her to fall) relies on her service dog to maintain her balance, get help and help her up. The student recently graduated with her BSN. (Happy Hudson).

Therapy dogs

Emotional support, comfort, and therapy dogs are not considered service animals under Title II and Title III of the ADA. The work or tasks performed by a service animal must be directly related to the individual's disability.

Emotional support, comfort or therapy dogs are often used as part of a medical treatment plan, but they are not considered service animals under the ADA. Support dogs can provide companionship, relieve loneliness, and sometimes help with depression, anxiety, and certain phobias, but do not have special training to perform tasks that assist people with disabilities.

Pet therapy programs staffed with volunteers bring dogs to pediatric oncology units to provide support and comfort to patients. In other programs, volunteers bring therapy dogs to residential/ mental health treatment centers.

A nurse in Illinois and her therapy partner, Tori, the Labradoodle, bring joy and comfort to patients going through chemotherapy (Larson, 2011). They can't walk down the hall without drawing a crowd!

In a nursing home, a poodle goes door to door visiting patients while her owner works as a medication assistant. "Nala" jumps on beds and laps to offer kisses. The residents love her (Swartz, 2015).

Some service dogs crossover roles

A nurse with multiple sclerosis uses a scooter and has a service dog "Georgia". They both volunteer at a local hospital's rehabilitation center. Georgia comforts patients and works with the physical therapist to assist and motivate patients involved in therapy sessions. Georgia crosses over in her roles...she is a service dog to the nurse, but she also "volunteers" as a therapy dog with patients in the rehabilitation center.

Dogs have proven (with proper training) to be an asset to independence for many people with disabilities. In addition, they can facilitate wellness, provide comfort and unconditional love. Dogs can connect with people in special ways.

So...the dogs are "out"!

Are service dogs working where you are employed? If so, in what type of setting? Hospital floor? Rehabilitation center? Community center for children with disabilities? Health Department? Long term care facility? Hospice?

Love to have you share your thoughts and experiences related to this topic.

References

ADA, (2010). Accessed July 14, 2015 ADA.gov homepage

Associated Press (2015). Service dog forges friendship with paralyzed man. Accessed July 14, 2015

Canine lifeguards doggie paddle to the rescue Companions for Independence (n.d.) Accessed on July 14, 2015

Hudson Valley (n.d.) Happy graduation for nursing student. Accessed on July 14, 2015 Happy Hudson Valley | Our news is good news,

Larson, J. (2011). Pet Therapy Programs Benefit Patients Physically and Emotionally. Accessed on July 14, 2015 NurseZone.

Maheady, D. (2006). Leave No Nurse Behind: Nurses working with disAbilities. New York: iUniverse.

Swartz, A. (2015). Poodle goes door to door at nursing home. Every day. All by herself. Accessed July 14, 2015

Specializes in Pediatrics, developmental disabilities.

You are preaching to the choir! Thanks for commenting.

Specializes in Med nurse in med-surg., float, HH, and PDN.

Before Therapy Dogs were a widely accepted thing I took my dog on my weekend rounds of Home Health visits. He even had a photo ID from my company with the title"HHD" (home health dog). Most patients LOVED him, and of course he thought everyone was in his fan club. He wasn't officially trained, he was just well-behaved and intuitive. Some patients ALWAYS wanted him to come in with me, others, not so enthusiastic.

One man who raised dogs when he was younger asked me to call him 5 min before I would arrive. He would then unlock the door and go into the bedroom and lie down in bed, pretending to be asleep. When we walked into this man's house I would say "Go wake him up!", and the dog would race back into the bedroom and leap up on the guy's bed....exactly what he wanted the dog to do. It gave him such joy to be 'woken up' by a dog again.

Another dog lover was a hospice patient w/ terminal CA. My dog would go into the bedroom and ease up on the lady's bed and snuggle up quietly against her side. It was so sweet. The lady's sister came from another state to be with her during her last weeks. When she saw the dog get up onto her sister's bed, she said. "Do you really think that's a good idea? Dogs can carry germs, you know." My patient was quite exasperated and said, "For God's sake! I'm dying of cancer....do you REALLY think I'm going to worry about dog germs at this point in my life?"

This dog was a 2 y.o. stray who jumped into my car the minute I opened the car door, about to go into another patient's house....It was Valentine's Day when he found me. He accompanied me on my rounds every weekend for 9 years. after that....at first because I thought I could locate his owner. I knew if he had been my dog, I would've been frantic if he went missing. The lady in front of whose house he found me pointed out that I would never "find" the dog's owner becuse I was now his owner. She said, "Honey, that's God's dog and you have been brought together because you need each other."

She was right on the money about that! He saw me through 3 months of healing from a broken ankle; also, a rough period when hubby and I were not very happy with one another. He got me out of the house to go walking (and mole hunting; he LOVED digging for moles so I would take him places where he could dig to his heart's content and not upset anybody by gouging up their lawns.) He went on a two week road trip with my sister and mother and me.

It's been eight years since I had to have him put down because his adrenal glands went kerflooey. I still miss him every day.

