Vent from a crusty old bat

Nurses General Nursing

Published

First off, I want to say that almost ALL of our newer staff are either already excellent, or have potential to BE excellent nurses with a little experience. Maybe my facility is just lucky, but we have primarily superb new hire RNs.

That said, every once in a while there is that one individual who is relatively inexperienced, but is pompous, pretentious, and truly believes that they are personally God's greatest gift to the nursing profession in our lifetimes. And sometimes these individuals are placed in a position of responsibility, such as Charge Nurse or Shift Supervisor. However ill-advised this assignment is, it only feeds the narcissism of this self-important person.

Lots of times these unfortunate primotions are a result of friendship or nepotism. Sometimes (as in this particular case), the reason is "we need to have more male charge nurses to prove we are 'diverse' ".

This young gentleman at my facility (let's call him Matt for the sake of argument), is incredibly self- important and feels comfortable dispensing his "knowledge" quite freely. He recently "corrected" an experienced and highly valued pulmonologist on his line insertion technique.... Embarrassing to say the least! Prior to this incident, he nearly killed a patient by incorrectly attaching a wound vac suction to a post-op patient with an open abdomen.

These, and several other similar incidents have been reported to unit management, who state "he will grow into the position." I wonder at what expense. This also makes me wonder once again exactly WHY he has been placed in any kind of supervisory position. Friend? Family,? I'm not sure.

My question is this: Has anyone else experienced this type of scenario? If so, how did you handle it? Barring an actual patient death or sentinel event, what can be done? I am beyond frustrated at this point! Any help is appreciated!

Specializes in CICU, Telemetry.

Even though what you find most distasteful may be his attitude, make sure you use management buzzwords in your communication about issues.

'unsafe to practice'

'fear he will cause a sentinel event'

'liability issue for the hospital'

I have had a lot more success when I've pointed out that when the person makes a huge error it will be INCREDIBLY expensive for the institution than just pointing out that someone is totally ineffective in their position and the absolute worst idea.

Even though what you find most distasteful may be his attitude, make sure you use management buzzwords in your communication about issues.

'unsafe to practice'

'fear he will cause a sentinel event'

'liability issue for the hospital'

I have had a lot more success when I've pointed out that when the person makes a huge error it will be INCREDIBLY expensive for the institution than just pointing out that someone is totally ineffective in their position and the absolute worst idea.

This uss excellent advice!! I have personally seem this in action. Thank you for reminding me!

Specializes in Psychiatry, Community, Nurse Manager, hospice.

So men who enter the nursing profession get into positions of authority without adequate experience or knowledge for "diversity"?????

Basically saying, We need to hire a man for this position.

Holy back to the 1960s batman.

No wonder he's a pompous schmuck. He's been given a job because of his genitalia.

So men who enter the nursing profession get into positions of authority without adequate experience or knowledge for "diversity"?????

Hard to believe, right?

It's been my experience that the men I've worked with in nursing are generally just as capable, talented, and skillful as the women. Great nurses are great nurses. It is a huge step backward; however, if we start promoting people based solely on sex, race, religion, lifestyle, etc. In this day and age we should be sophisticated enough to hire and promote based on ability and skill.

So men who enter the nursing profession get into positions of authority without adequate experience or knowledge for "diversity"?????

Hard to believe, right?

It's been my experience that the men I've worked with in nursing are generally just as capable, talented, and skillful as the women. Great nurses are great nurses. It is a huge step backward; however, if we start promoting people based solely on sex, race, religion, lifestyle, etc. In this day and age we should be sophisticated enough to hire and promote based on ability and skill.

So there's this situtation and The Evil Twins. Well, I hope things get better soon.

Specializes in Critical Care, Med-Surg, Psych, Geri, LTC, Tele,.

I've seen this occurrence. Most recently, our "Team Leads" have often been inexperienced (

I've also seen people appointed as mgrs because they have the correct letters after their name, even though they lack relevant experience.

I have learned its best to lay low and do my job and document, document, document. I've learned not to complain, because (in some places) bedside nurses are seen as expendable while the covetted "Leads/Mgrs" are harder for them to replace.

+ Add a Comment