The Struggle: When A Nurse Diverts

Published

We often read and hear about nurses, physicians, and pharmacists getting caught diverting drugs in health care facilities. Some have wondered after the fact, how could this go unnoticed? And how could this go unnoticed for so long? When it actually happens to a colleague, I would think the normal response would be picking your jaw off the floor. But, it does happen. That is a major reason why health care facilities employ monitoring programs.

The intent of this post is to share an experience about a former colleague, a colleague who diverted and was eventually caught. This situation happened several years ago. This colleague had been a nurse for a very long time, in her 50's, and married. Both made good money, and lived in (what I heard was) a beautiful home. At work, for the most part, she was very helpful in lending a hand, often smiling, and advocating for her patients. Life appeared good for her. And for the most part, she was a most excellent nurse. She looked after her patients, often speaking of them fondly.

However, in a relatively short period of time (let's say, over a period of a year), her baseline behaviors began changing for her. For the most part, it went fairly unnoticed and that all these behaviors were in fact connected.

1. Calling in every day off and offering to work extra if needed. If she was called in, after about a couple hours of work, she would then beg to be sent home (not feeling well).

2. Entering patients rooms not assigned to her or reading their charts/notes.

3. Offering to medicate patients for other nurses not assigned to her.

4. Getting into heated debates over the phone with physicians because she believed that her patients were not being medicated enough or properly, asking (if not demanding) more potent pain killers.

5. Offering to change a PCA machine medication for a patient not assigned to her.

6. Being absent for periods of time or needing to frequent the bathroom.

7. Complaining about her assignment at times, especially if there were not enough chronic pain or surgical patients under her care.

Now, this list of behaviors, in and of themselves, are not too terribly shocking. By themselves, we as nurses have often witnessed them in our colleagues during the course of our careers. By themselves, none raise up a "ding, ding, ding...red flag, red flag...something is happening here." However, when lumped together over a period of time, a picture does seem to develop. Often times, this picture only becomes apparent after the fact, after the colleague is suspected and caught. After picking your jaw off the floor, you may have a tendency to want to kick yourself for not seeing it while it was happening. Then, a normal response would be, "well, who else is doing it in the facility?" It is then that you come to understand why monitoring programs are in place and are necessary.

It does shake your confidence some as a nurse. It can also make one feel angry...for it almost feels like betrayal. A betrayal as to why that nurse was in the facility in the first place (an access to drugs), a betrayal to you as a colleague and as a professional (hmmm, how many times was I lied to?), and betrayal towards the patients under the care of that nurse (how many patients actually did not receive pain medication who actually needed them?).

Feelings of self abasement can often be experienced. "I should have seen this. If I had, I could have at least prevented this from happening or been instrumental in pointing that nurse towards help." Having mixed emotions about this occurring on your unit is often common. Our entire nursing staff was floored, if not devastated. When a nurse diverts, it hurts. It ends up hurting many persons around them...patients, as well as colleagues.

My ex-colleague who appeared as a model nurse got busted during a routine random urine screening. When asked for a urine sample, we had heard that she had declined. When pressured, she bolted. After nearly running over a hospital security guard with her car, she was apprehended in the hospital parking lot. When she and her car were searched, it was reported that they had found more than drugs on her person. In her car, she had various hospital supplies ranging from IV tubings and bags to small equipment. The last I heard about her was when I saw her name on a list of nurses who had lost their licenses (in my board of nursing's bulletin). She dropped out of sight then after.

Now, when I look back and think about her, I feel sort of sad. It still leaves me asking questions, however. How could this have happened to her? What initiated her drug use and how did it snowball into what it became? Why didn't she get help for this if it were available? Questions, always questions. I may never know the answers. In the end, when I think about it, it just leaves me feeling incredibly sad.

The job can be very stressful and if the patient is very sick, it can be hard to "forget" or get it out of my mind. Obviously, there are other diverts such as reading or hanging out with friends, family or loved ones that are much better!

I have recently known two great RN's who fell into this dark side of nursing. One was a young nurse who presumably didn't have the deep professional training and experience to overcome the temptation. The other was older and very experienced who should have known better. As someone noted in the blog, it was a sad situation. My concern is that if it can happen to these two nurses who I considered very professional and trusworthy, then can it happen to anyone, given the same circumstances? If we are all at risk then how do we eliminate this risk?

