Critical Thinking!!!!!! Whatever!! Critical Thinking!!!!!! Whatever!! - pg.2 | allnurses

Critical Thinking!!!!!! Whatever!! - page 2

Do you find yourself questioning and re-questioning rationales related to "critical thinking" questions? Yeah we all do..... I just felt like posting about this elusive "great white buffalo". I have... Read More

  1. Visit  jjjoy profile page
    #13 0
    Quote from That Guy
    "Critical thinking" is the crutch used in nursing school to say it's this answer just because.
    LOL! Sure did feel that way with some instructors!
  2. Visit  lillymom profile page
    #14 0
    Quote from jjjoy
    I'm curious what relationship you saw (if any) between how 'critical thinking' was defined and practiced in that class as opposed to the way nursing instructors used the term, especially in regard to test questions.
    I am not in nursing school yet so I can't really say. I just took the class because I thought it would be an asset for making the best decision in a timely manner. This class made us draw outlines, write short papers, and do lots and lots of research. I couldn't find any real way to apply it to anything that wasn't a personal goal. She talked a lot about persuasion and how best to get the other person to think your way. Quite annoying especially if you had a different opinion than the teacher.
  3. Visit  ImThatGuy profile page
    #15 1
    Critical thinking as a buzz phrase in nursing is stupid and demonstrates the poor quality of education in nursing.
  4. Visit  Jonathank profile page
    #16 3
    The idea of testing for critical thinking skills within nursing school test questions is a noble one. But in the real world, the actual quality of the questions from the publisher's test banks doesn't always live up to what should be minimal standards.

    [/rant]
  5. Visit  llee1279 profile page
    #17 4
    So as a nursing instructor, I can promise this isn't a great white buffalo. We look at critical thinking as your ability to look through the JUNK and find the GOLD. You'd be surprised how many students want to tell me their patient's primary nursing problem is pain (just because they are 1 day post op), when the patient is breathing 30 times a minutes and has a POX of 90% on RA. Or the biggest complication from a post op is RISK for a DVT as opposed to an actual DVT or Sepsis. Critical thinking is something you learn with some experience but it is also something we are trying teach. Teaching it isn't easy and testing/evaluating it isn't either. A big part of nursing is about anticipation, and being able to anticipate what might go wrong. You do get better with time and experience, but until then the nursing process helps you get there too.
  6. Visit  Butterfly_Light profile page
    #18 0
    I don't know why student nurses have to think critically while they're still learning and need to learn a lot. I can't think of an appropriate definition for "critical thinking". In fact, everyone can think! Putting together the word "critical" and the word "thinking" does not make any sense to the practice of nursing/healthcare. It's all about working with people and solving problems. People can't see problems if they have too little experience in a field. Expecting students to answer clinical questions based on clinical facilitators' perspectives is absurd and awkward.
  7. Visit  quiltynurse56 profile page
    #19 0
    Well, when you get to one of those many questions where two answers are correct, you need some way of determine the answer that is really the correct one. One way we developed this in school was case studies where we had to come up with all possibilities in a scenario. Then we had to figure out which one(s) were right for that scenario based on the information we were given. While you hear about it in school, you are also learning it in your case studies, labs and clinicals. Believe me, all that you get in school will come in handy when you get out there working. As was said in a PP, the easy answer many times is not the issue.
  8. Visit  la_chica_suerte85 profile page
    #20 0
    I'm curious as to what the "inherent dangers" are.
  9. Visit  PyridiumP profile page
    #21 0
    Quote from Butterfly_Light
    I don't know why student nurses have to think critically while they're still learning and need to learn a lot. I can't think of an appropriate definition for "critical thinking". In fact, everyone can think! Putting together the word "critical" and the word "thinking" does not make any sense to the practice of nursing/healthcare. It's all about working with people and solving problems. People can't see problems if they have too little experience in a field. Expecting students to answer clinical questions based on clinical facilitators' perspectives is absurd and awkward.
    I guess its because they have to learn how to think critically too? Nobody expects students to critically think the same as more experienced RN's but they should be showing that they can try to put clues together. That's what critical thinking means to me.

close