RNs and Pay-for-Performance: The Right Prescription?

Nurses Activism

Published

Introduction

Registered nurses are increasingly challenged by the pace and scope of change in the health care industry. Cost cutting and consolidation continue as RN employers seek to improve financial performance and remain competitive in their markets. For nurses, this can translate into pay-for-performance programs which their employers see as a way of reducing labor costs while increasing productivity and quality of care by motivating nurses with financial incentives. The purpose of this pamphlet is to briefly describe the main features of these compensation programs and suggest questions you should ask and steps you should take if your employer implements or proposes such a pay system.

What Are Pay-for-Performance Programs?

Pay-for-performance programs go under a variety of names: contingent or "at-risk " pay, variable pay, profit sharing, gainsharing, to mention only a few. Their common denominator is the linking of financial rewards for employees to improvements in the performance of the group.

Gainsharing, for example, emphasizes three key features: participation, achievement, and rewards. Gainsharing presupposes that all employees of an organization, if given the chance, can participate and contribute beyond the minimum or standard level of performance. Achievement emphasizes reducing costs and increasing profits and focuses on group rather than individual performance to improve productivity. Rewards are usually in the form of cash, paid at regular intervals.

Pay-for-performance programs for non-management hospital-employed registered nurses are relatively new. Nonetheless, employers nationwide are considering such programs, and one major HMO has recently instituted a "performance outcome program" designed to provide monetary incentives to registered nurses in exchange for reduced costs and increased patient satisfaction. Registered nurses must now seriously consider the appropriateness of incentive pay programs.

Full info:

http://www.ana.org/dlwa/wages/wp8.htm

Yesterday the charge RN told me to push my pts bed from one room to another that was larger. The pt is over 400 lbs & is on a KinAir bed. I told her I was not the transporter & I called the nursing supervisor to send some of those guys over to move this pt & I went to take care of my other pt. So the move didnt get done right away but it did get done - by the people whose job it is to do it. But the charge RN concluded that I was "just being difficult".

Tonight, after spending 2 hrs de-licing my unconscious, ventilated, dopamined, post code, intoxicated, hypothermic, homeless-living-on-the-subway, John Doe new admission, another charge RN told me to help her wash down & disinfect the bed scale, broken IV pumps, & other equipment that were to be taken out of the room. I told her no - and I asked housekeeping to take care of it. He promptly disappeared. The charge RN told me to "just do it" so it can be done & finished. I called the supervisor & told her to send someone up to disinfect the equipment. She did - but an hour later. So what? So the charge RN was annoyed because by the time the porter finally did it, we could have already been finished. Maybe, but then my other pt would have gotten his meds late & I am there to be an RN, not to wash equipment. Still I dont think she'd give me a good peer evaluation because I didnt do what she told me to do. My performance as an RN wouldnt even be considered.

Originally posted by NRSKarenRN

What Are Pay-for-Performance Programs?

Pay-for-performance programs go under a variety of names: contingent or "at-risk " pay, variable pay, profit sharing, gainsharing, to mention only a few. Their common denominator is the linking of financial rewards for employees to improvements in the performance of the group.

If they've got the money for incentives or rewards why not just add it to wages for the way under compensated work nurses already do? I can't believe it's suggested that nurses need to do more. Give nurses decent wages, working conditions, and the respect they deserve. The quality patient care and productivity will follow.

Achievement emphasizes reducing costs and increasing profits...

This just sounds dirty! I do the best I can in not wasting supplies, time, etc., but I think this type of thinking by us everyday staff nurses (especially the increase profits part) not only harms nurses, it will harm patient care as well because the focus turns from I'm doing everything I can to make Joe Blow in bed 15 comfortable to cha$ching, if I could just figure out a way to make Joe's stay a little more profitable.

I'm also in complete agreement with those who oppose subjective reviews. No, I don't trust all of my co-workers.

~Sally

Specializes in PACU/Cardiac/Nrsg. Mgmt./M/S.

we have gainsharing at my hospital, however, all it involves is financial savings among the employees..you know the routine, waste not want not..turn out lights, don't waste paper, etc..

it has nothing to do with performance..its a financial measure only...last year ft employees received 900.00 checks...

this year is supposed to be much better...

+ Add a Comment