PA-C or NP? What would you do?

Nursing Students NP Students

Published

I am an ADN, with many years under my belt in nephrology, ICU, ER, and M/S.

In my current role, I function quite independently/autonomously and I'm quite good at it clinically. One thing this role has taught me, I really, really, reeeeallly enjoy the medical science and application side of things, being able to use my knowledge to make more autonomous decisions, and having a high degree of contact and collaboration with nearly all departments (and docs) in the hospital.

Healthcare politics, business, and trends interest me a great deal, but my primary talent and enjoyment comes from assessing patients and problem-solving.

I am currently in the research phase of deciding between pursuing RN->BSN->ANP or becoming a PA.

>Both roles while similar, have different challenges not just in practice, but on the political scene as well. PA's (at app 85,000 in number) are terribly underrepresented at the State and Fed levels as opposed to RN's (millions strong).

>I like the heavy, medical-model of PA school, yet I like the fact that NP's can function under their own license.

>I dislike the fact that ANP scope of practice varies so wildly from state to state. The barriers to true autonomy are numerous. This issue I realize, is being heavily studied and lobbied.

>I've ruled out CRNA and perfusionist as options (had enough machine-management, thank you :) ).

>I like that PA's are considered "generalists" yet they have so many options in specializing. As one of the docs I work with put it, "you can write your own ticket."

One thought is to just finish my BSN and decide from there, but...PA programs can have different reqs...i.e, it's been so long, that I have to take some chemistry, English, and A/P again...sigh.

Any thoughts from those that have faced this conundrum (or otherwise) I'd greatly appreciate it.

Well my being a good strategist has nothing to do with Physician's controlling PA practice they just do. My rationale is pretty basic. Let's say your family's drinking water was in a large container inside your home and one day you saw two holes in it. You couldn't reach one of the holes but you could reach the other. What would you do?

What makes you think you can reach either hole?

It's a straightforward scenario but feel free to go far fetched. The bottom line is that a PA's ability to practice is tied to the Physician who can choose to hire them or not. They are governed by the medical board(physicians) AP nurses are not. To get back on topic I would pursue AP nursing for the reasons stated by myself and some other posters. Good luck with your decision

Specializes in Trauma/ER, Pysch, Pedi, Free Standing ER, L&D, ICU.

Thank you @TraceyMarino. Your comment probably sealed the deal for my decision. I didn't realize NP's are more recognized/utilized OCONUS. You're right, I'm tempted to go where FINAID is more accessible.

Hello all,

I am in a similar but slightly different situation. I have been admitted to 2 PA programs and a 3yr NP program at a certain amazing school in the bay area of CA. One of the PA programs I have been admitted to is not in CA, it is a couple of states over in Utah and begins in about a month. It is not University of Utah, rather a newer (almost 1 yr old at this point) program. They have their provisional accreditation currently. The program seems promising but again is still new. I do not have a spouse or children so that helps but I do have a sister that would probably move with me. She has a lot of medical issues and would probably be better off in the bay area where there is amazing tertiary care. To make it more confusing, I was also offered admission at a PA program that is part of a currently established dental school in Northern CA. It seems promising but I was thinking that it would be quite the gamble to turn down the PA program in Utah and the amazing NP program in NorCal for them to not receive their provisional accreditation. They won't find out their status until Sept. since their program doesn't start until Jan 2017, months after the other two programs start.

I cannot tell you how torn I am between the caliber of the school in CA and the fact that I think I would rather be a PA. If anyone has any input, I would greatly appreciate it.

I have heard Northern California was more NP friendly but it seems there is a place for PAs too? How is Southern CA in terms of PA vs. NP acceptability and employ-ability for new grads?

Again, my choices are:

-UC in SF (3yr RN/FNP program)

-UoP in Northern CA (PA program, 1st cohort, accreditation application filed)

-promising school in Provo, UT (PA program, 2nd cohort, provisional accreditation)

My goal has always been primary care but would like to have flexibility if I were to change my specialty later on. I have a public health background (I enjoy the "whole pt." approach) but I think I prefer the medical curriculum of PA school. So confused what to do. I feel like I am stuck between a rock and a hard place with 3 programs that have a lot of pros and a lot of cons without any one of them really being a good fit.

Thanks for the input!

Would not do any program with provisional approval, just my opinion.

Do you mind sharing your stats with me? I have been torn between PA and NP, but have always been interested in medicine. I have applied to a couple masters-entry programs and a BSN program, but am not sure what my chances are of getting into PA school. I have a low GPA, 3.16, at the University of Washington and a cumulative of about 3.25 with some other classes at community college. I struggled for awhile at UW, but for my last 1.5 years my grades improved. My general chem and bio grades were not so high (2.0-2.6), but my A&P and advanced sciences in the last year and a half were 3.7+. I have worked as a CNA for about a year and have some volunteering experience. Anyone have advice on how to become a better PA applicant?

Hey, it sounds to me like you want to go to PA school. That is okay. You will get there if you keep working. I say you apply this year and see where it gets you. If you don't get in this year there is always next year.

+ Add a Comment