Published
one of my instructors makes us sign in at the begining and sign out at the end of class..i think its kinda weird... i mean we are all paying to be there, who ever doesnt show up its their loss right?
In my experience, classes where there are many tests and not much assignments/in-class activities, attendance is not necessary. For classes that figure participation and in-class activities as being a part of the grade, and with few or no tests, attendance is necessary. Makes sense to me.
We had to sign in at the start of class after returning from our first break, and after returning from lunch. It was policy that if a student missed so many hours of class time that they could technically be removed from the program.[/quote']It was the same in my program. Nursing programs have much stricter attendance policies than normal college classes do.
This kind of thing is ridiculous.
I had one nursing school professor who did hourly sign-ins and got on my case for missing a couple of lectures. My response was, "I'm a grown-a** 26-year-old man. I've fought for my country, run codes as a medic on the streets of South Central, and pulled kicking and screaming victims out of structure fires. If I decide I need to miss one of your lectures, that's my decision and I'll worry about the consequences."
The problem with some nursing educators is they place you in a position that requires great reponsibility while simultaneously treating you like a child. Does. Not. Compute.
I would never ask my students to do this. They are adults. If they want to come to class, great. If not, that's their issue. Those who miss class regularly often don't pass. I would rather spend my efforts teaching than policing. Adults must be accountable for the results of both wise & poor choices. In real life if you constantly skip work, you get fired. No one calls or emails to remind you to show up.
CuriousMe
2,642 Posts
I hate this method... predominantly because in every class I've had that used it, the assignments were pure busy work (ie write a summary of something we read....give me a break, my reading comprehension skills are just fine, I don't need to write a summary).
When I commented on how useless the busywork was to a professor, she flat out told me that she used it as attendance. It ticked me off to no end....I'm busy enough, I don't need busy-work, just so the Prof doesn't have to use 5 minutes to take attendance.
We did get a small amount of points for it....I'd rather just be tested on my knowledge, than have my time wasted.