Gender Pay Gap in Nursing: 2017 Salary Survey vs. 2015?

Over the past couple of years, several studies and surveys have revealed that there is a gender gap in nursing salaries. Published in 2016, an allnurses.com survey yielded results also showing the wage gap with men making more per hour than their female coworkers. Nurses General Nursing Video Salary Survey

Updated:  

In 2015 The Journal of American Medicine released a study on the pay gap between male and female nurses. That survey revealed that male nurses earn about $5100 per year more than women. This survey sparked much interest and dialog as to the reasons for this disparity.

Quote
The new analysis, which included data on more than 290,000 registered nurses, also found that the pay gap had not narrowed within workplace settings and specialties from 1988 to 2013. The new study is the first to have measured gender disparities in pay among nurses over time.

Published in 2016, an allnurses.com survey yielded results also showing the wage gap with men making more per hour than their female coworkers. Is it just about gender or are there other variables that factor into the results?

Women make up 92% of the nursing workforce while men hold only 7.74%, as noted in the allnurses. com 2015 survey. The majority of nurses at the time were paid hourly, 80%, in fact. Men tended toward specialty areas like anesthesiology (with 41% of nurse anesthetists being men), cardiac care, critical care and Emergency room care. The AMA study found that approximately 40 percent of nurse anesthetist are men and were paid on the average $17,290 more annually than female nurse anesthetists.

It seems that one of the main factors that may influence the gender wage gap is that woman take time off to care for family and children. When they return to the workforce they often come back at generally the same pay grade while men have continued working and have received hourly wage increases along the way.

Women are also more apt to regulate their work hours. They seek out opportunities for a more traditional 9-5 nursing job or a shorter work week, again to meet the needs of work/family balance. Men are more likely to take "off hour" opportunities for higher pay and have more overtime on a regular basis.

In the 2017 allnurses Salary Survey nurses were asked to provide the number of regular hours they work per week as well as how many hours of paid overtime they average per week. This data, as well as a breakdown by gender, could shed some additional light on the gender gap in salary.

Men are also known to negotiate salary increases and higher pay rates than women. This accounts for some of the higher wage per hour values noted.

As we are nearing the release of the current (2017) allnurses.com salary results, it will be interesting to see if the gender gap has narrowed over the past year and what the variables will look like! What are some of your thoughts on this finding?

The complete results including interactive graphs are posted now in these 2 articles:

2017 allnurses Salary Survey Results Part 1: Demographics and Compensation

30% of Nurses Leaving the Workforce - 2017 Salary Survey Results Part 2

Resources:

Pay Gap Between Male and Female RNs Has Not Narrowed

Although women dominate the nursing profession, do men make more money?

2015 allnurses Salary Survey Results

I am male and I work as a Psych nurse. I get paid a little bit more than my female coworkers. In my case, it is because I am expected to take on a more physical role than most. I deal with violent psychotic patients on a regular basis. Yes, women can do my job. I have no doubt. The only caveat to that is a nurse that is 5'2"-5"5 inches and 120 pounds would have a real problem dealing with 6'2" and 280 pounds of violent psychosis. Me, at 6'4" and 300 pounds has less of an issue.

1 Votes

"I am male and I work as a Psych nurse. I get paid a little bit more than my female coworkers. In my case, it is because I am expected to take on a more physical role than most. I deal with violent psychotic patients on a regular basis. Yes, women can do my job. I have no doubt. The only caveat to that is a nurse that is 5'2"-5"5 inches and 120 pounds would have a real problem dealing with 6'2" and 280 pounds of violent psychosis. Me, at 6'4" and 300 pounds has less of an issue."

I really hope you are just being sarcastic here...this would be a fast track to a human resource nightmare because it is the most blatant sexist EEO case that could possibly exist.

I wish you would have just said you had the balls to negotiate or something, and not reinforce the false narrative that men make more than women just for being men, which basically what you just said.

For the rest of the people reading these blogs just look around, female nurses as a whole do make more than men for many reasons, but mostly because women are in the leadership and management positions due to earning it!! If you are seriously thinking someone makes more than you (regardless of their sex) and you do not like it....ensure you are in the right based on qualifications, and demand more money or leave....I mean that's what a guy would do :)

1 Votes
Secretperson said:

I really hope you are just being sarcastic here...this would be a fast track to a human resource nightmare because it is the most blatant sexist EEO case that could possibly exist.

While the post shows traditional gender roles in a workplace environment it is not sexist. He is not getting paid more BECAUSE HE'S A MAN. He gets paid more because his job duties entail more dangerous work than the other staff. If there were a 6'1" 320lb woman that does the same job opposite shift they would assumably get the same compensation as the poster, for doing the same job.

