Nat'l Nurses Week(ness) - page 3
It is my opinion that our celebration of ourselves and public displays of "look at us" are embarrassing. I did a search on Google.com(a popular search engine). Here are the keywords searched and... Read More
May 6, '01TLynn,
What part of these posts makes you sick and rather die than be cared for by one of us?
Is it the part where I suggest accepting unsafe conditions for patients is a weakness?
Perhaps it is that I feel insulted by poems that portray nurses as superhuman?
Bottom line is I choose to be dignified.
How dare you suggest I do not like this profession. I do not like the mockery some are making of this profession. I've pretty clearly stated some examples.
I draw my power for working from knowing I am a great nurse.
I should refrain from getting snotty but I have to say, based on your post, you are probably one of those that are keeping nurses from being recognized as a profession. I am sure you disagree. I knew there would be division.
[ May 05, 2001: Message edited by: HotSpam ]
May 6, '01aha, after reviewing your profile I think I found the sore spot. Your a poet!!
I didn't mean the attack on poems about nurses personally but it is a good example of what I think is a nurse writing a self glorifying tribute to nurses that well exceeds reality.
reposted with credit:
A hand reaches down from somewhere up above,
A hand of miracles, a hand doing what it loves.
Calming a sick child that is in need,
Wiping tears from an elderly woman's cheek.
The face of this stranger is all aglow,
No eyes, no mouth, it seems to have no nose.
Something lightly touches the hands of the dying,
Comforts family and friends who are crying.
It feels like feathers, it appears to be wings,
And bove the head, there floats a gold ring.
They carry a warmth that soothes and heals,
Leesons that pain that no longer seems real.
The swiftness of this stranger, the power that it holds,
Is miraculous, unselfish, giving of it's very soul.
Who is this stranger, reaching down from above?
With passion, warmth, honest love?
An Angel? God? Could be perhaps.
For the miracles they assist in the must have pwoers such as that.
To those whose life is graced with their presence, their touch,
They must be Heavenly beings sent from above.
But, no, this is not an angel, or someone of higher power for sure,
This person who's touching you is simply...a nurse.
May 7, '01I never celebrated Nat Nurses week in any way but I never gave it much thought either. After giving it the thought that this post forced me to give it I conclude that I LOVE THIS POST..
May 9, '01I received a private message from TLYNN.
Subject: Nat'l Nurses Week
What makes me sick that people think you are so high and mighty. We all know never to take any position that is unsafe for us or our patients, but to say that we don't deserve to be rembered for our hard, sometimes low paying jobs is wrong. I don't care what people think about poetry, that is a ligitimate way for those to releive the stress of nursing. Don't like them? Don't read them it is that simple. Poetry has a power of healing all it's own, I have letter about letter from all over the nation and Canada about a poem I wrote and had published on the OKC bombing. So don't ready them if you take that much offense to them.
This is the message in it's entirety. I think is only right to share it with everyone who contributed to this thread.
TLYNN, "Don't like them - Don't read them" isn't the point. The point I am making is the proliferation of these type of poems is a weakness. It keeps us patting each others backs, unrealistic, and enables the "mission" mentality.
Perhaps it would be different if we were discussing inspired poetry or prose with language that is reflective of the realities we face as nurses. But we are not. Perhaps that job should be left to true artists.
If you desire to seriously discuss the role of your poetry in nursing and furthermore suggest it reflects our professionalism It would help you to write in a manner that is easy to understand. From reading your post above It seems as though english is your second language. Either way, perhaps you should brush up on it a little.
May 9, '01Just saw the list at the ana site (www.ana.com) about nurses week and found it interesting that malaysia, Guam and Saudi Arabia had activities that far surpassed the ice cream socials and logo pens. Maybe they want to keep their nurses happy there since our recruiters are headed in their directions!
May 9, '01I must say I'm somewhat relieved to see a post on this topic. It makes me feel a little less like an old curmudgeon (sp?). I really thought it was just me.
I have never been big on ceremony- I didn't even attend my own graduation (a 'pinning' ceremony!). It was only important to me and my dad. He was too sick to attend and I already knew I had graduated, so..
I wonder how much of this stuff stems from nursing being a 'female' profession. I dislike bowties, teddy bears, knick-knacks, and, frankly, the junk that is often offered as token gifts. Our nurses day included a free make-up and fingernail session. Ugh.
I don't mean to sound ungrateful for a gift offered in kindness, but I'd just really rather be treated respectfully and acknowledged professionally. This doesn't have to be on a special, designated day.
I think nurses week would be better recognised by inviting non-nurses and future potential nurses to view our world of work, and perhaps be invited to join us. The best reward I get at my job is the satisfaction of a job well done. Despite its flaws, nursing is an immensely rewarding career.
May 9, '01Wow,
I'm impressed with the outcome of the initial post. I thought that surely this concept would have been disintegrated by now. I'm glad to know that it hasn't.
May 10, '01TLynn,
I would like to apologize if any offense for your poem was taken, I meant none. I know that for some this is a reliever, it is just that for me I believe that nurses should be seen in a more realistic light. As people with other responsibilities and obligations besides what they do for a living. I do believe that nurses are special, as it takes a special kind of person to be a nurse, it is truly an art and a science. However I will also offer up that when we wrap ourselves in the mantle of Florence Nightengale too tightly we smother ourselves quite deliberately.
Poetry can be beautiful and thought provoking as can any good writing. I myself love "Leaves of Grass." Read part of it at my dads funeral.
I am addressing this to you in the hopes that you understand how some of us feel about the touchy feely poems that are so prevelant about nurses and why we feel that way. I find it distasteful that someone else would post a personal email that was sent to them. Regradless of the motives for doing so I do not believe it should have been done. I'm sure that you have written beautiful things that have meant much to others, please just understand that not all of us feel that way about being a nurse. I am sorry that some have chosen the path of ridicule instead of explaining why they feel the way they do.
May 11, '01Truly good poetry must have certain elements.
1. Conciseness. See T.S. Elliot, e.e. cummings and/or Walt Whitman
2. Lyricism. See Shakespeare, E.A. Poe, E.B. Browning.
For poetry to be great, perhaps even move the reader to tears (of joy), it must express some universal idea. See Robert Browning, Emily Dickinson, and many others whom I cannot name.
I also do not wish to offend, but I find National Nurses Week offensive. I see it as the health care industry (the multi-billion dollar health care industry ) saying " We have to have you but we need you to work real cheap so we can increase our profits to record levels. So in lieu of any real rewards for your service, take this highly processed food, these key chains, coffee mugs and other advertising gimmics and be happy." But that is the opinion of one man, an incredibly well educated and erudite man,
perhaps one of the great thinkers of our time, but still only one.
[ May 11, 2001: Message edited by: cmggriff ]
May 11, '01Originally posted by Tiara:
<STRONG>Just saw the list at the ana site (www.ana.com) about nurses week and found it interesting that malaysia, Guam and Saudi Arabia had activities that far surpassed the ice cream socials and logo pens. Maybe they want to keep their nurses happy there since our recruiters are headed in their directions!</STRONG>