-ED

This is so sad. It hurts patients and reflects poorly on all of us as professionals in the health care field. I had a traveling nurse drunk on the job and it took all of 1 week to figure it out and find bottles in her locker and kick her butt out.

Specializes in Cardiology, Telemetry, Hemodialysis.

Unfortunately this is not a new issue. The first job I had as a new grad was working the NOC shift in a LTC Facility. In 1995 we had very few job opportunities. To make this short , when I came on my shift I did drug counts with the off going staff. It consumed a great deal of time as we did actual hand counts. I found a controlled substance short 2 tabs. I gave the staff member the benefit of the doubt, giving her time to review her shift and account for the shortage. Unable to account for the 2 tabs, I made a notation of the count shortage. Without assigning blame i.e. " Medication count off by two tabs of vicodin, staff nurse Jane Doe and I rechecked and count remains short as noted above". We both signed as required. This was done two times, after that the drug count was never short.

Specializes in Cardiology, Telemetry, Hemodialysis.

The risk of deverting pain medication to ones self is only as great as the selfishness required to medicate themselves AND allow the pt. to suffer in pain. There is no excuse for it.

Specializes in Case Management.

In the 80's I worked steady nights with a group of several young mothers with little children; there were about 6 of us who worked part time steady nights. We had to stay one morning as our charge nurse lit into everyone about narcs going missing. This was on a tele unit and I am talking BOXES of valiums going missing. It seemed like they didn't even know what shift it was because the whole box would disappear along with the med sheet that came with the box. We never suspected anyone from "our group" we were all part time and not there all the time. However, one of us, it turned out was the culprit. She would always be sleepy and blamed it on her kids not letting her get any rest. She would nod off during charting and we all felt so sorry for her, I remember us all dimming the lights in the chart room and talking quietly so she could get a little rest. She always preferred the far end of the hall, too. I remember that. She would switch assignments just to get that end of the hall. So they planted a fake patient unbeknownst to us whose job it was to order pain meds and lots of them to see who was diverting. Turns out it was her. The feds escorted her out the building one night that I was off. I was shocked. Even more shocked about 6 months later when I heard she was working as an OR tech. Say what? Guess the hospital wanted to keep it quiet.

I had another good friend in nursing school who ended up diverting years after we graduated. I was working managed care doing chart reviews in my neighborhood hospital working for an insurance company. She was an agency nurse and I was so happy to see her after so many years. I saw her that one day and then I learned after only a couple of days they caught her messing with a PCA to get the morphine out. I saw in our state bulletin that she had her license suspended. Then a couple of later I saw in the bulletin that her license was revoked for refusal to follow the rules outlined in her program.

Another good friend (one of the part time mothers I worked steady nights with) years later I got her to come with me to the managed care side of the business. Steady daylight weekends off, wearing nice clothes to work, she loved it. But she had a drinking problem. One too many DUI's and she requested to be put in the program. She is working in LTC now, having gone through the program . Our friendship is long over however, because her drinking clouded her judgement and after I stuck my neck out for her once again, she ticked off a medical director after being on the job 2 weeks. She was fired.

Only one more story: Talking about "weed" reminded me of a nurse I met who used to work hospice in Florida back in the early 80's. She remembers rolling her patients' joints for them!!!

We had a nurse who was diverting Diprivan....REALLY!!! She had a respirtatory arrest (go figure) in a patients room in the ICU. She ended up with a perm pacemaker b/c the cards thought she had sick sinus syndrome. Come to find out, she was starting her own IV's in her upper arm and shooting up at work. It was even thought she was taking the drug from hanging bottles in patient's rooms. All we could say was WOW!! How stupid!

Gosh these stories are shocking. Why ruin your career especially since you have worked so hard for it. Very sad

Specializes in CVOR,CNOR,NEURO,TRAUMA,TRANSPLANTS.

in my years of nursing i have personally come acrossed a "few" nurses, drs', anesthesia, nurse manager and 1 pharmacist.

some perhaps seen because i travel to different facilities and so i would not "be" familiar with anyones normal behaviors.