A male desk cop does not get the same pay as a female street cop. They are both police. One's job is more dangerous and is compensated rightly so.

If there were a female at his job that wanted to do the work he does, and qualifies for it, and they turn her down or pay her less due to her gender then THAT IS sexist. As it stands you're all hot and bothered over simple traditional roles.

Seriously, if you take the emotion out of this and look at numbers and reasons there are easy ways to account for disparities. Here is simply one job is more dangerous and is compensated for such.

1 Votes
Specializes in PACU, ED.
tnbutterfly said:
The graphs are interactive. You can select various filters including location, years of experience, gender, specialty,degree, etc.

We have separate graphs for hourly pay and salary pay. You will be able to compare average hourly pay for all hourly paid respondents, full and part time. Annual pay comparisons uses data from only full time respondents and it is based on the amount of income reported to the IRS.

Are the graphs available? I have not been able to find them. Thanks.

1 Votes
Feelgood RN said:
While the post shows traditional gender roles in a workplace environment it is not sexist. He is not getting paid more BECAUSE HE'S A MAN. He gets paid more because his job duties entail more dangerous work than the other staff. If there were a 6'1" 320lb woman that does the same job opposite shift they would assumably get the same compensation as the poster, for doing the same job.

I would agree with you if the nurse is hired specifically as a nurse and bouncer, but with almost two decades of healthcare under my belt and as a hiring authority...I have never seen this practice, however, if you are correct good for him ?

I can promise you that if a more qualified licensed professional was boxed out of the RN position because of a "size" requirement a good HR would destroy this units hiring process.

1 Votes
Specializes in Peds, Med-Surg, Disaster Nsg, Parish Nsg.
azhiker96 said:
Are the graphs available? I have not been able to find them. Thanks.

Yes, the complete results including interactive graphs are posted now in these 2 articles:

2017 allnurses Salary Survey Results Part 1: Demographics and Compensation

30% of Nurses Leaving the Workforce - 2017 Salary Survey Results Part 2

1 Votes

I have a lot to say about this is feel its extremely unfair for them to say women "like" to take time off. The role of a women is very difficult and the belief that we just willy-nilly take time off is just false. First off finding child care can be an extremely difficult task! It took me years to find a solution that didn't choke the life outta my wallet. Women are expected by society as a whole to be homemakers and caregivers of their families before they are anything else and we are considered bad moms if we dare for one second take our eyes off our child(ren).

If men and women were both expected to take time off due to family needs then the playing field would be not only more fair but more easy on all the players involved. If it wasn't for my nanny I couldn't support my family. I pay a good bit for it. I pay and my employer pays for a Back up Care program LBC's Child Care benefits program which has helped me so much I recommend it to everyone I know. It saved my sanity. (luxurybabyconcierge.com if anyone is curious I swear by their service honestly couldnt have made it thru college or my Res w/o it.)

1 Votes
StarrActress said:
I have a lot to say about this is feel its extremely unfair for them to say women "like" to take time off. The role of a women is very difficult and the belief that we just willy-nilly take time off is just false. First off finding child care can be an extremely difficult task! It took me years to find a solution that didn't choke the life outta my wallet. Women are expected by society as a whole to be homemakers and caregivers of their families before they are anything else and we are considered bad moms if we dare for one second take our eyes off our child(ren).

If men and women were both expected to take time off due to family needs then the playing field would be not only more fair but more easy on all the players involved. If it wasn't for my nanny I couldn't support my family. I pay a good bit for it. I pay and my employer pays for a Back up Care program LBC's Child Care benefits program which has helped me so much I recommend it to everyone I know. It saved my sanity. (luxurybabyconcierge.com if anyone is curious I swear by their service honestly couldnt have made it thru college or my Res w/o it.)

I know many young couples where the male stays home with the child, in fact I lobbied for that for a long time but my wife told me that if anyone was staying home, it was her. I believe the joke is with the younger couples that no one gets to stay at home anymore due to financial constraints.

I cannot understand what you are saying. Are you blaming social pressures for you taking time off of work thus stunting your career? Why didn't your significant other just stay home? Why didn't you just get a nanny like you do now?

Where do you live where the social pressures are that high? Hell, everywhere I have traveled in the U.S. the financial pressures keep people anyone from staying home.

1 Votes

There are companies nowadays that make it equal. When I was hired I got my number from a grid. Number of years experienced, maxed out by a certain number of years and that was my pay. I knew this before I even interviewed with one facility. Interviewed with another facility owned by same company the next day. In less than thirty minutes I had two offer letters from different recruiters with the same exact hourly rate.

1 Votes