Nurses are Irresponsible and Money Oriented

This article is about the growing public opinion that nurses are irresponsible and money oriented and, how this opinion discourages people from pursuing nursing as a carreer. This article is based on my observations and experience. Nurses Announcements Archive Article

Before pursuing nursing as a career, I had a bad impression of nurses from what I had heard but I never propagated it.

A couple of years ago when my grandmother had a knee surgery, I got a chance to look closely into how nurses provide care and communicate with patients and their family. I noticed how therapeutically the nurses talked to my grandmother. They explained everything so well and even answered the relevant questions I asked out of curiosity. Never before this episode did I ever want to be a nurse.

When I talked to some friends about my positive views about nursing and nurses, I was confused to hear what they had to say. Occasionally, people have opposing views but if they are contrary to what you believe in you start to doubt your own observations, it can be disturbing.

One of my friends openly declared that nurses are evil and work solely for money and do not really care about their patients. They care for the patient just enough to keep themselves out of trouble but they ignore a patient's unsaid obvious needs like positioning, which make them cruel.

Such views about nurses lead me to think if real nurses have forgotten their ethics but, something inside me said that these views are a stereotype. I decided to venture into the world of nursing to unravel the truth myself.

I have finished the first year of my nursing program and I am still determined to be a nurse. During my field placement at a hospital, I figured out the driving force behind the different opinions about nurses - the positive and the negative. Nurses follow some nursing ethics which form the very basis of their job.

Patient wellness, patient confidentiality, truthfulness, fairness and respecting patient choices are the values that need to be adopted in order to be a nurse, but does everybody has the ability to do so?

To be tough, caring, agile and strong enough to keep secrets all at once may not be the qualities present in a single person. People have preconceived notions about good nurses and they want them to 'act' accordingly. What they don't know is that it takes time for different personalities to incorporate a nurse's qualities.

People have different personalities and when they become nurses, their way of providing care and communicating with others differs. People categorize nurses as friendly or unfriendly, knowledgeable or unknowledgeable, caring or negligent etc.

It cannot be denied that negligence by nurses have lead to serious medical consequences for patients. However, it does not imply that all nurses are irresponsible. Despite all the hard work that nurses do, people seem to complain. Over a dozen of people I talked to had low opinion about nurses but only three of them had actually witnessed poor treatment by nurses. Why and how did the rest form a bad image of nurses? Maybe the same way I had formed it when I believed what people said.

Nurses are neither angels nor demons, only human. They make mistakes, try to learn from them and take care not to repeat them. Does anyone realize that when people vilify the nursing profession without putting themselves in nurses' shoes, how many good-nurses-to-be are discouraged from joining it?

I so hate to hear these stories, from people that are treated so badly. My job isn't perfect but I have been lucky enough to, for the most part, work with people I respect and be treated with respect. That's not to say everyone, but most.

I want to video them, make them watch themselves, then hopefully be ashamed. People that act like that don't deserve to be nurses. Or humans for that matter. :mad: Unfortunately, or fortunately for them, I don't rule the world.

Just believe you are there for a reason, to make a difference, and don't stoop to their level.

Then come work with me! :heartbeat

Specializes in Ortho/Peds/MedSURG/LTC.

I am so burned. My experience with nursing has been so heartwrenching sad. I love nursing, work circles around some, I know I am smart - I was so new. If I could go back there and begin again. The first week their slang during report "appy's" Lap-colys"..the look on my face. Instead of me stopping them in their tracks (what I'd do now) with WHOOOAH what are you talking about. I was sooo frustrated with this look on my face. They would run to that chain smoking manager telling her I was stupid did not know anything behind my back. I went to the nice nurse that trained me and asked her.."what is an appy?" She explained their use of slang...its an appendectomy :). Meanwhile the manager, who never took the time to ask, thought I was the stupid one. I for one would never ever stoop to their level - bunch of insecure, severely lacking social skills, self centered...hateful...posers on facebook...needing attention..drama...hags to be. I may have my heart on my sleeve but I did not deserve the way they treated me or others. The manager when put on the floor was clueless...she'd tell me "I don't know why the patients love you like they do..but here.-it'd be another card" (I hated receiving any recognition of kindness from patients because the girls got meaner) MY first day on the job..the manager said and I quote "they are going to eat you alive!"....and she was right. I left after one year..it was like a tour ...in a prison..they were the inmates..and their wasn't any thing I could do. Enough of this..it makes me sick. thank you for listening dmdmd thank you for your kindness appreciated:nurse:

Good you left. What an awful place. I believe you but your situation is not normal. There are always going to be nasty people but somehow you got a bunch of them. You had bad luck. Try again at another hospital. We would NEVER treat someone like that and I have been at the same place for over 20 years. NEVER!

