Diabetes treatment and why success does not pay

Specialties Endocrine

Published

I am insulin dependent diabetic and have a vested interest in this topic but I am interested in hearing the experiences and opinions of my peers on this topic. For the past three days, the New York Times has run a series of articles regarding the cost of diabetic care, the impact on the city and the diabetics themselves, programs tried and one that is currently being funded by a grant. For those interested, go to their website to read the complete articles.

We all know that there has been an increase in weight, in most adults and children. And we are aware of the fact that there has been a corresponding increase in the number of Type II diabetics. We are also seeing an increase in the hospitalization of those suffering from complications of their poorly controlled diabetes. What most of us fail to realize is the following:

1. Approximately 90% of diabetics are managed by their PCP.

2. Most PCP average eight to ten minutes a visit with their diabetic patients.

3. Medicare, Medicaid and private insurance re-reimburse less for the education and preventive care, then they do for the acute care such as amputations.

4. Most diabetics receive hit and miss education about their disease.

5. Many diabetic do not look at the long term complications, not being able to focus 10 or 20 years down the road.

6. Most diabetic are unaware of the importance of theirA1c test and its importance.

Several hospitals have opened diabetic centers where their outpatients meet in groups with diabetic educators and nutritionists. And they have access to endocrinologist, ophthalmologists and podiatrist. Studies have shown in improvement in the health of those attending such programs, weight loss, reduction in A1c percentage, improved nutrition and lessening of the number of complications. All three types of patients, Medicare, Medicaid and private insurance attend these programs. Now, one would think that with such proof, everyone would be willing to fund such programs. Guess what? No, no no. All but one, at Columbia has been forced to close its doors because of the loss of dollars. Apparently all three forms of coverage would rather spend its money on complications.

What does everyone think? Do you think that one or two education sessions are enough? Do you think it is a matter entirely of personal responsibility? That the people are responsible for the management of their own disease? Do some blame the diabetic for any complication he/she develops because if they managed their disease better they wouldn't suffer complications? How do you feel about the poor funding for the management of a chronic disease like diabetes?

Like I said, I am an insulin dependent diabetes, who also suffers from hypertension and asthma. I suffered a TIA in 1998 and it scared me. I became an insulin dependent diabetic in 2001. I have a problem with controlling my blood sugar because, one I love a drink of regular soda once a day and two I have to take prednisone, which effects my blood sugar. I fortunately have not suffered any complications although I have been a diabetic for fifteen years. Am I responsible for my high blood sugar by drinking that regular soda. Or can I lay the blame on my prednisone. Actually I think it is both. And I am dependent on my SIL for one meal a day, which tends to be high in carbs. What do you all think? Do you think, as a nurse I should be able to do what I have taught other diabetics?

Grannynurse:balloons:

I am wondering if your non-compliant relatives are non-compliant because they have seen all the complications and feel they have no control? They have given up because of what they have seen? No, you cannot make someone comply but you should explore all the reasons for their non-compliance and attempt to work with them. And by work with them, I do not mean scold, constantly point out the failures, etc, etc, but give them positive feedback no matter how small.

Grannynurse:balloons:

It's hard to provide positive feedback to someone, who absolutley will not try to make any improvements in thier diet/lifestyle/etc. My father is a prime example. He will not go to any diabetic education classes, will not do fingersticks/ will not follow a diabetic diet. He has seen what the disease did to my grandmother, who had a stroke and heart attack, due to non-compliance.

Part of his non compliance is due to culture. He comes from a culture that emphasis "machismo" and he doesn't like being told what to do. He has been in the hospital numerous times, and has been "fired" by several doctors, because he will not comply. The docs have told him that they will be more than happy to see him again, once he decides he is going to do the needed changes.

I can not make him or any of my other relatives "change", if they don't want to. I also will not feed into the co-dependency issues that are a part of my family. My father and other relatives have to take responsibility for thier actions/non-actions, and ultimately, they will pay for the consequences.

It's hard to provide positive feedback to someone, who absolutley will not try to make any improvements in thier diet/lifestyle/etc. My father is a prime example. He will not go to any diabetic education classes, will not do fingersticks/ will not follow a diabetic diet. He has seen what the disease did to my grandmother, who had a stroke and heart attack, due to non-compliance.

Part of his non compliance is due to culture. He comes from a culture that emphasis "machismo" and he doesn't like being told what to do. He has been in the hospital numerous times, and has been "fired" by several doctors, because he will not comply. The docs have told him that they will be more than happy to see him again, once he decides he is going to do the needed changes.

I can not make him or any of my other relatives "change", if they don't want to. I also will not feed into the co-dependency issues that are a part of my family. My father and other relatives have to take responsibility for thier actions/non-actions, and ultimately, they will pay for the consequences.

I'm sorry that you have given up on your family members. I hope it has not translated to any non-compliant patients who may come under your care. It is so much easier for physicians and nurses to shrug their shoulders and say it is all a matter of personal responsibility or co-dependency. One does not have to feed into co-dependency but that does mean that everyone should wash their hands of those non-compliant members of our society. Or perhaps some do, to sooth their own conscious. After all, one cannot help someone who refuses their help. And therefore, one is no longer responsible because they have washed their hands and left it entirely up to that person. Fortunately, not everyone washes their hands of their non-compliant patients.

Grannynurse

+ Add a Comment