Re: Barbaric doctor or oversensitive nurse?
Based on what I have read first off Ketamine would have been a better choice for sedation if the doctor didn't want to use two agents ie a bezodiazapine and a narcotic.
Second as far as the use of lidocaine in peds alone for an LP most generally its about 50-50 weather it is used or not. This is one of those procedures that one the patient has to be still and because of that the fewer times the patient gets poked the easier it is to complete. Even with lidocaine the patient is going to feel pressure so its hard to tell if it is that or pain the patient is feeling and causing them to move, cry and fight. Of note the more skilled the doctor the more likely that lido doesnt get used as far as what I have seen, that and I have never seen a doc wait for the drug to actually work anyway.
As well I personally cant think of a single physician I have worked with that is going to allow a parent to remain in the room while an LP is being done. Thats going back almost 20 yrs.
Rj
Nursing News