1) nurse- nebraska i was working in the operating room and we had a trauma come into the er, farming machine verses limb. when asking about the vast amounts of narcs given to this patient *(i would want to be gorked out too)* i was getting report with the charge when she started going over who gave what.... 10 mg morphine quk jet was not accounted for. i didnt think anything about it and patient was taken to surgery. ( the nurse over my patient wasnt the charge nurse, the nurse for the patient was not there when i got there so i had no idea other than a name who was the nurse i had to get report and go). i got to work the next morning and there was a note given to me by my charge nurse to go to admin, her note said "random drug screen" ok not a problem. i later found out, all persons whose name er doc, er nurses, all er techs and me along with my anesthesologist. 3, did not pass....... 1 rn, 2 er techs failed the screen. that was my first experience.

2) 3 am call back for emergency appendectomy- i went to the er picked up my patient and took him to surgery family in tow. set the patient up in the room and anesthesia was with me in the er, my tech was there we were waiting on the doc... general surgeon, well known been there for years..... i was told salt of the earth kinda guy. i had worked with him maybe 4 times, (different speciality but when your on call you do it all). we waited for a half hr in the room patient aaox3, medicated for pain per anesthesia...... hour goes by.... i have called him 3 times, each time he stated he was in route...last phone call was pretty short. when he finally showed up. 1 .5 hours post the time he was notified from the er doc about the case. he stuck his head in the door nodded to the anesthesia and instructed us to prep and drape while he washed his hands for surgery. when he came in the room he walked by me to the back table to gown up, as i was tying his gown, he reaked of booze. i asked him ... dr are drunk? loud enough all in the room could hear. the anestheologist jumped up and ushered him right out of the room and within a few minutes his partner showed up and surgery went forward. aparently he was going through a divorce and they had been covering for him. i wrote everything up and went straight to the director with it. it was not the first notice of this issue........ frightening

3) anethesia tech od'd in the surgery lounge on diprovan, roc, ativan, lidocaine, papaverin... all the wasted syringes from the anesthesia red box, all of the above mixed together and self injected.....that happend on the night shift.

i dont think anyone can predict when someone becomes to diverting, it is sad to see the end result though. i have worked in the days where we counted each and every pill, shift by shift one person had the keys and you guarded ith with your life. when the pixis system came in i exhaled thinking it was the fort knox of drugs.... no it seems its the golden gate because i have heard others give thier passwords when they werent close to the pixis and the password just shouted out to whose listening. in surgery its an entire different ballgame. we are privi to so much we look at everyone, question and a smart nurse has anesthesia watch her distribute drugs or another rn, i watch my anesthesia and drs constantly, because that is a time where my patient has no voice.

z

This is one of the saddest events that occur in our profession.

________________________________________________

I was accused of diversion by an irate room mate of mine.

I came home one day and found every single piece of belonging- including items from the fridge dumped in my room and the electricity turned off at the box ( this was at 2300). She and her friend then took snapshots of the mess in my room including a small bag which she claimed was filled with drugs.

I subsequently moved and then got married and moved abroad. I received a letter from the BRN informing me that I had lost my nursing license.

I flew back to the states to face the board. The accusation was so trite and ridiculous ( I worked in the PACU at the time and charted every time MS was given to my patient- esp by anesthesia who had a habit of just walking in and giving meds without charting). I don't consider that an error because I had to know the total dose of MS on board before I gave the patient some more pain med. The error I did make is not having someone witness me when I discarded a med- sometimes it was hard to find another nurse to do so and it was the standard procedure at the time.

To make a long story short, the judge wanted to throw the case out but couldn 't because it was a meeting of the BRN. I pleaded guilty to poor documentation and my license was reactivated as long as I work overseas. The judge told me that I could reopen this issue again and go for a retrial.

Until this incident, I had no blemish on my record. I also had taken over as the pre-op holding nurse and had no orientation as my preceptor had dropped dead at work.

My room mate apparently had a history of making problems with all of her room mates ( she was also a nurse).

It is a miserable to happen to anyone but it can happen.

I got dinged for not having orders covering the MS which I had charted and such things as wrong dating on the chart ( it was a holiday and I had put that date instead of the date following it). If someone wants to make trouble for you there are endless ways that they can.

Specializes in PSY & ADDITION.