Specializes in SICU, trauma, neuro.
What about patients who have dog allergies? No problem if the NP's therapy dog is a labradoodle or other hypoallergenic breed, but very quickly it becomes a case of one person's rights imposing on another's in some instances?

Very good point. Were they to meet a service animal in the store, they have the option to leave if they are allergic. A pt in the hospital or SNF doesn't have the choice to get away from the dog in the unit.

And may be inappropriate to allow into the OR or Burn unit?? Really? Is that even a question?

Specializes in Med nurse in med-surg., float, HH, and PDN.

Every service dog and handler I've ever seen at any facility ALWAYS asks permission before entering a room or allowing the dog to approach someone. And certainly common sense would dictate that dogs not be allowed in certain areas.

Specializes in Pediatrics, developmental disabilities.

What a beautiful story. Thanks so much for sharing.

Loved the story about the man who wanted to be woken up by a dog again....oh the little things that mean so much!

I've had two experiences with service dogs and they were not at all pleasant. The first one was with a family member's 2 standard poodles Standard Poodle Information, Pictures of Standard Poodles | Dogster. She was crippled and walked with a walker. She had a friend and the 2 dogs went into my patients room and closed the door. I am a staff nurse on a cardiac floor and the patient came in with chest pain. When it came time for me to go in and give the patient some medication I knocked on the door and before I could get the door open for me and the med cart the 2 service dogs barked and charged out the door almost knocking me and my cart over. They rushed past me and the owners came out and said they never do that and obtained control of them and went back into the room. Afterward I told my charge nurse about the dogs and their barking and running me over. He went in to talk to them and the dogs barked at him. They told him it was my fault. I had opened the door and startled the dogs. So, the charge asked them to leave the door open so the dogs could see that there was other people here and get them accustom to flow of our some what busy floor. Well, the dogs barked at the tray passer that came by to pick up the dinner tray. The next day when the patient came back from the cath lab the youngest dog (6mos old) came in while I was doing my assessment and placing the patient on telemetry and oxygen and proceeded to jump right on the patient's groin where he was freshly cathed. The family member had no control over the animal at all. Risk management was notified twice in regard to the dogs barking and jumping on the patients groin. The only thing that was ever done was the charge nurse and the house supervisor was sent to talk to the dogs owner.

My most recent and second experience was with a homeless man with a service dog who demanded hospital staff to take his dog outside to go potty. He threaten to call the Senator when we told him we could not do that.

We have seen an increase on "Service Dog" ownership on our unit and have been made aware of a site https://www.officialservicedogregistry.com/ where anyone can get a service dog vest for their dog for $50. Even people joke about it being their service dog. For me it's been hard to be the nurse for patients with such protective dogs. The homeless man's dog nipped at me when during shift change rounds I reached for the patients arm to show the on coming nurse the IV.

I'm glad to see this post. Nursing is changing in so many ways twenty years ago I would have never thought I would be dealing with this.

We have therapy dogs in our facility. When I had a young woman who was so needle-phobic that she was losing it (before having a needed diagnostic procedure requiring sedation), I had one of the dogs come and sit next to her on the other side of me. We held a blanket up between us, with only her arm out. Had that IV placed in a jiffy as she petted the dog, and the dog walked her back to the procedure room. Turned it around 180 degrees.

Fake service animals really make me mad because they cause trouble for those who truly need them, who get hassled because they aren't instantly identifiable with an issue, i.e. Vets with PTSD dogs.

Specializes in Pediatrics, developmental disabilities.
We have therapy dogs in our facility. When I had a young woman who was so needle-phobic that she was losing it (before having a needed diagnostic procedure requiring sedation), I had one of the dogs come and sit next to her on the other side of me. We held a blanket up between us, with only her arm out. Had that IV placed in a jiffy as she petted the dog, and the dog walked her back to the procedure room. Turned it around 180 degrees. Fake service animals really make me mad because they cause trouble for those who truly need them, who get hassled because they aren't instantly identifiable with an issue, i.e. Vets with PTSD dogs.
Thanks so much for sharing this story...awesome!

I'm late on the uptake here, but I'm so happy to find this article! I have a diabetes alert dog, and am starting nursing school in August. I'm doing a graduate entry program, so I will only have about a year on the floor before moving on to advanced classes, but my DAD will be coming with me to clinicals. It is doable, especially because these dogs have amazing abilities. In my case, Fleur (my DAD) can pick up on the scent of my blood sugar levels falling, and will warn before they get low. WIth her help, I have avoided many dangerous situations. I plan on having a kennel for her in some central area, out of the way of patients. I will not bring her in to each room with me, but I do know another nursing student with a DAD who does. In Fleur's case, I will check in with her every so often, and she will be able to alert me if needed. I'm considering rigging a button that she can push that will notify me, but that's pretty high tech, even for a dog with her smarts!

After school I will be a Pediatric NP, so I look forward to having her in my practice. It is doable with a service dog!! Having Fleur with me is much better than the alternative (my blood sugar getting so low that I am not able to provide good patient care). Obviously there are better nursing paths than others - I would never want to work in a burn unit or ICU, just because I know that asking for accommodations in those places are unreasonable. But, I will be a nurse with a service dog, and there aren't many of us out there!