About patient confidentiality
- 0Apr 16, '09 by hyalophora09I have a question for you guys. My physician's nurse is a close friend of our family.Last year she told a relative of mine ,who is a patient of his also,that the doctor and her were worried over a health issue of mine.She told her what it was.I have not trusted her since and I'm very apprehensive about telling my doctor certian things. I'm wondering if I should just switch physicins,as I would never say anything to get her in trouble?Should I say something to her about it or do I have to sign something for my record to be confidential?Please let me know ,as I am thinking of looking for a new doctor because I feel uncomfortable when I go there now.It was done out of concern,not gossip.Thanks.
- 4,725 Visits
- 0Apr 16, '09 by JolieHer actions were inappropriate and constitute a HIPAA violation.
I understand your loss of confidence in the office and don't blame you for wanting to change providers, but that in and of itself will do nothing to prevent her from divulging confidential information regarding your or others in the future, regardless of her good intentions.
Please consider requesting a meeting with the physician/office manager and nurse to air your concerns. They may be able to reassure you that this won't happen again. If not, you will have the peace of mind that you took the steps necessary to protect your privacy and that of other patients.
Thank you for finding a way to address this professionally.
- 0Apr 16, '09 by elkparkShe has violated Federal law, and there are v. serious consequences for this if you choose to make a complaint. Many hospitals would fire her on the spot for that behavior. I encourage you to at least bring this up with her employer (your physician), and consider making a complaint to the feds and/or your state agency that regulates healthcare (there are also state confidentiality rules which she has violated).
If she is truly a "nurse" (and I qualify that only because so many folks working in physician's offices aren't, but get referred to as "nurses" anyway), you could also complain to the state BON.
- 1Apr 17, '09 by elkparkhttp://www.hhs.gov/ocr/privacy/index.html
Here is the main HIPAA site. It includes info about how to file a complaint.
I'm curious about why you want to change docs (presuming you were happy with your physician in the first place), but don't want to do anything to jeopardize the nurse's job. Hearing that the person in question is definitely an RN makes the situation even worse, IMHO. If if were some unlicensed person who sincerely didn't know any better, I would feel more charitable. But this RN has violated state, Federal, and state BON rules, and, if she doesn't know that she's doing so, that's evidence of incompetence in itself (IMHO). She either doesn't know or doesn't care about one of our most basic professional responsibilities. This is very serious business!
- 0Apr 17, '09 by hyalophora09For elkpark,The reason I'd rather change my physician and not jeopardize her job is,when she was 16yrs. old, she was with our family when my cousin,her best friend died a horrible death from a respatory illness.This was one of the reasons she became a nurse.I know she must be aware of the law,she's been a R.N. for almost 20years.She is not incompetent and I have never herd her talk about any of her patients.My mother was a nurse 40+yrs.She did everything from riding with the squad,O.R.,to director of nursing.My brother and sister were C.N.A.'s also.I never asked,but thought confidentiality was hospital policy,not law.My mother would never talk about patients,the same with my brother and sister.Someone told me recently, that you had to sign something in your record for it to be kept secret.By the way,thanks for the site!I guess what I'm saying is,as perfect as I'd like to think she is,she is only human and just made a mistake.I can live with the inconvenience she's caused me.I will make sure my new physician knows how I feel about confidentiality!I thought I would add this,it's from the last part of my mother's class of 1953 Nurse's Pledge.It says"I pledge myself to keep sacred and inviolable whatever matters of an intmate nature may come to my knowledge in the course of duty"
- 2Apr 17, '09 by elkparkYou have to "sign something" (a Release of Information form) in order to give permission for any information to be released from your record (and the form specifies what information is to be released, and to whom), NOT to keep your information private!! Your medical information is always to be kept private unless you give instructions otherwise.
I appreciate that you have a personal relationship with this nurse and information about her past that makes you reluctant to create problems for her, and that is certainly your choice to make, but I do hope you will at least make her employer aware that this happened -- if she did it to you (disclosed legally protected information), she can/will do it to others, and, again (not to beat a dead horse), that is a serious violation of Federal law, state law, state BON rules specific to nurses, and even (as you note ) the Nightingale pledge (!) The next person whose confidentiality she violates may well not feel so charitable and forgiving, and her actions can have legal repercussions for her employer, as well.
- 5Apr 17, '09 by 3boysmom3Just to throw my two cents in; if it were me I would probably opt to just tell the nurse that what she did was upsetting to me, and let her know that I was going to go ahead and change doctors because of it, and let the doctor know as well. Of course it was a serious legal violation. You'd be justified, certainly. But that would be a mighty painful way for the nurse to learn her lesson. If she's the kind and sensitive lady that you describes, it seems to me that she'd be horrified enough to know that her slip impacted you the way it did. You know how sometimes we have an awful experience and learn from it? If I had made that slip, and someone confronted me about it, that would be enough to make me never open my mouth again. But you're the only one who can decide.
- 1Apr 25, '09 by LovingNurseShe made a big mistake and yes, it was against the law. I know you don't want her to get in trouble or go that route - but you REALLY do need to address this. The law is there to protect you. Let her learn through this. Since she's a close family friend and the person she made the oops with was a relative of yours, perhaps she thought everyone was in the information loop as to what is going on with you and didn't think she was disclosing info. Or maybe it just slipped out - but either way, it was wrong.
You said she doesn't talk about other patients - which is good. Was this an innocent slip up?... or A 'can't hold it in' tidbit of info that she just had to tell? ....or..... Overstep of her bounds because she thought that relative needed to know in order for your welfare? ... No matter what the reason, it was wrong and I'm sorry to hear it happened to you.
Talk to her. If you feel that she could learn from this and not do it again, maybe you could stay with the practice.
If you feel that she really can't be trusted even after pointing out the magnitude of her error, then change practices, but her boss needs to know. Sometimes people are uncomfortable going to any practice where they know someone well; even if that person keeps a tight lip on everything, it's still someone you know well - knowing your private health issues. That alone can be enough reason for some folks to seek a different practice. Sometimes folks feel better knowing someone in the office - other times it just complicates things and makes things uncomfortable.
Good luck. (And I hope you are okay.)