- 0Jul 7, '99 by blakeWhy are so many physicians threatened and hostile toward NPs? What are the strategies in dealing with these types of professionals,and in what ways can we make it easier to practice together?
- 19,298 Visits
- 0Feb 21, '04 by hopbaltQuote from blakeFor one thing you can tell your state nursing boards to quit encroaching on the scope of MD work.Why are so many physicians threatened and hostile toward NPs? What are the strategies in dealing with these types of professionals,and in what ways can we make it easier to practice together?
Its no wonder MDs are mad. With the stroke of a pen and nothing more, nursing boards are directly competing against them.
NPs would be spitting mad if there was a bill in the state legislature to give PAs independent practice rights. Everybody tries to protect their turf, including MDs, PAs, and NPs.
- 0Feb 21, '04 by EastCoastQuote from blakeHi Blake.Why are so many physicians threatened and hostile toward NPs? What are the strategies in dealing with these types of professionals,and in what ways can we make it easier to practice together?
I'm fortunate that i've had minimal if any hostility. I also first worked as a house officer role so I was working to 'help' house docs manage their patients off hours. This made the docs more familiar with me as a person and a practitioner. I have made it a point now in private practice to consult subspecialities and always note in my progress note "so and so help appreciated ". If i see the doc in person i will also thank them. We have a 'doctors' lounge and i will swing by on my way in and out and converse with whoever is there. If i send one of my patients to a doc as an outpatient i will always write an introductory letter before hand and send my latest exam. What has been nice is that now some docs will write for me specifically for a consult. Now, there is one doc who would always change whatever antibiotic i ordered when i covered him and i think overall he is just inept and threatened. He treats the staff nurses like idiots they outshine him daily. The payback?? If someone is looking for a new PCP I will never recommend him.
- 0Feb 23, '04 by TMnurseQuote from blakeI am an RN (prospective NP) working in a University hospital where the doctor NP relationship works very well. I guess much of the MD to NP relationship is based on over all setting. At an academic teaching center, the is no competition for the almighty $$$... maybe that's why they no one fights here.
- 0Feb 23, '04 by PA-C, DOThe reason that physicians are hostile toward NP's is that NP's attempt to seek more autonomy when their training does not prepare them to be solo providers. The pathophysiologic knowledge necessary to be a medical provider is simply well above that taught in any NP program. At least in PA school they teach the basics of the medical model, and they humbly agree that they need supervision to provide the best care. NP's will slowly alienate all state medical boards to the point that the they will push them to urge legislators to repeal the current nursing practice acts. NP's should simply learn that they serve an important role, but one that should be supervised. NP's will only cut off their own tails if they continue to seek autonomy.
- 0Feb 24, '04 by RolandHap, and PAC does that mean that if NP programs added another thirty hours or so in additional classes such as gross anatomy, and advanced, advanced (since many already have advanced patho) pathophysiology that you would be satisfied and agree to more NP autonomy? Don't get me wrong, I do NOT blaim you for opposing the expansion of NP autonomy, just be honest and "keep it real". Every profession seeks to protect, and at the same time expand it's "turf". It is intrinsic in our economic system from accountants and appraisers to zoologists and zoo-keepers. At the same time almost none of these groups will admit their true motivations (and yes this probably includes NP's from time to time also). M.D's will wage a legislative, and PR war with NP's. Sometimes they will win, and sometimes they will lose (other times it will be a stalemate). NP's can appeal to HMO's, insurance companies, government, and hospitals that they are safe, and COST EFFECTIVE (in a setting of health care inflation that runs double to triple the rate of overall inflation in the overall economy). On the other hand M.D's can appeal to tradition, and the great trust that the public tends to place in them (as well as rely upon long established political contacts, and considerable economic firepower). It will be an interesting contest, but don't pretend it is something other than what it actually is, a battle rooted in our economic history and intrinsic to our economic system.Last edit by Roland on Feb 24, '04
- 0Feb 24, '04 by globalRNI work in a teaching hospital.
I have not experienced doctor hostility just because I am a NP. The hematology physicians I work with created the NP position ...it was THEIR idea to hire a NP...and I believe it is working out well. Doctors in other specialties have been courteous and professional when I send patients for consult. Any negative vibes that I have had, have come from staff nurses, notably the ones who have been practicing 20+years.