CNA or MA?

[Girlyskull]

Hey, I'm Anna - I'm 26 and have been working in dead end jobs for a long time now, I'm currently working in retail as a Cashier/Assistant Manager and while I don't hate my job - I feel like it's just that, a job. I'm looking to make my life better and finally have what I consider a career by going to school this spring. The medical field seems like the smart thing to get into. I'm planning on attending MATC (Mountainland Applied Technology College) in American Fork because of their reputation and also because their tution is MUCH lower than what those private schools charge. I've narrowed it down to two programs that I'm trying to decide between - CNA or MA (Medical Assistant). The CNA program there takes 5 weeks (it's an EXTREMELY accelerated one) and the MA program takes about a year. I know that CNA's do far more "dirty work" than MA's - but I went and shadowed with a CNA for a few hours and I actually that despite the hard work it entails, it would be extremely rewarding and I'd enjoy it. I'd also possibly go back to school to get my LPN if CNA is the program I choose. I want to make the right choice and do my research before I spend my time and money - so I'm hoping to get some honest answers here - which one will I have an easier time finding a job in? Is it tough to find entry level jobs (no experience) in one or both? Would you recommend and is it even possible to volunteer/intern to gain experience? Is it true that many doctors offices now hire CNA's rather than MA's? What can I realistically expect to make an hour in each? I'm going to be looking to work in North Utah County or Salt Lake. Thanks in advance!

[caliotter3]

You will find it easier to obtain work if you go through the CNA program. You will be in better shape if you use the CNA program to launch into an LPN or RN program. The MA program is limiting and you may not find work at all.

[everwonder_y]

More nursing schools are requiring students to have a CNA certificate in order to even gain admittance. Pretty much you will need a CNA no matter what direction you go in, so start there.

[cbcle]

The CNA program will give you more flexibility shift-wise. For MAs, you're kind of limited to office hours which might make it harder to go back to school. Good luck!