Preferential treatment for new staff

Nurses General Nursing

Published

Does anyone else have a problem with new staff getting preferential treatment? I have worked at the same hospital for eighteen years, and it seems new hires are getting better treatment from administration than older staff. They get sign on bonuses, better schedules, and seem to have lower standards of behavior. I was actually asked to work overtime last weekend because a guy who has worked here only three months wanted the weekend off. The supervisor even said that she wanted to keep him happy because he was new. It wouldn't have made me angry if I hadn't been told just last month I could not cover for another RN who wanted the day off for her sister's surgery because it would mean overtime. People are coming into the hospital and paid the same wage as those of us who have been here for years. A friend of mine was moved to night shift recently because there was a new girl coming who could only work days. There was an incident recently where one of our staff who has been here for fifteen years was suspended because he said something inappropriate to a physician. I witnessed the incident, and he was way out of line, and did deserve suspension. Shortly after that , another girl,who has been in our unit less than a year, called a doctor a name in front of a patient and his family. When the doc complained, he was told that she would apologize to him. She refused to apologize, and nothing further was done. This girl is often inappropriate to patients, families, and physicians, but it is just overlooked. There are incidents similar to this on a weekly basis, some just as outrageuos, some more subtle, but all very demoralizing. I know that recruitment of new staff is important, but keeping experienced staff happy should be too. Loyalty should be rewarded. I have never thought that there was a place for unions in health care, but I am beginning to think that maybe organizing would stop this kind of treatment? Anyone have any thoughts?

A senior nurse should not expect preferential treatment, but seniority and respect for experience should be considering factors

On a side note:

This week two new nursing grads verified an insulin order and drew up what they thought was the correct dosage per sliding scale. One would have given the patient 60 units of regular insulin INSTEAD of 6 if I had not been (coincidentally) in the room and noticed the error as this new RN was wiping the patient's skin with an alcohol pad! I brought this new RN into the hallway and quietly and privately told her of her error. Her response was less than comforting.. a grin, a flip of her ponytail, and a high-pitched "oops!"

Specializes in Case Management, Home Health, UM.

Thank you, Ageless....we Senior Nurses are NOT asking for preferential treatment. We are just asking for the same respect given to our younger colleagues, who have also had to meet the same clinical and academic standards as defined by the NLN and the State Nursing Boards in order to sit the licensing exam and EARN the same title: R.N.

Ageless is right. Senior nurses don't want preferential treatment, just fair treatment. And seniority and years of loyalty should count for something. I earned my place in my hospital, and now brand new staff are getting breaks I never had. I don't want to be told that I cannot have the vacation week I want because that week was promised to a new hire when she signed on, or that I have to work Christmas because someone who has been there less than a year wants to be off. I want new employees to be held to the same professional standards of behavior as I am. I don't expect them to have the same clinical skills I do, that takes time, but courtesy and and a professional demeanor should be an expectation. I would never call a physician an a**hole in front of a patient and family, and if I did, I would expect to be disciplined, even if the doc is an a**hole. It's just not professional. It creates resentment when the person you are orienting brags about his wages, and tells you that he is making the same hourly rate as you. Administration justifies this by telling you he has experience. I don't think after two years in long term care, someone should get the same wage as someone with 18 years acute care experience. All of these incidents have happened to me, and there are many more that I could tell you about. We are lucky in ICU because we have a good manager who does try to be more fair, but still has to abide by the policies set by administration. On some of the nursing units, the favoritism is even more blatant. I don't want to leave my job and start over again. I don't want to give up my seniority and the benefits I have accrued, but I am beginning to think that maybe I should go somewhere else and be the new person.

:nurse: Hi all.....well....I don't know what to say here. I consider myself a 'senior nurse'....having been in this profession for over 23 years, but I'm a 'new hire' at one of our large hospitals here in the St.Louis area.

Everybody has been SO nice and supportive. I sure hope I don't cause these kinds of feelings with my 'new' co-workers. I have not worked in the hospital setting for several....several years and all the new 'technology' is ,at times, overwhelming, but I'm really enjoying it and thankful for the new surroundings.

Yes, I did get a large bonus. Yes, I was offerred the choice of 8 or 12 hr. days....You just can't imagine how thankful I am for that! I was seriously considering leaving nursing.

With our shortage now days, if student nurses and new grads are met with these types of attitudes, (even seasoned nurses entering the hospital setting) I can't say I blame them in developing 'attitudes' themselves or even leaving.