I have attended a couple of training classes to be alerted to nurse dirversion of narcotics . I am still amazed each time it occurs. In a couple of situations I noticed some of the signs but still didn't want to believe it. Some signs not noted in other responses are; Super nurse (everyone loves them, patients and co-workers because they help everyone); Grand Diverter (they not only divert drugs, they divert attention to other co-workers in a negative manner, including sugesting others are not medicating enough or over medicating); Either always running late or early and whiling to clock in and help previous shift finish up; Heres the "Biggy" the never were short sleeves, never, they may push up cuffs a few inches but they do not remove their jacket.

I was a new employee at a facility and a nurse & I were talking and this conversation came up. We had a few previous conversations but didnt work the same area. That was her last day to show up for work. Come to find out she was being watch and thought i had noticed the long sleeves she always wore. The facility did turn here into the State Board of Nursing.

Posted by: Thunderwolf

We often read and hear about nurses, physicians, and pharmacists getting caught diverting drugs in health care facilities. Some have wondered after the fact, how could this go unnoticed? And how could this go unnoticed for so long? When it actually happens to a colleague, I would think the normal response would be picking your jaw off the floor. But, it does happen. That is a major reason why health care facilities employ monitoring programs.

The intent of this post is to share an experience about a former colleague, a colleague who diverted and was eventually caught. This situation happened several years ago. This colleague had been a nurse for a very long time, in her 50's, and married. Both made good money, and lived in (what I heard was) a beautiful home. At work, for the most part, she was very helpful in lending a hand, often smiling, and advocating for her patients. Life appeared good for her. And for the most part, she was a most excellent nurse. She looked after her patients, often speaking of them fondly.

However, in a relatively short period of time (let's say, over a period of a year), her baseline behaviors began changing for her. For the most part, it went fairly unnoticed and that all these behaviors were in fact connected.

1. Calling in every day off and offering to work extra if needed. If she was called in, after about a couple hours of work, she would then beg to be sent home (not feeling well).

2. Entering patients rooms not assigned to her or reading their charts/notes.

3. Offering to medicate patients for other nurses not assigned to her.

4. Getting into heated debates over the phone with physicians because she believed that her patients were not being medicated enough or properly, asking (if not demanding) more potent pain killers.

5. Offering to change a PCA machine medication for a patient not assigned to her.

6. Being absent for periods of time or needing to frequent the bathroom.

7. Complaining about her assignment at times, especially if there were not enough chronic pain or surgical patients under her care.

Now, this list of behaviors, in and of themselves, are not too terribly shocking. By themselves, we as nurses have often witnessed them in our colleagues during the course of our careers. By themselves, none raise up a "ding, ding, ding...red flag, red flag...something is happening here." However, when lumped together over a period of time, a picture does seem to develop. Often times, this picture only becomes apparent after the fact, after the colleague is suspected and caught. After picking your jaw off the floor, you may have a tendency to want to kick yourself for not seeing it while it was happening. Then, a normal response would be, "well, who else is doing it in the facility?" It is then that you come to understand why monitoring programs are in place and are necessary.

It does shake your confidence some as a nurse. It can also make one feel angry...for it almost feels like betrayal. A betrayal as to why that nurse was in the facility in the first place (an access to drugs), a betrayal to you as a colleague and as a professional (hmmm, how many times was I lied to?), and betrayal towards the patients under the care of that nurse (how many patients actually did not receive pain medication who actually needed them?).

Feelings of self abasement can often be experienced. "I should have seen this. If I had, I could have at least prevented this from happening or been instrumental in pointing that nurse towards help." Having mixed emotions about this occurring on your unit is often common. Our entire nursing staff was floored, if not devastated. When a nurse diverts, it hurts. It ends up hurting many persons around them...patients, as well as colleagues.

My ex-colleague who appeared as a model nurse got busted during a routine random urine screening. When asked for a urine sample, we had heard that she had declined. When pressured, she bolted. After nearly running over a hospital security guard with her car, she was apprehended in the hospital parking lot. When she and her car were searched, it was reported that they had found more than drugs on her person. In her car, she had various hospital supplies ranging from IV tubings and bags to small equipment. The last I heard about her was when I saw her name on a list of nurses who had lost their licenses (in my board of nursing's bulletin). She dropped out of sight then after.

Now, when I look back and think about her, I feel sort of sad. It still leaves me asking questions, however. How could this have happened to her? What initiated her drug use and how did it snowball into what it became? Why didn't she get help for this if it were available? Questions, always questions. I may never know the answers. In the end, when I think about it, it just leaves me feeling incredibly sad.

+ Join the Discussion