Nurse Tracking Devices: Whats Your Opinion?

Nurses Activism

Published

The hospital I work for has changed our classification to "associates" and "partners in healthcare". They are redoing our evaluations to reflect "objective criteria" for evaluations rather than the current "subjective criteria".

They have instituted a new computer charting system, which only the RN/LPN's can chart patient care and education. We must also chart all of the care given by the CNA/tech's. The system is very labor intensive to learn & use. It took me 20 minutes to chart 12 vital signs and I/0's for 6 patients; 30 minutes to do an admission on a new patient. (I could do ALL this in about 20 minutes on the paper system)

The hospital will soon be installing a "tracking system" for employees which is a device attached to your name tag that sends information to a centralized display (like "telemetry" cardiac monitors). They will be able to see where the staff is, how much time is spent in each location and who you are with (ie multiple employees are in a patients room providing care vs in the lounge)

They will be providing a "quality service satisfaction guarantee" to patients. It has not been fully explained to the staff, but it seems to be that if a patient has to wait longer than "x minutes" for anything, they will recieve a financial renumeration by the hospital.

The administrators are saying all of these changes "will improve health care delivery" by allowing "location of staff" and "quick communication patient needs to the appropriate staff member" and "monitor the documentation of care"

Two references about electronic monitoring:

http://www.graduateresearch.com/buswell.htm

http://www.light1998.com/faceit/Tracking.htm

If you work in a hospital that uses these electronic system, what is your experience with them?

MY OPINION: the potential for the employers to abuse exists when they reduce professional nursing to a "time and location study" and they "do the monday morning quarterbacking" system of evaluating your whereabouts and time your every move.

WHATS YOUR OPINION?

Interesting concept--could we use it to prove that we never get to take breaks and/or meals? Seems to me if it can be used to "catch" those who goof off, it should also be used to negotiate additional staff. Anybody who has this system ever use it for that?:)

The feeling among the most of the staff has been: "keep an eye over your shoulder, and your back to the wall"...Recently, I spoke to a former middle manager, who said our perseptions are correct and that she couldnt take the control from up above anymore, so she left.

In simple terms, the top people are "obsessive coumpulsive controlers" & the middle management's response to this control is to attempt to control the staff even more! Now with this "new system" going into effect, its as though 'BIG BROTHER' will be clocking in with you and watching your every move...waiting for you to screw up and then OUT you go!!! :eek:

Living in a dictatorship that (honestly) calls itself a dictatorship is "easier" than living in one that (dishonestly) calls itself a democracy, but exibits ultimate control at every turn...then says "you" are the one with trust issues!! :mad:

Originally posted by majic65

Interesting concept--could we use it to prove that we never get to take breaks and/or meals? Seems to me if it can be used to "catch" those who goof off, it should also be used to negotiate additional staff. Anybody who has this system ever use it for that?:)

HHMMM now that IS a very interesting concept. Maybe I just might mention that to my manager. That may be an eye opener for her :eek:

Specializes in Med/Surg, Geriatrics.

While I can appreciate the frustration encountered while trying to find a coworker or CNA to peform some duty, I feel this is not the way. A tracker sounds degrading to me. It also sounds like an invasion of privacy. I like the idea of mobile phones much better, they serve the purpose of furthering patient care without insulting the nurse or her dignity.

when my husband was a pt recently the nurses at the facility he was in carried phones. i found it very distracting to have that phone going off several times when she was going over post op instructions, doing drsg changes etc. he said it went off 5 times that morning when she was doing his assessment. what about when you just want to go in and check an iv of hang a piggy back and the pt is finally getting some much needed sleep? talk about a rude awakening!! i did not ask her if the phone had a vibrator option, sure hope so!/ :rolleyes:

+ Add a Comment