Called a Hero

Nurses General Nursing

Published

February 28, 2003 New York Region

The New York Times

Called a Hero in a Fire, a Nurse Demurs

By ALAN FEUER

HARTFORD, CT - Feb. 27-The alarm at the Greenwood Health Center sounded in the middle of the night. Marian Schumaker, the supervising nurse, saw the flashing red light on her indicator box.

She ran nearly 200 feet. Toward the flames, not away from them.

Ms. Schumaker, 60, has been hailed by officials here for having rescued patients from the flames and thick smoke of a fire that killed 10 people and injured 23 in a deadly fire at the nursing home on Wednesday. A veteran nurse who had worked as an emergency technician in Tarrytown, N.Y., she was in charge of a staff of 11: three nurses and eight nurses' aides. Through the night, they cared for 148 patients, many of whom were elderly and infirm.

"She was a hero," Deputy Fire Chief Daniel Nolan said. "She didn't want to leave."

Ms. Schumaker denies that she was a hero. She said she did what anyone would have done-and did it without much thought. "You have 10 seconds to get yourself together and ask, `What am I going to do?' " she said. "Then you have to act."

Although her recollections of what she did that night are hazy, witnesses recall her pulling patients from the fire despite burns on her hands. They recall her leading the professionals into the very heart of the blaze. "It felt like your clothes were going to melt," Ms. Schumaker said. "It was very, very scary. The smoke was in your lungs all the time-in every breath you took it was there."

Ms. Schumaker said the real hero was the first firefighter who arrived on the scene as she stood by the patients. "He said, `I'm here now. It's time for you to go,' " she said.

She did go, but only after the Police and Fire Departments had arrived. She was hospitalized for burns and smoke inhalation, but hours later, when the hospital released her, she went back to the nursing home to see whether her staff members or patients needed help. "It takes a lot to get me down," she said. "You can only cry so much. Then you have to get back to the routine."

i'm sending an e-mail to the letter to editor address at the new york daily news , where the first---oops, the second--- story in this this thread came from. that story was written by joe mahoney and tracy connor, if you want to reference it.

address is [email protected].

i'm including a request that a copy of the e-mail be forwarded to ms schumacher.

edited to include my "oops"

It appears they have about a 14 to one staff to nurse ratio in that nursing home on nights. You might think that is bad but it is not. Most places I have workedhad 20 to 1 on nights. If the lastas been staffed like most of them were staffed it would have been even worse. I already made a post about that supervisor. She really is a hero because a lot of people would not have lead so well under same circumstances. Good chance her actions inspired other staff to respond in heroic manner. They are hero's also.

It appears they have about a 14 to one staff to nurse ratio in that nursing home on nights.

The above should read: The warm body :patient ratio was 1:14; the actual nurse :patient ratio was 1:48. There were only 3 RN's on staff that night, including the nurse supervisor. The remaining eight (or nine, depending on which news article you're reading) staff members were CNA's, not RN's.

The sad part of this whole story is that the company that owns the nursing home will probably try to pin some of the blame for the fire on Ms. Schumaker, since she was the nurse supervisor on duty. :o

It seems a tragedy that such an incident has to occur for the politicals to finally listen and wake-up...

If anyone hears a follow-up on this story ;especially if Ms. Schumaker gets "blamed", please let us know.

No, it was a much worse ratio than that. There were about 12 employees there but only 3 of them were RNs - with 148 pts between them. In a blazing inferno, with just moments to act, there were only 12 people to move out 148 frail, infirm residents - some of whom were unconscious or totally dependent. The kicker is that this did meet the state's staffing requirement. When healthcare workers went on strike in that state over unsafe staffing in nursing homes last year, the only response from the state was to pass a law allowing the nursing homes to use taxpayer medicaid money to pay for scab agencies & strikebusting. If they had paid attention to the issue back then, the states staffing requirement would have been improved long ago & there might have been enough staff there that night to get the rest of those people out. Unfortunately, it is taking a tragedy like this for the state to suddenly understand that this kind of ratio is not safe. I wonder if the state can be sued for negligence now since nurses & healthcare workers have been informing it all this time that its staffing requirments were dangerous but it did nothing about it.

+ Add a Comment