What are your perspective on Mandate Fairness?

Nurses General Nursing

Updated:   Published

I work in a 24 hour institutional setting, union contract, 8 hr shifts as an RN.

Our union contract is such that if there is a call off on the next shift, we can be mandated to a second full shift with ~ 3 hours notice, leading to a 16 hr shift unexpectedly. Everyone gets mandated eventually. Sometimes its a little brutal, but we are all in the same boat. Almost.

My problem is, my co-worker, after they were hired as permanent, has chosen to file an ADA dispensation for psychiatric reasons (they chose to disclose this, to everyone) disallowing themselves from being mandated to the next shift.

Unfortunately, my schedule often mirrors this employee's schedule and often our 3rd nurse is agency/on call and cannot be mandated. So, if I am working with this particular employee, which is frequent, the mandate automatically falls on me. This particular individual is a favorite of the current direct manager, although they have numerous professional conduct problems and extensive attendance issues.

Just venting. Looking for any perspective. I am struggling with feelings of resentment toward my employer about all of the above. I will be attempting to change my shift assignment but there are no opportunities right now. Thanks y'all

On 4/2/2019 at 2:47 PM, Jedrnurse said:

Yup. Staffing should be the responsibility of management. I'm referring to the "magical" ADA status that would allow one to work a full-time job but be exempt from mandating. I'm also reading between the lines of the other references the OP made to this person's work habits/behaviors on the unit. I don't buy this abuse of ADA. I guess we'll have to disagree.

Jedrnuse, you are not wrong. Beyond the ADA no-mandate, co-worker in question, often does not come to work in the first place. The funny thing is although they cannot be mandated, when they call off day shift gets mandated to cover them. It's great for morale!

2 Votes
On 4/3/2019 at 10:54 PM, Here.I.Stand said:

It was just a thought... besides I have seen nurses who work in procedural areas, or on my unit who are ECMO trained, and who work home hospice all have on-call hours in addition to their scheduled hours. I have myself been put on call when census is low but not low enough to comfortably cancel us

Oh, I know - I'm guessing most people who work acute care have been put on-call at one time or another (self included). I'm just not sure whatever made all of us feel it was acceptable to not be paid for such (regardless if "it's that way everywhere" and regardless if it's buried in the "I understand and will abide by all applicable policies" employment-agreement stuff). Isn't it just a little weird that the first people to experience this didn't say, "Uh, wait a minute...". But, who knows....maybe there wasn't a nursing shortage then (?) and that's why no one protested.

I mean, employment agreements generally involve doing X for $Y. Not doing Z for $0.

2 Votes
Specializes in ER.

I wouldn't put up with mandatory overtime, and I'm brave enough to say so in the employment interview. If I somehow wound up in a position that required it, I'd let my manager know that the amount of time I agreed to be available was set when I was hired. If they want to renegotiate the position, that's fine, but until we come to a new agreement, I'm not available for extra hours

2 Votes
+ Add a Comment