Specializes in Critical Care.

Had to write. There are some nurses that do not care, however; they are far and few. How many professions have employees who work 12+ hours with a 5 minute break (no food or water because JC and OSHA feel it is not safe for these people to do eat and drink at the nurses station or running down the hall---the only way some of us are able to do this). How many people come home from work and cry, because they could not do their best r/t hospital administration and politics. How many professionals get abused on a daily basis? If I walked into a restaurant and handed out the emotional and physical abuse that many of us nurses experience, I would be shown the door if not arrested. In it for the money, what a joke. I am at the point of quiting a brand new hospital that was tauted as exceeding the ultimate in patient satisfaction. My ASS. I have to beg some physicians for orders and it is always the nurses fault. Why are the nurses always the scapegoats? Why are we blamed for a very flawed health care system. An honorable profession my ASS.

Very true. It is NOT an honorable profession and I wonder why anyone thinks so? It is just health care at its most intimate. That is it. Nothing more. Nothing less. Except comes with tons of responsibilities. That is why it pays more than working at the mall. So if I look at it that way, I can work 3 eight hr days/week and make twice as much or more than someone working full time at a mall, etc. Now the job is good! I do not pay for health insurance coverage (other than little co-pay) and get lots of days off, education days off. Not a bad thing.

Everyone wants to survive and how do we survive? By WORKING. The field of nursing has been a buzz to different individuals who wanted to have a career where they can assure themselves that they will receive a good salary. I admit that I want to get into the nursing field to earn a living for my family. Aside from that though, I love to see the people that I help regain their health back to normal smiling and seeing their faces full of life. I want to be able to help my future patients to provide them not only with health care but also to provide them support spiritually, emotionally, and psychologically. Being a nursing is not all about the salary we receive at the end of every salary period but it is about providing our patients with the best health care possible and to be a supporting hand in terms of despair and sadness. There is more to being a nurse than just Money. It is sad to admit though that there are OTHERS out there that enters the world of nursing just for it.

I am glad you wrote this article. While reading it, I became inspired to work harder as a nursing student. :) God Bless you

Jema

You sound so idealistic. Please get into reality land. You will make a difference for some, yes. But most patients are sent home still recovering. It is not like many many years ago when people actually "recovered" in a hospital. And you will be so busy with electronic charting, paper work, that your time with the patient will be mostly just to pass meds and change dressings, give blood transfusions, etc. So while you are doing that, you will have that time to spend. You will be lucky sometimes because just sometimes you will have time just because all your other patients were easy, walkie talkies or unable to even use a call light. You are going into it with the right attitude but you will change because it is not about you, but about getting the job done for the next nurse to continue it.

HI needshaldol,

Thank you for telling me that I am idealistic and that I should be realistic. :) I am going to start my nursing program this fall semester. Thank you for telling me not to expect that everything will be according to my expectations and that there is another story to being a nurse.

Thanks!

Jema

I've been an RN for 26 years, and more recently (and too frequently) a patient in ERs and an oncology unit. I've seen a lot of good nurses, and unfortunately those who have absolutely no compassion, or realization that "work" is a verb. Compassion can't be taught. If someone goes to nursing school only looking at personal gain, they will end up being lousy at any interpersonal care.

I've had some great nurses. I've also had ER nurses tell me that "all seizure patients are non-compliant and don't follow up with their regular doctors"...I had been sent to the ER per my doc's epilepsy parameters- nobody cared about that. I never deviated from my anticonvulsant med prescription- and had therapeutic levels. I've been told that chronic illness patients are a "wasted bed"- again, I was following my doc's instructions to go to the ER when my BP dropped below 70/50 (I've got dysautonomia, and at the time a lot of this was going on, an undiscovered/unquestioned drug interaction was trashing my BP a lot).