But on the other hand, I certianly understand the 'other side of the coin' here.

Maybe you 'senior' nurses could take one of the new members of the team under your wing and REALLY teach them what REAL nursing is all about????:saint:

to the senior nurses here....I am a student now...I'll be 40 next month so I'm a little late getting started, but I just want you to know that there are those of us who don't feel that we "know it all" and WILL respect the experience and wisdom from seasoned nurses. Since I have been reading these post, I feel that I have already learned so much from nurses who have been the profesion several years. I have even started a file of procedures some of you have recommended and when you write a term I don't understand, I look it up so I can follow the conversations. You have answered questions I did'nt even know I had and I have enormous respect for each of you. I hope and pray that when I am a newly graduated nurse I will be fortunate to work with a class act such as you are. I will be the one asking LOTS of questions. ha God Bless each of you.

Specializes in Med/Surg, ER, L&D, ICU, OR, Educator.

Is this a generational thing? The 'young ones' don't want to "pay their dues" and want the good hours right away, the time off whenever they want it "or I'm outa here" or "I'll just take it and see if they'll do anything about it", the attitude of "oops! oh well" and "I know that".

Has the work ethic been lost in this generation?

Oh ceecel.dee I hate it when people say that. I am of the younger generation (in my 20s) and have a very good work ethic. Laziness goes to all ages (for every "young slacker" there is an experienced nurse who needs to be "put out to pasture")!

I think rotating time off and holidays is the only fair way. I don't think a young nurse has any dues to pay if she is doing the same job as a more experienced nurse, and we'll never be able to retain new people if they only get the short end of the stick. If everyone would be willing to work their share of weekends and nights and holidays, things are nicer for the whole staff.

I am all for equality, Fergus, and we have been exchanging posts for some time and you already know this about me, more than likely. ;)

What I DO object to is new hires being catered to, with old hires picking up the slack. If new hires feel 'eaten' this may be what is going on... remember new hires, you are 'taking' energy from the staff...energy we may not have to spare; and we are many times exhausted before you got there. So....give us a break. We are more than happy to help you if you display a learning attitude. But don't be surprised if you come in 'entitled' and aren't shown a lot of love...know what I mean???

Peace!!!:)

I don't feel the need to cater to new people either, just to be fair. I hate hearing newer nurses whine about not getting as much money as more experienced nurses and I hate hearing more experienced nurses whining about having to work a weekend here and there (especially when I have been here longer than they have!:)). Sharing makes EVERYONE better....

I've been a nurse for 4 years now, but I'm already seeing some of this at my hospital. We recently hired in some new grads that took positions. After about a month, several of them decided these postions weren't convenient for them, and went over our supervisors head to tell her supervisor that either they got what they wanted, or they walked. They got it.

In terms of new nurses walking right into choice hours, I started on days. It was offered to me, and I took it. I didn't ask for it. In fact, when they asked at my interview, I said that I would prefer days, but I wanted to work at that facility so badly, that I was willing to work whatever they offered me. I got some attitude from some nurses. I told them flat out, take it up with your supervisor - I took what was offered to me as you would have.

I'm with you fergus about time off and holidays. Our hospital works on a first come first served basis. No special considerations for senority. It puts us all on the same level, no one better than anyone else (just faster :D )

For some, the complaining of preferential treatment of new nurses turns into the complaining of a nurse that she is not the one receiving the preferential treatment. What entitles a senor nurses to Christmas off before me? Why, because of my age, am I required to suffer and "pay my dues"?

There is so much infighting in nursing, and it only takes the light off the real problem, which is management. As long as we are so concerned with who gets what among each other, it takes the light off them. Who caters to the newbies and allows them to act as they do? Management. Who gives them whatever they ask for ? Management. Who grants their time and holidays off? Management. Who is responsible for picking and choosing who gets what? Management. Does anyone see a theme here? Management are the responsible ones here. They've learned how to use and manipulate us to their liking. Are they losing anything? Nope. Are we? Yup.

Don't hate the new nurse for what she is offered. Hate the people that offer it to her knowing the animosity it will breed.

I wanted to say so much here. I wanted to offer the other side, while still showing it was an unfair practice.

Heather

You are absolutely right Heather, I totally agree. :)

Specializes in Med/Surg, ER, L&D, ICU, OR, Educator.

If management would decide on issues consistantly, regardless of who the nurse is, we may know what to expect of them and could better address concerns....but must we HATE management?

+ Add a Comment