Hospital CNA vs. Dialysis Tech

[Johnnydr]

Hello All,

I am all set to start nursing school in the fall. I have worked in a group home for 2 years as a "habilitation tech" which basically is NA, med pass, dietary, and occupational/physical/speech therapy assistant work combined.

I am currently taking a CNA class because one college I am applying to requires it. During this class, I have received and accepted a dialysis PCT position for next month when class is over. It's at Fresenius which seems to have great benefits and we have a a great clinic here.

During clinicals at my hospital as a CNA student, I have been recognized by staff and my instructor made me aware of this.

My question is......as a pre-nursing student, would you specialize and get better benefits (dialysis), or try CNA in a a semi-par hospital and gain the more interdisciplinary experience before and during nursing school.

I know it's my life and ultimately up to me....both have their attractions, but I'd like some opinions at least.

Thanks much!!

[mindofmidwifery, ADN]

If you want to work in dialysis as a nurse then that's a good way to get your foot in the door. However, if not, it'd be better to work as a tech/CNA at the hospital you would like to work at as a nurse and try to get in the specific department that you want to work in.

[Johnnydr]

If you want to work in dialysis as a nurse then that's a good way to get your foot in the door. However, if not, it'd be better to work as a tech/CNA at the hospital you would like to work at as a nurse and try to get in the specific department that you want to work in.

Thanks,

I am not 100% a have a passion for renal vs. another field. It's just a good first opportunity into a clinical setting.

And then also, I'm not sure i'd want to stay in this area of the state after graduating. I may even wish to try traveling, which fresenius offers....I'm just worried about specializing and getting trapped when I still want to try other things.

[idodialysis]

I would consider the dialysis tech route. Dialysis patients have many Comorbid conditions and you would get exposure to many disease processes. You will likely get better pay and benefits as well as tuition assistance. Fresenius is a good company. I think you would benefit greatly!

[AriesRNSoon]

I agree with idodialysis , and they have the best training program!

[pixiestudent2]

I'd go for better pay and benefits personally.

And I personally think I would hate being an aide in a hospital, I worked as a tech in another healthcare setting, and had no issues getting a hospital job as a new grad.