I've had 2 nurses on either side of an ER gurney shoving ammonia inhalants under my nose when I was regaining consciousness after passing out from the BP problem-- they would NOT back up and let me breathe. I've had a nurse inflate a foley balloon ON my internal sphincter, and walk away when I reacted in pain (verbally- calmly, but urgently saying something was wrong) and ended up pushing it in the rest of the way myself-- I was there for a BP that had been so low I became unconscious at a neighbors' home with no warning- after 4 liters of fluid, I was sent to ICU because they were going to start dopamine- fortunately, the fluids ended up working- but I wasn't there for grins and giggles. I've had nurses tell me that if i could push the medical alert system button (with preprogrammed information at the service center about where I lived and medical info that EMS would need) I didn't need an ER. This was also set up per my MDs orders. I was being compliant with my MDs instructions, but trashed at the ER because the nurses didn't like patients with chronic illnesses who were having emergent issues.

I had a nurse send me to the waiting room for a cab, when she knew it would be 45 minutes before they got there...I'd been brought in with a blood sugar of 37mg/dl- and had just started insulin, so was having a lot of trouble at home getting it to go up. I got the D50W (2 amps), and NO protein follow up. My blood sugar started crashing in the waiting room. When I told the triage desk (after trying regular soda and candy) they told me "you've already been seen".... I was safer in the cab.

I have a typed out medical history in my wallet, and it explains my diagnoses (not everyone has dealt with dysautonomia), the reason for all meds, and what MDs I see and why. I've never been a call-light jockey, and learned to disconnect monitors since call lights were generally left out of reach. I'd get myself to the bathroom, then reconnect the monitors. Nobody ever reacted to the alarms, which in the case of that ER was a blessing...but for those who can't navigate in a hospital, could be deadly. I've never asked for pain meds, never demanded anything, and have been compliant and cooperative- and still treated worse than a rabid bat. (the dud/horrible stuff was all at a particular ER in the area that has a horrible Press Ganey score and anybody I've talked to who's been there has had similar experiences- it's not just me- which is inexcusable).

Nurses have always been the measure of what makes a good hospital, for me. I've had great nurses. I've had those who respected my years of experience, and really included me in my care- not just tolerated me. I've worked hard to not be a 'bad patient'. When I've been in the hospital for leukemia over the past 16 months, the nurses have been wonderful. (different hospital than the scary ER)

When people ask me about my experiences, I don't sugar-coat anything. As with any profession, there are bad apples who have no business doing what they do. I believe that most of the bad apples don't last long- they just aren't cut out to be compassionate and caring. They aren't equipped to deal with intense situations that require helping someone through a horrible period in their life. And, fortunately, there are those who understand that it's not all about them when they're working. They don't have so many of their own emotional needs that it seeps over into their professional life.

I've worked with many wonderful nurses- way more than the duds. But as a patient, I've seen a lot of duds (still more good- but an unsettling number of uncaring people that go through the motions looking only at payday). When I was still working, I'd talk to those who were abrupt or cold towards patients. My basic question to them was how would they want to be treated if they were scared, didn't know what the future held, or in an environment that was overwhelming and impersonal (even the best places are still institutions :) ). Many had never considered the view of the patient.

I continue to be on guard when I'm in the hospital, and feel terrible for people without a medical background who have to deal with the duds. I've also had horrendous experiences with ER docs, but that's a whole different story (but it was at the place with the nurses who should have only worked in morgues- though I don't know if they could have respect for the deceased either).

I think nursing is a great profession- I miss working a LOT since being disabled. But I'd question anybody going to nursing school about why they want to be a nurse- if it's for job availability and a decent paycheck, I'd hope they'd be useful in another area that minimized human interaction.... JMHO :)

Specializes in Home Health.Plastic Surgery.Gen Surgery.

Thanks for your posting. Being a nurse is by no means an easy job. You need to want so much more than just money to be an excellent nurse. I have been disappointed a few times by hearing people take nursing pre-reqs just because they want more money...they're in for a good one when can't hang taking care of patients. I really think being a nurse is something special.

-Mo

I have read this article 4 times, and I STILL don't understand the point. Apparently, nurses need time to grow into thier positions; yes that is true; and the general public are quick to judge with little reason to do so. Was that it? I am just not sure what I was supposed to take away from this.

Maybe it's a personal comment, leaving people to take from it what they will....not sure there has to be a universal point to it, or set message- we all read into things based on our own experiences. ???