Muslim, Orthodox Jews, Mennonites; How to care for female patients of "modest" faiths

Nurses General Nursing

Published

Hello everyone,

I have a situation and would like some opinions.

I have a friend who went to an ER the other day. She had fallen and hurt her leg and knee. She is a Muslim and wears a hijab (headscarf) and long dress. Her hijab covers her hair, neck and ears are but not her face.

She first asked for a female doctor. Anyway, there was no female doctor on duty, but she did not have a problem with seeing a male doctor as they offered her a female nurse in the room.

They asked her to take off all her clothes, including her headscarf and any underwear so they could examine the leg. Then they asked her to wait in a small waiting room as they might have to wheel her down to radiology

She had worn no bra or metal clothing, a pair of easy remove bike shorts and a flowing caftan so she would only have to lift up the hem and take off the shorts so she would be nude under her caftan. They could see all the way up to her pelvic bone or take x-rays if neeeded.

She said they did offer her a paper hospital gown, but when she asked for a second hospital gown and to keep on her headscarf to preserve her modest, the nurse told her they did not have any. She said she explained as best she could her need for modesty to the nurse and tech who first saw her, but they were not very nice. She left without being treated.

My Muslim girlfriend is a college educated American and was raised in the US. She was not raised a Muslim and reverted about ten years ago. Of course she is quite familiar with American culture and healthcare, so I do not think that was the problem.

Of course I understand and emergency is an emergency and if you have to cut the clothes of a trauma victim to save their life, you do what you must.

Curious, do hospitals have procedures to deal with members of very modest faiths like the Mennonite, Amish, Muslims or Orthodox Jews?

I would liek to through another religion in the mix of the conversation.

In christian science they do not beleive in health care of medicine, how is this handled, especially in an emergency case?

I pulled this form a website on the religion.

Additionally, Christian Scientists prefer not to use doctors, medicine, or immunizations. Christian Science Practitioners are used to help people through the false reality of illness.

Proper prayer and training are employed to battle the "non-reality" of illness.

They have no ordinances like the Lord's Supper or baptism.

Church services are interspersed with Bible reading and readings from Science and Health.

Mary Baker Eddy is highly regarded as a revelator of God's word, almost equal to Jesus.

Specializes in Critical Care.
In christian science they do not beleive in health care of medicine, how is this handled, especially in an emergency case?

I would think that the only emergency cases for that religion would be the ones that were brought in unaccompanied and unconscious, therefore unless they have something on their person stating they are christian scientist, they would be treated the same as any other person would in that situation. It's not ethical to withhold treatment just becasue you aren't sure of a person's religious persuasion.

seems to me that they were making their own little crusade here against this poor women. as there was no pertinent need for this women to be forced to strip down even after it was made clear to them that it went against her religious beliefs. in all honesty there is no real need for clothes to be removed for an modern x-ray machines and for older ones lite clothing without any metals are fine. and to make her remove her head scarf is down right wrong.

+ Add a Comment