therapeutic response: schizophrenic hearing voices

Nursing Students Student Assist

Published

I'm working on case study questions from our unit on schizophrenia. One of the questions is:

What is the most therapeutic response by the nurse to the observation that Caroline turns her head to the side? (The case study mentions that she turns her head to the side as if listening to someone).

A. "Tell me about how you are feeling."

B. "What are you thinking right now?"

C. "Have you been hearing voices?"

D. "I notice that you are talking to yourself."

I eliminated D because the question doesn't say that she is talking to herself, only that she turned her head to the side.

The books says the first intervention is to "Ask the client to describe what she is hearing", so my thought was C, but C only provides the opportunity for a YES or NO answer (closed-ended), which we've been taught to avoid.

I don't believe it's A because I think it's too open-ended and doesn't get to the point of finding out if she's hearing voices.

B is a therapeutic response (and was my initial answer) and is asking about RIGHT NOW.

THANK YOU for your input!

Up Vote Up Vote ×

In reading further notes, it says to validate client's action/comment but present reality. "I see you turning your head. Do you hear something?" C is the only one that actually mentions the possibility of voices.

Up Vote Up Vote ×

I would probably have picked A on this one. Its often the "tell me....." answers were the right ones

Up Vote Up Vote ×
Specializes in Nursing Assistant.
I'm working on case study questions from our unit on schizophrenia. One of the questions is:

What is the most therapeutic response by the nurse to the observation that Caroline turns her head to the side? (The case study mentions that she turns her head to the side as if listening to someone).

A. "Tell me about how you are feeling."

B. "What are you thinking right now?"

C. "Have you been hearing voices?"

D. "I notice that you are talking to yourself."

I eliminated D because the question doesn't say that she is talking to herself, only that she turned her head to the side.

The books says the first intervention is to "Ask the client to describe what she is hearing", so my thought was C, but C only provides the opportunity for a YES or NO answer (closed-ended), which we've been taught to avoid.

I don't believe it's A because I think it's too open-ended and doesn't get to the point of finding out if she's hearing voices.

B is a therapeutic response (and was my initial answer) and is asking about RIGHT NOW.

THANK YOU for your input!

I would go with C.

What was the correct answer?

Sent from my iPhone using allnurses.com

Up Vote Up Vote ×
Specializes in Leadership, Psych, HomeCare, Amb. Care.

C

Yes, it's a closed end question, but you go from there.

Up Vote Up Vote ×

I chose C but I won't be able to review the answers until everyone in the class responds. I'll post when I know. Thanks for your help!

Up Vote Up Vote ×

FYI: the correct answer was "C: Have you been hearing voices?" . Happy I chose C!

Up Vote Up Vote ×
Specializes in Nursing Assistant.
FYI: the correct answer was "C: Have you been hearing voices?" . Happy I chose C!

Thanks for letting us know :)

Sent from my iPhone using allnurses.com

Up Vote Up Vote ×

Hello Runner this is off subject but which would be the best school for nursing. I have all my pre reqs done except for micro. I was looking into cpcc and cchs? Which would be the best way to go being that i have taken some pre reqs? Thanks for the help.

Up Vote Up Vote ×
Hello Runner this is off subject but which would be the best school for nursing. I have all my pre reqs done except for micro. I was looking into cpcc and cchs? Which would be the best way to go being that i have taken some pre reqs? Thanks for the help.

Since I go to CCHS, I would definitely say CCHS! Overall, it has a much better reputation than CPCC.

Up Vote Up Vote ×
+ Add a Comment