Ethical Question About Pacemaker

Specialties CCU

Published

Hi all! I have an ethical/end of life question for you. I had a patient who had a pacemaker placed in the 90s as well as an AVR a couple years previous to this visit. The patient was a young patient in the 50's and just had a "bad" heart. Trouble with arrhythmias and all other sorts or problems. Well a couple of years ago they found out their new valve was dehissing. They needed surgery to replace it but he had already gone into kidney failure and bad heart failure and was refusing surgery due to unwanted more stress on their already fragile body not to mention family. So this visit they came in with shortness of breath and a DNR. Specifically no shock and no intubation. They were put on BiPAP, Levophed, epinephrine, dopamine, and Milrinone. About the third day of inpatient with the pt no longer responding to stimuli and having to keep titrating drips up and up the family decided enough was enough and that's not what the pt would want. So they decided to completely withdraw care. The pt was taken off BiPAP and was weaned down on all of the drips. I come in the next morning and come to learn that the pt is still alive. I get report from a newer nurse and something stands out to me. She is telling me the pt woke up and tearfully told their family member they was ready to go and wanted to go to heaven. The nurse said she had been pushing morphine to keep the pt comfortable etc. but then the nurse told me that his HR was PACED at 70. Well, he had an internal pacemaker/defib. My charge asked if it had been talked about if they had discussed turning off the pacemaker... Considering that was the only thing keeping them alive. When I discussed with the family, no one had brought it up before, and within 2 hours we had a dr order, the electronic company who had placed device up there, IOPO called, and the device off. The pt had no underlying rhythm and respiration a ceased immediately.

My question is, I felt incredibly uncomfortable that turning off the pacemaker was an option. I felt that considering it was a device keeping them alive, that turning it off would force them to go instead of weaning down a drip or w/e. Older nurses have compared it to pulling the patient off a ventilator... its a machine coming off when the body is no longer working.

Am I being too emotional?

tewdles, I appreciate hearing your thoughts and experience. I also appreciate you telling me about hospice. No, I didn't think you were intentionally being argumentative, and it was not my intention to be either. Thank you for taking the time to reply as thoroughly as you did, and for posting the links to the journals.

Specializes in Cardiac, Transplant, Vascular, NICU.

Thanks for all the replies!!! I really appreciate all the stories. :) Love learning this way!

OP: You keep referring to the patient as "them". Is this a subconscious referral to the entire family and their wishes?

I think it is not to give any personal information away.

you did the right thing. because that is the patient wish. according to my professor in college. never incorporate too much emotion on the things you do specially on the hospital. but be sensitive enough to their needs.

Specializes in ICU.
I agree with limaRN. I see this as no different than extubating a pt when withdrawing care. You are stopping a medical treatment/intervention that a pt no longer wants. It's not like you are smothering a pt with a pillow (in the case of extubation). In the case of stopping a pacemaker, you are not stopping the pts heart, you are stopping the device (read as treatment/intervention, that the pt expressed they do not want) that is keeping the heart going. In my mind their is a big difference. I think you did the right thing.

Extubation isn't like smothering a patient with a pillow if you do it right. If you have the patient on a nice dose for an hour on a morphine drip, it could be pretty peaceful.

you did the right thing :)

Specializes in CVICU, CCU, Heart Transplant.

In my experience it is expected that an ICD will be discontinued when supportive care is withdrawn. The physician will write an additional order to have device rep turn of ICD. The rep will NOT turn off the pacer function, even if an order is written to do so.

I would feel very emotional too. But think of this when the body stops working, care is futile and we have to think what is best for the patient, it is best for the patient to not feel any pain and be at their final resting place.

+ Add a Comment