Nursing(NA/LPN/RN) vs Medical Assistant***VENT

Nurses Relations

Published

Hello all! Is anyone else annoyed by MA programs and the attitudes of Medical Assistants themselves??? I had a friend of a friend of mine, who is a medical assistant basically act like a B***h today. We were introduced to each other and she stated she was a medical assistant. She went on and on about how she could do more than most nurses could, worked directly under the doctor, yada, yada. She asked me what i did. I said "I'm an LPN." She then mentioned how she was "an equivalent of an RN in a doctor's office and MA was the next closest thing to an RN as you could get." Then this idiot had the nerve to say,"but LPN's are good too.":madface: I said "Excuse me?" and started a huge arguement. IN WHAT WORLD DOES NURSING LEVEL OF TRAINING GO RA, CNA, LPN, MA, & RN????? The only equivalent to an RN IS AN RN. LPN's are one step lower, not MA's. On top of that, I had one year of intensive training to be an LPN. This is coming from an MA who had ON THE JOB TRAINING ONLY!!!!!!!!!!!! She had no formal education whatsoever, she doesn't even have a high school diploma or GED. As an instructor of allied health training courses(EKG, Phlebotomy, NA), I am appalled at what they teach in these MA classes. She said the MA she trained under was told this in class. MA courses cost more than my LPN and they are not even required to take a course in my state. ANYONE, including people with horrible criminal backgrouds, can work if the doctor says its ok. No education needed just need to be signed off on skills. Skills such as drawing blood, EKG, injections, etc. How is that I can take a year of med administration class, pharm, anatomy, etc but I am not qualified according to BON to do veinapunctures, but some yahoo without any GED, education, or formal training can do it after being watched as little as one time????? This should not be legal. I think all MA's should be regulated and required to have certain hours of training, or eliminate all MA positions. A CNA or an LPN can do the same things in my state with the PROPER, DOCUMENTED additional training. Long rant but set me on edge like nothing else. I just looked at her and walked away.:mad:

PS. Not looking down on CNA's, LPN's, RN's, people with backgrounds, people with no Diplomas or GEDS. You have what you have. I was the 1st person EVER in my family to graduate high school. Everyone's life situations are different . Just saying that certain positions with life or death consequences should have a certain level of education and training.

I want to put this out there right now because I am a CMA. stop with this bull ****. We as MA are right hand man of the DR. We have so many similarties and I will tell you now. I am a CMA and I make as much as an LPN so to hear that LPNs make more than MA's you are sadly mistaken it depends on the situation. WE may not be "nurses" we are a different enity. WE also get weekends holiday and work a reg schedule. The difference is nurses are licensed an an medical assistant is not but I tell you what we work damn hard and we do a lot of similar jobs that Nurses do. I love nurses and they are very vital to the medical field and so is MA so stop with the bull **** about how nurses are better than mas we are not even in the same inity. WE do our own thing by being the Doctors right hand man. but don't ever think that MA are not vital because in outpatient care we are. and personally I love being an MA

This has to stop this whole tearing people down for what they are. We are all making a difference. So stop that crap and dont put of here that LPN make more than ma's because that is not nessassarily true> money should not even come up. Like i said i am a certified medical assistant case mananger and i make what an LPN makes in a dr office i work awesome hrs with paid hoildays and my weekends. I love my job . If you love what you do nothing else matters and what other said should not bother you... But bringing money up is def not something to use because we are all at different levels... Just saying..

We do work hard we do alot in a dr office & nurses do a lot in a hospital. The main thing we are both very important to the medical field stop dowingin someone for what they are and start working together to make our patients which is our focus healthier and better!!!!

I plan to go back to school to become a nurse to better my self but I love my job and would not trade it

On 5/11/2011 at 7:34 AM, Mudder said:

it really irks me when I hear a MA say "I'm Dr so&so's nurse" NO, you are not his NURSE. Yes, he lets you do everything I do but that still doesn't make you a nurse. I have a license, you do not. I do everything a RN does too but that doesn't make me an RN!

Amen to that. I work as a temp nurse for a psych clinic. It was irking me because a CMA was telling me that she and I were the same because we did the same things in the office and nurses who believed otherwise were holding on to "old ideas." In the area of the country where I live many clinics are not employing nurses at all... only CMAs. As an RN this practice does not sit well with me.

Specializes in Home Health (PDN), Camp Nursing.

I haven’t seen anyone in this thread call MAs lazy or deny that they task. I haven’t seen anyone say that MAs shouldn’t exist or don’t have their place. The fact of the matter is you SHOULD be proud to be an MA. You worked hard for that certification, you specialize in primary care and clinical specialty offices, that’s a very hard area to work in. So own that. MA’s will never get the professional recognition they deserve if they don’t claim their name. Every time a doctor calls an MA a nurse or a parent is allowed to understand the MA as a nurse it is a disservice to the MA and Nursing profession. MA’s are sabotaging themselves and creating bad will by not taking a firm stand.

+ Add a Comment